“Shadow Milk Cookie now has DID.” No, he does not. Assuming such harms real life systems.
— Opinion of someone who has an INTENSE interest in Disassociate Identity Disorder.
I am in no way a professional, however I have done years of research on DID with different sources ranging from online websites to physical books and talking to systems.
Diagnosed systems are allowed to correct me or disagree.
What happened in the CRK storyline? — After absorbing the Ultimate Cookie and the SoulJams of the other Beasts, we see a scene where Shadow Milk Cookie “switches” between mindsets of said Beasts and presumably Ultimate Cookie.
Which characteristics could apply to DID? — The before-mentioned switches could be something that made people think that this may be DID, especially the part where SMC argues with the other ‘personality.’ Whether the souls of the beasts still live on inside Shadow Milk’s mind or if part of their energies simply have an impact on his mentality is yet unclear.
Why is it not DID? — Devsis absolutely did not have the intention of writing a character with such a misunderstood disorder. Aside from this obvious fact;
1) the switches occur very quickly, something that is only a thing in fictional media written by singlets that do not comprehend that switches involve disassociation. While this was a stress situation for Shadow Milk Cookie that might have lead to switches, this is very extreme and fast. It is a possibility that they may be talking in their minds, which is possible in co-fronting, however I am uncertain about that actually happening, as he is speaking out loud.
2) DID does not get developed in such a way. While it may be a fun headcanon to you, labeling him as a system may make people forget about the roots of the true development of DID: It gets formed during childhood if the person grows up in a traumatic environment where they can only cope by disassociating during stress, usually due to abuse. Labeling SMC’s identity crisis as DID disregards the traumatic experiences of real systems—in my opinion. Systems are allowed to disagree.
Why is this assumption harmful? — This assumption only fuels the bad reputation that DID and OSDD already have. That they are crazy!!! And that, oh, all alters are evil personalities!!! “Oh get out of my head get out of my head!!!” type shit.
I apologize if I’m being too woke, but fuck, let’s not make DID another fandom trope the same way that people are labeling Yanderes as characters with BPD.