Somebody Else (Sodapop Curtis x Reader Part 3)
Part 2 - Please read first
When Steve shows up at her window unexpectedly, Y/N can no longer run away from the decision she has to make.
Warnings: mentions of smut, angst
Authors Note: Hey all, sorry this took so long, I’m on vacation this week and it’s been hard to find time to write, but I had a sudden burst of inspiration tonight and managed to finish it. This story is not over yet though, stay tuned for the next couple parts which will hopefully be posted in the next few days. Thank you for all the love on this story <3 I really truly appreciate it so much. Enjoy!
Y/N wakes up to an abrupt loud noise. She sits up, catching her breath.
“Oh, sorry, Y/N, I didn’t mean to wake you. I’m real dumb- I dropped the pan while I was trying to get it out of the cabnit to make breakfast.” Ponyboy explains. He’s standing in the kitchen, flustered, and alone.
“It’s cool,” she tries to rub the sleep out of her eyes. “Where is everyone?” she asks.
“Sodapop was gone when I woke up, Darry left work a little while ago.” he explains.
“But Sodapop doesn’t work on Saturdays, so he didn’t leave a note or anything? Where could he have gone?” Y/N feels a sick feeling rising in her stomach, hangover, and dread. Had Sodapop remembered what he said last night? Was he trying to avoid Y/N by sneaking off before she woke up? Did he no longer mean it?
“No clue, maybe he decided to meet up with Steve or something.” he suggested, though Y/N found this very unlikely. And then it hit her- Oh god, she needed to talk to Steve. But what could she say? How could she justify abandoning him at a party? And with Sodapop, no less. Of course, she could always leave that part out...she could say she felt sick, or-
“Y/N?” Ponyboy interrupted her thoughts. “You alright?” he asks.
“Oh, yeah, sorry- I just- have a lot on my mind, is all.” she reasons.
“Well, are you hungry at all?” Pony offers.
The thought of eating made Y/N’s stomach turn, so she declined. “I actually should be getting home, my mom will start to wonder.” she started to gather her stuff. “Thanks though, and tell Darry thanks for letting me crash. See you around, kid.” she waves goodbye, and is out the door swiftly.
That night, Y/N lies in bed, contemplating the events of the past week. How could everything have changed so suddenly? She probably would have drove herself mad, had she not been interrupted by a few knocks on her window.
Y/N sat up quickly, turning to the window to see Steve. She thought back to all the times she had crawled out that same window to go see him and Soda. Those nights were always the most fun, the ones where she hadn’t told her mom she had left. The thrill of doing something she wasn’t supposed to. It wasn’t like they ever got in real trouble, often opting to grab a few coca-cola's at the local 24-Hour diner. Sometimes they would just sit at the lot and talk. Occasionally Steve would try to convince the group to meet up with Dallas and go to a party, usually at Buck’s, but Soda always declined. And Y/N tried to split her time between them evenly when this happened. Saying she would meet up with Steve at the party, just a little later. That time she spent with Soda, that must have been when she fell in love with him. No one except them knowing where they were, what they were doing, it was quietly and peacefully intimate.
Tonight, Sodapop wasn’t with him. Y/N was opening the window and inviting him in, not climbing out to join them.
“Steve? What are you doing here?” Y/N asked.
“I needed to see you. After you left last night, I couldn’t stop thinking about you.” he responds.
“About that- Steve I’m so sorry-” she starts.
“It’s okay, Y/N, I’m not upset. I just wanted to talk to you. Can I come in?”
Suddenly realizing he was still outside, Y/N agreed, quickly moving out of the way so he could climb inside. Realizing she was only wearing a tiny tank top, no bra, and shorts, she shuffled across the room to throw on a sweatshirt. By the time she was done, she turned around to see Steve sitting on her bed, cross legged, fiddling with his thumbs. Y/N sat beside him.
He sighed, “Are you okay with all this? Am I moving too fast?” Steve turns towards her, looking at her with concern in his eyes.
“No, Steve, you aren’t doing anything wrong. Everything has been going perfect.” she replies.
“Okay, so, be honest with me, Y/N, is there something holding you back from wanting to make this official?”
She looks away, a lump forming in her throat. Suddenly, she's lost for words.
“It’s Sodapop? Isn’t it?” he asks, defeated.
Y/N isn’t sure what to do, does she deny? Pretend that she's okay, that he’s not on her mind? Or is she honest with Steve, and risk her relationship with him? Let alone their friendship. She thinks for too long, and Steve is already saying something else.
“I- I get it Y/N, I know he’s the one the girls fall in love with. I’m not blind, I have eyes. I know how I look compared to him. I’ve seen the way you look at him. I guess I really was a fool for thinking you could have looked at me like that, too, huh?” he rubs his eyes, and Y/N is sure he’s fighting back tears.
“No.” she says. Y/N grabs his face and holds it between her hands. “Look at me, Steve.” she begs.
She doesn’t give him much of a choice, so he makes eye contact with her.
“You’re wrong. You’re not second best. You’re not my second choice. I like you, Steve, a lot.” She tries to convince him.
“Why did you leave with him, Y/N?” the hurt in his voice can no longer be concealed.
Y/N softens her expression. She looks everywhere except at him.
“I just took him home because he was drunk and wasn’t making any sense and I was worried he would get in trouble- I- you know how he is, he never drinks, and I didn’t want anything to happen to him.” she explains.
“That’s all it was? Truly?” he asks.
“Yes, Steve, that’s it.” she replies.
“And you’re telling me you’ve never thought about him like that?” his posture is defensive, standoffish even.
“I guess, technically, I did have a thing for him at one point. But that was then and this is now, you’re the one sitting in my bedroom right now. You’re the one who gets to take me to parties, and the movies, and hold my hand, and kiss me.” At this point, she isn’t sure who she is trying to convince. Either way, Steve seems satisfied.
He smirks, “Wanna test that theory?” and leans in for a kiss. And another, and soon enough they are making out.
He trails his kisses down her jawline, and neck, and Y/N finds herself feeling frigid. But Steve is kind, and funny, and willing to lay it all out on the line for her, something Soda could only due drunk.
Steve slowly creeps his hand under her sweatshirt, noting the lack of a bra. She doesn’t stop him.
The longer they remain kissing, the more aware Y/N becomes that all she can hear is Soda confessing his love for her. She needs to make that stop, she needs to get him out of her mind.
And when Steve reaches into her shorts, she doesn’t stop him.
Another week goes by, and Y/N sits in bed, alone this time. She’s reading a book she just recently picked up from the used book store, a ten minute walk from her house. The landline phone she has in her room rings, and she instinctively reaches for it without hesitation.
“Hello?” she waits for a reply.
“Y/N!” a cheerful voice comes through on the other line.
“Sodapop?” she hadn’t been expecting to hear from him, she didn’t know if he would ever talk to her again after their last conversation.
“Hey- how have you been? I haven’t seen you in days.” his voice shakes.
“I wasn’t sure that you wanted to see me.” she replies.
“Well, I do. Can you stop by in say...half an hour? An hour maybe?”
Y/N glimpses at her alarm clock, signaling it was half past ten. She had slept in more than usual, but it was a Saturday, and she didn’t have anywhere to be.
“Yeah, okay. I’ll see you soon.” they exchange polite goodbyes, before hanging up.
Nerves pulse through her as she gets ready. What could he possibly have to say to me? Does he even remember our last conversation? Oh god- I told him I would always love him. Maybe he forgot about that part...he was pretty wasted. How could he have been so casual on the phone otherwise? But why ignore me for a week then?
Nothing seems to add up, but she decides that she is just getting in her head about it, and she makes every attempt to treat this like she would any other day, or any other hang out.
When she arrives at his doorstep, she knocks lightly, and the door is opened almost instantly after.
“Y/N! It is so good to see you.” Sodapop pulls her into a hug, and she hates the electricity she still feels from his touch. Once he finally lets her go he says, “Come in,”
They are the only ones home, from the looks of it. Y/N wonders if he planned that.
“I haven’t heard from you in ages,” she tells him as they both take a seat in the living room. Y/N sits on the side of the couch that faces Sodapop in the arm chair that Darry typically claims. She is acutely aware that she is seated in the same spot she was the last time she was here, the night everything changed. I wonder if Soda realizes, too.
“I guess I didn’t know what to say.” he stares down at his hands, which are resting in his lap.
“So, you remember that night?” Y/N asks, suddenly feeling her heartbeat quicken intensely.s
“I remember parts, it’s all a little fuzzy. But I think I’ve been able to piece most of it together. And I was hoping you could help me fill in the rest.”
Y/N feels dizzy with anxiety, what does he remember? What do I admit to? What should I deny?
He takes a long, deep breath, his nerves quite apparent. “We can’t avoid it forever, so I might as well just come out and say it. I told you I loved you.” his cheeks heat up in a way Y/N almost never seems them. Sodapop has always been the cool, smooth talking guy. He flirts with every pretty girl he meets, never striking out, always knowing what to say.
Y/N feels relieved that he hasn’t said anything about her saying it back, yet.
“Yeah…” her voice trails off.
“I’m so sorry Y/N, I know I’ve probably ruined everything. And I didn’t want you to-” he starts.
“It’s okay, you were drunk, Soda, you weren’t in your head, it’s alright that you didn’t mean it. People say stupid stuff all the time when they’re drunk. Like that time I told Dallas if he wanted-”
“I didn’t want you to find out that way.” he interrupts, to finish his prior sentence.
Y/N swears her heart stops. The world doesn’t just stop spinning, everything is frozen. This isn’t like last time, now, he knows what he’s saying. She can’t deny that he means what he’s saying anymore.
“You didn’t want me to find out you loved me? Or that you love me?” she hears her heartbeat in her ears as she waits for a reply. The mere seconds between her question and his reply feel like hours.
“Did you mean it?” he asks, not answering her previous question.
“Mean what?” she asks, too overwhelmed to bother protesting about him avoiding her question.
“You told me, always. That you’d love me, always.”
“I could never not love you, Soda, you’re my best friend.” she argues..
“And that's it? You love me like a best friend, always?” he sounds frustrated, especially when he emphasizes the last word.
“I slept with Steve.” she spits out. Her head hurts, her pulse so loud and pounding in her head, and she feels as if she could pass out. She isn’t sure why she said it. All she can come up with is that she couldn’t let Sodapop love her, when if he knew what she did he would hate her. He deserved more than that.
He deserves more than me. She tells herself.
Silence takes over the room, and Y/N feels very out of place. Silence had always been a comfortable concept between Soda and her. They had always felt so comfortable in the others presence that they could go hours together without saying anything. But now, the silence is deafening.
“When?” is all he says. He mumbles it weakly, like hes already given up. He avoids making eye contact with her.
“Saturday night, he came to my window and- I wasn’t expecting him at all. But then we started talking about what we were and where we were going, and I guess one thing lead to another.” Her cheeks heat up. “I- I guess it was my messed up way of a distraction.”
He places his head in his hands, rubbing at his eyes, which are now turning red and puffy. Even with his eyes swollen and skin red from fighting tears, he still manages to be the most handsome boy shes ever laid eyes on.
“The night after I told you I loved you?” his voice breaks, and so does Y/N’s heart.
She feels a tear roll down her cheek, and she realizes she has no right to cry, so she quickly wipes it away. “He asked me to be his girlfriend.”
“You know,” he says. “when you told me always, it sounded like the prettiest, most beautiful word in the world. Now it just feels like one big lie.”
By now she can’t prevent the tears from falling, so she lets them, a tiny sob leaving her body when she realizes he’s crying too.
“I didn’t lie.” she tells him.
“Then why are you with him?”
“Because I couldn’t have you.”