The Fallout: A Brallie Fanfic (pt. 2)
“Hey,” Callie sighs, leaving Jamie a third voicemail. “Sorry to keep calling you. Are you on your way? Quinn’s family night event starts in fifteen minutes.”
She’s pacing in front of Quinn’s childcare, smiling tightly at the other families and passersby.
She feels ridiculous as she ends the call, tucking her phone into her purse. The San Diego sun feels particularly hot today. She can feel sweat beading at the nape of her neck.
She’s in a pale blue sundress, and she’s afraid if she sweats more, it will become noticeable.
Brandon has already taken Quinn inside to play with the other children before the event starts.
Tucking her phone into her purse, she’s not quite sure how she actually feels. Two simultaneous thoughts intertwine in her mind. She doesn’t particularly care if Jamie attends the event. It’s easier if he doesn’t, she thinks.
But she’s also frustrated that she told him about this event last week, and then at the beginning of this week, and again last night. This morning too.
She enters the childcare and feels the refreshing breeze of air conditioning. There are teachers everywhere greeting families and hugging children.
She sees Brandon chatting with a teacher, Quinn perched happily on his shoulders, sing-songing Dada.
Callie’s heart stutters in her chest at the sight. The beauty of it. Of her baby.
She can see Quinn’s deep, expressive eyes – a soft gray-green that shifts with the light. Her lashes are long and thick, fluttering curiously at the world.
Brandon often tells Callie that Quinn looks like her. Her small, heart-shaped face and brown curls – not quite as dark as Callie’s rich, chocolate locks, but with a hint that suggests her hair will darken as she grows.
Brandon turns his body slightly, and Callie watches as the light catches on Quinn, making her wide smile brighter.
She loves everything about the little girl. Her thoughtfulness, and inquisitive personality. her quiet concentration that mirrors Brandon’s focus, and her stubborn streak that Callie recognizes all too well.
Callie walks towards them slowly, continuing to admire them.
From the periphery of his vision, Brandon sees Callie approaching. Continuing his conversation with a teacher, she watches Brandon use one hand to hold Quinn securely in place, outstretching his other to Callie – beckoning her into his embrace.
She fits against his side, making the picture of a happy family. It’s an affectionate gesture. Subtle enough that it isn’t strange.
Brothers hug sisters. Uncles carry their nieces.
Callie likes the way it feels to fit against Bradon’s side — the kind of closeness that’s never had to be forced. His arm remains around her waist, hand resting lightly against her hip.
She slides her hand up the center of his back, brushing just beneath the collar of his shirt in a gesture so casual it might be missed by everyone else. But not by Jamie.
Because at that moment, he walks in.
He hesitates in the doorway, caught in the cheerful chaos of Family Night: toddlers darting between legs, teachers laughing, parents balancing juice boxes and phones. It takes him a moment to find them — his family — and when he does, the breath leaves his body like someone’s pressed a fist to his chest.
Callie’s head is tilted back, laughing softly at something Brandon just whispered. Quinn is still perched on Brandon’s shoulders, arms draped comfortably across his forehead like it’s her favorite place in the world. And maybe it is.
Jamie stands frozen, his messenger bag slung awkwardly over one shoulder. He realizes too late that he’s overdressed — blazer and slacks in a sea of sundresses and dad jeans. It’s not the clothes, though. It’s everything.
He watches for a moment longer, unnoticed. Callie’s hand moves gently to Quinn’s ankle, a reflexive touch. And Quinn holds out her arms in a gesture to be held.
Brandon shifts his weight, so Callie can reach her. Pulling Quinn into her arms and kissing her little cheek.
Brandon says something to Quinn, who giggles and calls out again, clear and proud: “Dada!”
Callie and Brandon both freeze for just a beat.
They don’t look at each other, but it’s clear they’ve heard it. Heard it again. And they don’t correct her. Not this time.
Jamie steps forward, clearing his throat, “Sorry I’m late.”
Brandon’s eyes flick up first. Calm. Controlled.
“Hey,” his voice is friendly. Practiced, “You’re just in time,” Brandon looks at his phone. It reads five-twenty-eight.
Callie turns more slowly, the warmth draining from her face as she spots Jamie standing merely feet away.
Too softly at first, “Hey. You made it.”
She detaches herself from Brandon, almost imperceptibly. A small step, but Jamie notices. The space between them widens — visibly, deliberately — but the image of them lingers in Jamie’s mind like a photograph burned into the back of his eyes.
“Did I miss much?” he asks casually.
Callie shakes her head, her own dark curls fluttering against her face, “Not yet. They’re about to start.”
“We should find our seats,” Brandon suggests.
“Great,” his voice is even. He doesn’t move to kiss Callie. Doesn’t make a move to hold Quinn who is snuggled against her mother, small fingers holding onto Callie’s necklace.
He stands. Watching. Observing the room and observing them.
The voice of the childcare director cuts through the tension, “Families, thank you for joining us. If you’ll find your seats, we’ll start our program.”
Brandon reaches out, rubs Quinn’s back.
Jamie’s jaw twitches. He swallows.
All three adults make alternating eye contact with one another, but no one corrects Quinn.
Instead, Brandon leans forward and kisses her forehead.
The proximity to Callie that this simple gesture brings makes Jamie clench his fist.
Brandon steps back just enough, giving space, giving air. Following the crowd of other families into a room with rows of chairs.
Jamie watches the whole exchange in silence.
Callie falls into step beside Jamie.
“She really loves him,” he says slowly. Waiting for a revelation.
“Mmhmm,” Callie agrees, gently bouncing Quinn in her arms. “She does.”
He doesn’t ask what that means. Doesn’t say what he’s thinking.
But Callie feels it – the accusation, the resignation, the ache. She doesn’t meet his eyes as she moves towards her seat. Sandwiching herself between Brandon and Jamie.
The sun has already dipped below the horizon by the time they exit the building, leaving streaks of violet and orange across the sky.
Callie is crouched at the back seat of the car, securing Quinn into her car seat. She’s already falling asleep, clinging to a small blanket.
Brandon stands a few feet away, watching with quiet tenderness.
Jamie lingers for only a second before entering the driver’s side door. Sitting. Waiting for Callie to finish.
“Okay, baby,” Callie whispers to her sleepy daughter, “We’ll be home soon.”
She fastens the last buckle, listening to Quinn babble something indecipherable, thumb tucked into her mouth, her eyes already beginning to flutter closed.
Callie stands, stepping out of the way so that Brandon can quickly kiss Quinn goodbye.
He closes the door softly and turns to Callie.
“Thank you for coming tonight,” she tilts her head to the side. “For always showing up,” she says this part quietly.
“You know there’s nowhere I’d rather be,” his eyes flicker briefly to the side of the car where Jamie disappeared. Then, back to Callie.
“Drive safe,” her voice is soft, wobbly even.
Brandon nods. He doesn’t reach out to hug her, but he does reach for her hand.
The touch is intimate, hidden from Jamie’s line of sight. He squeezes her hand before letting go and walking away.
Callie stands, watching until he’s at his car. She turns to her own door, opening it and sliding into her seat.
Jamie waits until he hears the click of her seatbelt before pulling away from the curb.
His hands are tight on the wheel. The hum of the engine and the rustle of Quinn’s sleep-soft breathing fill the silence.
Callie stares out the window, one hand propped up to cradle her chin in her hand.
Jamie’s voice is even, “He didn’t even flinch when she called him Dada.”
“Sorta like he’s been waiting to hear it,” it’s close to an accusation.
At this, Callie’s cheeks flush. Not with embarrassment. Moreso anger. But she’s not sure if it’s anger at Jamie or the situation they are in, “She has been saying it. For weeks. You’re just never around to hear it.” The air thickens with implication.
The words leave her mouth sharper than intended.
Jamie lets out a low, humorless laugh, “You say that like it’s not a choice I made for all of us,” his voice rises a bit. “Because someone has to keep things together,” another accusation.
“Keep your voice down,” Callie hisses, turning to make sure Quinn is still sleeping. “I didn’t ask you to keep things together. I asked you to show up.”
It feels like a slap, because he knows it’s both true and untrue.
“Did you?” he asks rhetorically. “Really, Callie?”
Callie’s jaw goes slack, her mouth hanging open, “What’s that supposed to mean?”
“It means that every late night. Every missed dinner, and every skipped event – that is what has made space for you and Brandon to become whatever it is you are now. You don’t get to resent me for being gone when it’s the only reason you get to have him.”
Callie blinks. Unable to speak.
His voice is calm, but there’s hurt underneath. Unmistakable pain.
“I never asked for that,” she says.
His hands are fixed at ten and two on the steering wheel. Dark streets roll past.
“You didn’t have to. It’s what you chose – every time you let him pick her up from childcare, or put her to bed, or sit next to you like he belongs there.”
Neither speak for several minutes.
Callie stares ahead, her expression unreadable. Hands now knotted together in her lap. Then, so quietly, “He does belong. With her.”
Jamie swerves to the shoulder, putting the car in park.
She doesn’t answer right away. The silence loud and devastating.
“She loves him so much. You…you were always trying to build something with me. A version of life you thought I needed,” she’s crying now. The emotion of it all consuming.
“You said you wanted stability. A future. A family.”
“I…I did,” her tears are almost sobs, but she holds them back, not wanting to disturb Quinn.
The house is dim and cool. The hallway lit only by the dull glow of Quinn’s nightlight.
Callie tucks a blanket around her little body, brushing the curls away from her forehead.
“Good night, my baby. Mama loves you,” she presses a kiss to Quinn’s cheek, still chubby with babyhood. She lingers longer than usual, just looking at her.
She slowly leaves the room, closing the door with a soft click.
She walks into the living room like she’s forgotten how her body moves. Her sundress clings slightly to the back of her legs with the sweat of a long evening. Her arms hang limply by her sides.
The house feels empty. Despite Jamie’s presence in their bedroom.
Callie sinks into the sofa and curls her knees to her chest, bare feet tucked beneath her. She can see the faint outline of her reflection in the blank screen of the television.
She reaches for her purse on the floor and fumbles with the zipper for a moment before reaching inside to take out her phone.
Without thinking about the time, or the implications, she calls Brandon.
He answers on the second ring.
He’s in the study reading, so as not to wake Eliza – who was already in bed by the time he got home.
“Hi,” he says. There’s silence on the other end of the line for a second, just the faint sound of breathing.
Brandon’s voice goes low, concerned, “What happened?”
“I think he knows everything,” she doesn’t clarify.
Brandon knows, but he asks anyway, “Knows what exactly?”
“That Quinn loves you. That I love you,” her voice cracks around the words, just enough to betray the weight of everything.
“Come here. Please. Just come here. Both of you.”
Despite the gravity of the situation, she smiles. She would love nothing more than to scoop Quinn into her arms and run to Brandon.
She shakes her head, silent tears escaping her eyes, “You know I can’t. Not right now.”
“Okay,” he concedes easily. “I’ve got you. I’m right here.”
She lets out a breath she doesn’t realize she’s holding, “I think he’s always known. He said he’s never here because he knows I prefer you. He’s not wrong, Brandon.”
She hears Brandon swallow thickly on the other end of the line.
“I know, but I don’t want you to carry this alone.”
She exhales a long, slow breath, “I don’t want to hurt him. I hated seeing the shattered look in his eye today.”
“I get it,” he thinks about Eliza.
The whole family buzzes with excited energy beneath the grand archways of the San Diego Symphony. The lobby hums with evening chatter, polished shoes tapping against the marble floors. Velvet programs are folded neatly into people’s hands.
Callie stands near the glass entryway, watching her daughter toddle between family members. Mariana is knelt down in front of her, complimenting the little girl on her cream-colored dress, dusted with little gold stars.
“I’m so proud of Brandon,” Lena says admiringly, holding a flute of champagne. “I still can’t believe his composition was selected.”
Stef leans into her wife with a nostalgic smile, “Our first baby. All grown up and writing full symphonies. Conducting a national debut.”
Callie smiles. It’s genuine, but it aches a little.
Things are still tense with Jamie. They probably always will be. But he’s there – making conversation with Jude and Mariana, carrying Quinn’s diaper bag slung over one should like an accessory he isn’t sure he’s allowed to put down.
He was holding Quinn earlier, her expressive eyes scanning his face like she couldn’t quite figure out who he was but implicitly understanding that she should. Like a nearly forgotten dream. She had not cried, but she had not reached for him either.
She’s in Jesus’s embrace now, mid-giggle as he tosses her gently in the air, catching her on the descent with exaggerated flair. The sound of her laughter cuts through the noise of the lobby and lands directly in Callie’s heart. Her tinkling laughter filling Calling up.
When fifteen minutes remain before the start of the performance, Callie steps forward and reaches out for Quinn. Scooping the little girl into her arms and nuzzling her nose against the soft curls above her ear.
“Come to Mama, my sweet baby,” she says. She turns to the group, telling everyone, “I’m going to change her before we find our seats inside.”
Without speaking, Jamie hands her the diaper bag. Their fingers brush, and for a split second, she sees something flicker behind his eyes. She smiles appreciatively at him and is surprised to see his effort to return the gesture. A small, forced smile.
Inside the elegant, the sound of rushing water from one of the marble sinks echoes gently through the space.
Callie hears the water stop, the door open and close, leaving her and Quinn alone.
She lays Quinn down on the changing table, humming softly. Quinn babbles and chats in her two and three word phrases as Callie changes her.
After a fresh diaper is secured, she lifts her up and leaves the stall, heading to the closest sink. She balances Quinn on her hip to help he wash her little hands.
The water runs cool and clear between her finger, tiny palms splashing enthusiastically.
“Are you ready to hear Dada conduct his music now that you have a clean diaper,” Callie coos playfully to Quinn, dabbing at the water droplets she’s splashed onto her chin.
Quinn continues to splash, “See Dada?” it sounds like a genuine question as she turns her head towards the door.
“That’s right,” Callie smiles. “It’s going to be loud, though,” she warns teasingly. “But don’t worry. Mama brought headphones for you.”
She makes a funny face in the mirror, and Quinn giggles, delight bubbling out of her.
That’s when Callie hears it – the metallic whose of a flushing toilet in a stall behind them.
She thought they were alone in the bathroom.
Her body stills and the color drains from her face when she sees Eliza exit the stall.
She exits slowly, not startled, and walks to the sink beside them. Callie’s heart climbs into her throat.
For a moment, no one speaks. She can feel the tension, but she does her best to remain composed. Fully intending to pretend everything is normal. She dries Quinn’s hands and straightens her dress.
She brings Quinn close to her chest and kisses her temple. Smiles like everything is fine.
“Hi, Mama,” Quinn responds, making Callie release a breathy laugh.
“Hi, baby. Say hi to Aunt Eliza too?”
She turns her body slightly towards Eliza so Quinn can see who she’s referring to.
She watches Eliza lick her lips. Their eyes meet.
Quietly, she asks, “Does Jamie know that she calls Brandon Dada?”
Callie stiffens. Her mouth suddenly dry.
“Uh yeah,” she says too lightly, feigning nonchalance with a purposeful lilt to her voice. “He does. It’s cute,” she tries to make it sound normal, “she’s so little, and she loves Brandon so much. I’m sure it won’t be forever.”
Eliza nods, turning on the faucet. “Right…of course. I just wasn’t sure how Jamie felt about it.”
Their eyes meet in the mirror. Eliza’s gaze even. Steady.
“It’s sweet how close they are,” Eliza chooses her words carefully, smiling in a way that doesn’t quite reach her eyes. “She looks a lot like you,” she pauses for a beat. Then, delicately, “but there’s something about her smile, her eyes. Something familiar.”
Callie’s pulse flutters. She shifts Quinn on her hip, pressing her cheek to her daughter’s hair.
Eliza doesn’t say anything else. Just leaves the space open. A quiet knowing without declaration. Before she leaves the bathroom, she glances at Quinn again. Her face softens, not with affection, exactly, but with a kind of aching awareness.
Only when Eliza is gone, the door closed, does Callie exhale.
She knows they shouldn’t be back there. She’s surprised no one stopped her, but something about tonight – the conversation with Eliza and the swirl of things left unsaid – makes her feel like she needs to see him. Just once more before the lights go down.
Backstage hums with energy. A rare kind of anticipation that only comes before art meets audience. Hushed voices. Tense smiles. Musicians tuning, adjusting sleeves. Waiting. The buzz from the crowd beyond the velvet curtain is a distant rumble, rising and falling against the hush.
Callie approaches Brandon, standing in a pocket of light near the wing. His head is bowed as he checks the arrangement again, his fingers tapping against the music stand. He straightens his collar and rolls his shoulders.
She thinks it looks like he’s trying to shake off the weight of expectations.
Otherwise, he looks calm. Confident. Handsom. But she knows the truth in the quiet tremor of his fingers. The way he bites the inside of his cheek.
The intimacy of knowing him so well makes her yearn for him. She wants to reach out for him, but she doesn’t.
Instead, she steps a little closer. Her voice soft as the shadows around them, “Hey.”
Brandon turns to see Callie and Quinn. His face visibly brightens. And she blushes like they are teenagers again at seeing his reaction to her presence.
He exhales through his nose, “As I’ll ever be.”
Callie brushes her fingers lightly against his forearm, “You’re going to be brilliant. I mean it. I’m so proud of you.”
He searches her eyes and sees the reassurance and belief in him that she offers so freely.
He leans in and kisses her gently on the lips. Unhurried in the secrecy of their space backstage. He only pulls away when he hears Quinn’s sweet, small, “Dada.”
“Hey, my girl! Look at you,” he takes Quinn into his arms, tapping her headphones. “How’d you get so cute? Like being backstage with all the cool kids, huh?” he asks her.
Callie doesn’t tell him what Eliza overheard in the bathroom. Eliza will probably tell him this evening, in the privacy of their home.
Callie bites her lower lip, thinking that Eliza’s words revealed how close she is to the truth. That the moment they’ve been delaying for two years may be closer than ever.
She doesn’t say any of this. Not tonight. Tonight is his.
“Break a leg,” she wraps her arm around his neck, her voice tender.
They kiss once more. Brief. Electric.
“Tonight’s for you. Both of you,” he murmurs.
“For us,” Callie says, referencing all three of them in the singular word.
She takes Quinn back into her arms, giving Brandon one last look before he’s gone, disappearing into the state light and the swell of the waiting orchestra.
She bounces Quinn, “Let’s go watch Dada.”
“Why was Callie crying?” her question floats into the space of their bedroom hours after the performance has ended. Their home now. Brandon showered, teeth brushed, and pajamas on, is already in bed. He’s curled beleath the comforter in the low lamplight of their bedroom.
His body aches pleasantly with exhaustion and pride. Everything has gone better than he could have imagined. The standing ovation playing over and over in his mind, echoing throughout his bones.
He turns his head slightly to look at Eliza. She’s seated at the vanity across the room, patting moisturizer gently into her cheeks. Her reflection meets his in the mirror.
“I guess she liked it,” he shrugs. “She wasn’t the only one crying,” he adds, hoping the night will make the question dissolve.
“Yeah,” Eliza agrees. She’s still peering at him through the mirror, though her fingers now move more slowly in circular motion over her skin. “But…she seemed particularly moved. Like she felt it differently than the rest of us.”
Brandon offers a soft chuckle, trying to keep his voice light. “She knows how much music means to me. She’s been around long enough to see how far I’ve come. Before conservatories and deadlines and commissions.”
He says it all so plainly, so reasonably, that it’s almost believable. A logical explanation that isn’t quite a lie. Not exactly. But not the whole truth either.
Not that the piece was born the moment Callie placed his hand on her stomach and whispered that she was pregnant.
Not the truth that the chord progression mimics the rhythm of Quinn’s earliest heartbeat on the monitor. Not that every measure was written for the two people he loves most in the world.
Eliza closes the small glass jar and rises from the vanity. She walks over to join him in bed. She looks pretty, Brandon things. Her long, red hair falls in waves around her freckled shoulders. The pale, baby pink of her nightgown catches in the lamplight and is almost the same shade as her skin.
She smells like lavender, and he can feel the warmth of her body as she slides beneath the blankets. For a moment, there is only the rustling of fabric as they both settle onto their respective pillows.
She turns to face him. He’s laying on his back, looking up at the ceiling, “Have you ever written something for Callie?”
His heart skips a beat. He could lie. He considers it. It wouldn’t be the first time. In many ways, his life seems to be crafted of small, curated lies. Careful things that are meant to patch up the cracks between his two lives. Gentle evasions meant to hold his marriage together with delicate threads. Though he’s not sure why when neither of them are happy in this marriage.
He could lie, but he knows Eliza. And he knows that she would know. She would hear it in his voice. Besides, she already knows the answer. What she’s really asking for is the truth, so he gives her a bit of it.
“Uh…yeah,” he says slowly, rolling over to face her. “Back in high school. A song on guitar.” He tries to read her expression in the dim light. “Nothing groundbreaking. Just something I wrote…when I was learning how to feel things out.”
Eliza nods, everything about her posture and facial expression unreadable.
“The one you played with Someone’s Little Sister?” she references the garage band he was in at seventeen. The words are neutral enough, but her lips are drawn into a tight line.
Brandon looks surprised, “Yeah. You remember that.”
“I knew it was a love song,” she says, her voice sounding tired. “I just didn’t realize it was personal.”
“That was a long time ago,” he says. His tone is distant.
“Was it?” two words that land heavy between them.
“I used to imagine that your music was ours,” she tells him. She lets out a small, deprecating laugh, “that I was even your muse. It was comforting, thinking that maybe something inside you was shaped by me.”
She pulls the comforter up closer to her chest, needing something to hold onto, “But I think some part of me always knew. Maybe not the details of it all. But something in me knew where your music really came from.”
“Eliza,” he reaches out to caress her cheek. He doesn’t want to hurt her. To continue hurting her. What could he say that wouldn’t make it worse?”
She cuts him off gently, “You don’t have to lie, Brandon. Not tonight. Especially not after the performance.”
He studies her face—beautiful and tired. Her red hair spilling across the pillow, her freckles dulled by the warm light from the nightstand. This woman who knows him, but not all of him. Who’s tried to build a life with him based on a version of the truth that even he can’t fully commit to.
“I didn’t mean to hurt you,” he says.
“I know,” she replies. Her voice cracks a little. “But that doesn’t mean you didn’t.”
She swallows hard, then offers a small, strained smile. “It really was a beautiful composition tonight. The way it built slowly. Like grief. Like love. The kind that lingers after the person is gone.”
Brandon says nothing. He doesn’t have the words.
She reaches up to turn off the lamp, leaving them in near darkness.
“You didn’t write that for me, did you?” she asks after a beat. Her voice is almost inaudible.
He closes his eyes. “No,” he whispers.
And that, finally, is the truth.
The house is dark and silent. Quinn and Jamie have been asleep for hours. Callie tries to sleep, but she can’t, so she pushes her blankets back and lets her feet meet the carpeted floor.
She glances at Jamie to make sure she hasn’t disturbed him and then walks out of their bedroom.
Her pacing disrupts the stillness of their home. Every movement she makes sounds loud, ringing in her ears in the silence.
She wears an oversized t-shirt and pajama bottoms. Jamie doesn’t know that the shirt used to belong to Brandon.
She slipped it on before bed, needing to feel close to him even in his absence.
She opens the door to Quinn’s bedroom and slips inside, sitting on the floor beside her small, toddler bed. She places her hand on Quinn’s back and lays her head on the pillow, sharing the space with her daughter.
Quinn’s breath is even. Peaceful. Small puffs of air ghosting across Callie’s face with every exhale. She sits for a long time, feeling the rhythm of her breathing.
After a long while, she kisses her forehead twice, before leaving.
She’s in the living room, balled into the corner of the sofa, thinking about Brandon. Remembering the feel of his body pressing hers into the sofa during their lovemaking.
The light from above the kitchen sink reaches, just faintly into the living room, leaving everything in silhouettes and outlines.
She closes her eyes and hears the music all over again.
Brandon’s symphony. Hers. Quinn’s.
It had not just moved her—it had unmade her. From the first delicate measure, she had known. It was their story. The rising tension of longing. The resolve of soft piano chords that mimicked Quinn’s sleepy murmurings. The ache in the second movement. That was what their grief felt like, she thought. And sacrifice. And then the ending. A swelling, defiant, yet tender crescendo ending in a lullaby for a life not meant to be hidden.
Tears slip down her cheeks now, silent and unprovoked. Her body holds so much. Her chest tight with the ache of loving two people more than she ever thought she could.
Callie presses her fingers to her lips as if to keep from crying out. From whispering the truth into the dark. That it was hers. That it was Quinn’s. That he had written them into the world, even if no one else knew it.
And yet, Eliza might know. Jamie too.
He had not said anything to her on the way home. Had not said anything as she cried in her seat – unable to even stand during the ovation.
A thought needles its way back into her mind.
Does Jamie know she calls Brandon Dada?
Callie exhales shakily. The guilt flares, then folds beneath the deep love that continues to pulse through her.
She doesn’t regret the music. Or the man who wrote it. Or the life they made between what was allowed and what was undeniable.
She just regrets the hiding. The hurting. She knows that Jamie and Eliza don’t deserve any of it.
It feels like a constant negotiation between truth and betrayal.
She feels herself sinking further into the sofa’s cushions, wrapping her arms around her knees.
She lets herself remember every note. Lets herself be broken open by it again.
When her phone buzzes quietly on the coffee table, she already knows who it is.
Her thumbs hover over the screen. She types, deletes, types again. Finally, she settles on
It was beautiful. I don’t have words.
You don’t need words. I wrote it for you.
Callie presses her phone to her chest. Her tears come softer now.
Because he had. He had written it for her. And because, in some small way, she had always known he would.
I love you every day and every night.
“Congratulations,” Callie hugs Mariana tightly, the familiar scent of her little sister’s shampoo bringing a rush of nostalgia.
They are at her new home for a housewarming party. Sun spills through her open windows and amiable chatter fills the air.
“I got you something,” Callie says, pulling a small gift bag from behind her back.
“Oooh! What is it?” Mariana asks excitedly, already reaching inside.
Callie laughs, keeping one arm wrapped around Mariana, “Nothing fancy. Open it.”
She watches Mariana pat the tissue paper, pushing it out of the way until her hand lands on something solid. She pulls out a rectangular picture frame.
“Callie!” she gasps with adoration and appreciate. “I love it! It’s perfect.”
It’s a picture of Callie and Mariana standing together, smiling at the camera. Their cheeks are sun-warmed and bright with laughter. Both are in swimsuits with wet hair. They are young in the photo. Soft, childlike angels are still present in their teen years.
The photo was taken during a weekend camping trip with the family.
“We look so cute,” Mariana gushes. “Look at your cheeks! They look just like Quinn’s.”
Callie laughs at that, “I lost all my baby fat. It’s sweet to see it on her again,” she says, turning her head slightly to get a glimpse of the little girl.
“I’m glad you like it,” she hugs Mariana again.
“I love it. You’re the best big sister.”
“I’m your only big sister,” Callie nudges her gently, “and I’m only eight months older than you.”
Mariana sticks out her tongue teasingly, “Still older.”
“Haha,” Callie deadpans good-naturedly.
Soon enough, Mariana is absorbed into the crowd and attention. People oohing and aaahhing over her new home; and Callie is left to observe.
Outside, Jamie is crouched in the small front yard, blowing bubbles for Quinn to catch. The drift up and over her head before descending. She squeals with delight each time she pops one.
Stef and Lena are in the kitchen, coordinating the first dinner in Mariana’s house. Jesus and Jude are tangled in cords, trying to mount a TV and installing a gaming system in the guest room – adamant that Mariana must have one even if it goes against her aesthetic.
Brandon and Eliza aren’t there yet.
Callie was with him this morning. They took Quinn to the zoo. But she misses him already.
Everything feels incomplete when they aren’t together.
Callie enters the kitchen and pours herself a glass of wine, “Hey, Moms,” she greets both Stef and Lena who stop what they are doing to each come press a kiss to her cheeks, one woman on either side of Callie.
“Hey, love,” Stef greets. “Getting hungry?”
Callie nods, “It smells good.”
“Well, it should be done in about fifteen minutes. Just enough time for you to round everyone up…please,” she adds cheekily at the end.
Callie winks, “You got it.”
She flits lazily from room to room, letting all of Mariana’s guests know that dinner will be on ready in fifteen minutes and that they are eating on the back patio.
Eliza and Brandon finally arrive, looking a bit flustered but not too out of sorts.
Eliza is wearing a coral wrap dress, her hair in soft waves down her back.
It makes Callie self-conscious for a moment. Acutely aware of the texture of her jeans clinging to her legs.
Eliza holds a bouquet of lilies and eucalyptus in one hand. Her other is looped through Bradon’s arm, resting at the crook of his elbow.
Brandon has trimmed his beard since this morning – Callie can tell. He looks handsome and casual.
The sight of him makes Callie blush.
Before she can greet them, there is a flurry of Quinn, the patter of small feet on hardwood. Jamie rushes after her, following close behind.
She comes to Brandon’s leg, tugging his pants and insisting, “Up!”
He laughs, face splitting into an incandescently bright smile. “Hey! Missed you too, Bug.” He takes her into his arms, spinning her gently. “I saw you playing with bubbles out there. Was that fun?”
She nods, understanding more language than she can produce.
Brandon kisses her cheek and sways with her, holding her close when she lays her head against his shoulder.
“She hasn’t had a nap today,” Callie offers a timid smile – tinged with fatigue and adoration. “Unless you count the twenty-minute drive.”
“She didn’t sleep after the zoo?” Brandon ask, quirking a dramatic brow at Quinn. “You didn’t let Mama rest after the zoo?”
Quinn giggles at his teasing tone, burying her face into his neck.
The scene feels almost domestic. Almost natural.
Eliza shifts next to them, her posture still. Controlled. Jamie hasn’t moved at all from the doorframe.
“Dinner should be ready,” Callie finally says. “I can take those flowers for you, Eliza.” Callie reaches out for them, but Eliza takes a step back. A slight but unmistakable movement.
“Thank you,” Eliza says. Her voice is polite and crisp, but she doesn’t move to hand the bouquet to Callie. “I actually want to give them to Mariana myself, though.”
Callie can do nothing but nod, “Of course.”
Jamie, ever the awkward savior, claps his hands together. “Should we eat?”
And for the first time in a while, Callie is grateful for his presence. For cutting through the thickness of the air that lingers among the group.
They file onto the back patio—Mariana’s backyard strung with warm lights, the table set with mismatched chairs and paper name cards. Brandon sets Quinn into a booster seat between him and Callie.
It’s only in afterthought does Brandon realizes that maybe Jamie should be sitting in the seat he occupies.
But no one says anything. Jamie takes a seat to Callie’s other side, and Eliza into the seat next to Brandon. The air is warm and layered with grilled vegetables and laughter. For a while, things feel normal.
Callie and Brandon take turns cooing over Quinn, making sure she’s eating her food and drinking water.
Brandon’s arm is draped across the back of Quinn’s seat, and his fingers are close enough to brush Callie’s bare shoulder every time she leans into Quinn.
“Tell us about your days,” Lena says warmly. “I miss this. I miss always knowing what was happening in everyone’s life.”
Jude perks up first. “I’m on week two of shadowing in the juvenile court clinic,” he says. “It’s heavy, but honestly kind of incredible.”
“You always did like to fight for the underdog,” Stef smiles proudly. “Just like your sister,” she gives Callie a pointed, loving look.
Jesus jumps in, “I finally got the zoning permits approved for that expansion. Took forever. Bureaucracy is a beast.”
“That’s huge!” Mariana clinks her glass to his. “My backyard gym dreams live on.”
Then Stef turns to Brandon and Eliza. “What about you two? Anything exciting today?”
Eliza opens her mouth to answer, but Brandon beats her to it, smiling as he leans forward slightly, “Callie and I took Quinn to the zoo this morning. She was obsessed with the meerkats. Wouldn’t stop talking to them.”
Stef raises a brow, eyes flickering between them. “Well, that sounds fun. What were you up to, Eliza?”
“I was with my mom,” Eliza says evenly, “Jamie and I are helping her finish up the last of the estate business. It’s been a long three years…” she takes a meaningful drink from her full wine glass.
Callie quietly cuts up Quinn’s food, offering her a soft, “Wanna try this, honey?”
Brandon leans in closer to help, and his fingers brush Callie’s shoulder. Almost caressingly.
Lena catches the moment—brief but there.
The party winds down with the haze of twilight. The porch light flickers on. Everyone helps clean up before gathering their things and making their way out the front door.
In the front yard, people gather in little clusters, saying their goodbyes. Eliza is deep in conversation with Lena. Jamie has wandered off with Jude to talk about one of the cases he’s following.
Quinn is fast asleep in Brandon’s arms, her curls sticky with watermelon juice, her head nestled against his collarbone.
Callie opens the back door of her car. Leaning in, she unbuckles the straps of Quinn’s car seat. Brandon carefully lowers Quinn into it, moving slowly so she doesn’t stir, making soft shushing noises.
As he clicks the final buckle, Callie rests her hand lightly on his back.
“Thank you for today,” she says softly. “She loved the zoo.”
Brandon turns to face her, the space between them suddenly hushed. “I love her,” he says, his voice quiet but firm. “You know that, right?”
Callie nods, eyes shining. “She loves her Dada too.”
Brandon exhales like it’s the first real breath he’s taken all day. “I’ll see you tomorrow?” he asks.
Callie nods in affirmation, “Yeah.”
And then—without thinking, without calculating—he leans in and kisses her goodbye.
It’s tender. Familiar. Reciprocated. The kind of kiss you give someone you love after a good day. A habit born of real life.
But this moment and this place is not private.
This kiss is a breach of discipline. The realization that they have gotten too comfortable living in the dual worlds they’ve created.
Behind them, the voices fall quiet. Stef and Lena stand frozen near the steps. Jude pauses mid-laugh. Mariana stares, eyes wide. Eliza goes absolutely still.
Eyes fluttering open, and in the periphery of a mind that can only think of the kiss, Callie can hear Jamie punch something before the slam of Mariana’s front door.
Callie realizes it first. She pulls away just slightly, eyes widening as her hand lingers on Brandon’s chest.
Brandon looks up, gazing over her shoulder, taking in the stunned silence of their family.
“Oh,” he breathes. Just that one word. Small. Devastated.
“Brandon,” Callie’s voice trembles.
“I forgot where we were,” he says.
And just like that, everything changes.
All sounds and motions are sucked into a vacuum. It’s as if someone has pressed pause.
Brandon’s hand lingers at Callie’s waist. He watches her take a steadying breath before turning her body towards their family.
She’s braver than he is. She is acknowledging it. It has happened. It’s done. And now…the world knows.
Callie sits in her car outside Brandon’s studio. It’s a small place nestled on a side street of San Diego’s downtown district. A neighborhood still caught somewhere between renovation and memory.
Old brick buildings line the block, their faded paint and rusting signage whispering of earlier decades. The storefronts are eclectic – a used bookstore with handwritten hours in the window, a small café that smells of espresso. Tucked between them is a narrow building with tall arched windows and chipped blue trim.
It’s an endearing area, and Callie can understand why Brandon chose to rent a space in this area. His studio is on the second floor, above a music supply shop that has long since stopped making a profit.
The day is beautiful. Bright and sunny. It seems wrong somehow. Like the day shouldn’t be so nice when she feels so conflicted. Like, the sky should reflect her internal state: maybe a dull pewter with fractured sunlight – too bright in some places, too dim in others.
That’s how she feels. The idea of having a baby, in general, simultaneously elates and terrifies her. The idea of having a baby with Brandon all the more so.
A narrow staircase hugs the side of the building — wrought iron railing, half-covered in ivy, and worn wooden steps that creak under the weight of every footfall. A buzzer at the bottom doesn’t work. But Callie knows to knock softly on the blue door at the top.
It’s a place you could miss entirely if you didn’t know to look for it. Tucked away. Private. The kind of space that seems to exist just outside of time.
Callie is sitting in her car, parallel parked right outside the building. She’s gripping the test results in her lap – two different pregnancy tests, secured in a zip lock bag; and paperwork from her gynecologist. Three different confirmations of what she already knows.
It’s silly, but she thinks she felt the exact moment she got pregnant. Before her missed period. Only days after her night in the study with Brandon, she felt different. Something in her knew.
Taking a deep, courageous breath, she exits her car and ascends the stairs. Before knocking, she listens for his piano. She wants to make sure that he will hear her.
There’s the faint sound of piano notes, so instead of knocking, she twists the doorknob. She’s not sure if she’s relieved or disappointed that it’s unlocked.
When she steps inside, the scent of old wood and sheet music is almost olfactory overload.
The melody Brandon is playing vibrates through the walls.
The studio feels like a world apart. High ceilings with exposed beams give the space a rustic charm, and oversized skylights cast dappled light across the polished wood floors. Dust particles dance lazily in sunbeams that filter through the old glass.
She softly closes the door and clicks the lock – the sound triggering memories of the several nights they’ve spent together here, wrapped in nothing but one another.
It isn’t until she steps around the corner that Brandon comes into view. A wall of windows, only partially muted by gauzy curtains, casts Brandon in dark shadows for a moment before Callie’s eyes adjust.
Brandon looks up from the piano bench when she walks in, his face brightening instinctively. Another memory of their time together:
A floor littered with Brandon’s scrawled compositions, having been pushed off a nearby table to make way for Callie’s body. Her legs spread wide, Brandon’s lips against her inner thigh, traveling steadily upward.
The studio holds a thrifted velvet sofa with mismatched pillows – something Callie chose and insisted upon when they both woke up on the floor with sore backs.
“Hey,” the music abruptly stops. Then, he registers the fear in her features.
“Callie?” he goes toward her immediately.
She doesn’t speak. Not yet. She meets him in the middle of the room and lets her trembling body melt in his embrace.
He kisses her hair, mumbling against it, “Is everything okay?”
She doesn’t hesitate as she reaches into her purse and pulls out a folded piece of paper and the zip lock bag, she leaves the security of his arms to set them gently on the piano.
Brandon doesn’t look at them at first. He looks at her, confused and already unraveling.
Her eyes are glossy. Her lip quivers.
Then, finally, she says it. Soft, but clear.
The words land like a dropped stone. Not sharp. But deep. Sinking.
Brandon meets her at the piano and looks down at what she’s placed atop it. One. Two. Three. His throat works hard to form words. “How… how far along?”
His fingers hover over them, hesitant, as if touching them might change everything. And when he does pick them up, his breath catches—audible and sharp.
“Callie…” His voice barely registers above a whisper. He looks up at her, as if needing confirmation from her face, not just the facts in his hand.
The math is instant. The night of the funeral. The study. Him.
His knees buckle slightly as he fumbles to sit back down on the piano bench.
Callie nods. Her whole body feels electric. Not with joy, not entirely—but with a vibrating current of everything she’s tried to suppress for weeks. Her palms are slick, her knees unsteady. It feels impossible and inevitable all at once.
He hasn’t asked, but she wants to assure him, “I got the dates confirmed. It’s no one else. Jamie and I always use protection, but I haven’t…haven’t been with him in a while.”
Brandon’s hand covers his mouth. “A baby.”
“I didn’t know how to tell you,” she says quickly, tears finally breaking free. “I didn’t even know how to tell myself. I didn’t plan for this, Brandon. I didn’t mean for it to happen this way.”
“A baby,” he repeats, not with fear but with something quieter – something that sounds like awe. “Our baby.”
His voice breaks just slightly on the word “our.” And then he laughs, breathless and disbelieving. “I think part of me knew. I’ve been working on a new composition, but I just haven’t been able to get it right. Like it’s missing something. Maybe it’s been missing this.”
Callie smiles, a gentle laugh through her tears. Leave it to Brandon to find the silver lining.
Brandon stands and walks toward her — slowly, deliberately — like he’s afraid she’ll disappear. “Are you okay? You’re both safe…healthy?” He cups her cheek in his hand.
She nods. “I’ve been to the doctor. She said everything looks perfect.”
His hand finds hers. His warm, calloused grip acts as a lifeline.
“I’m scared,” she admits. “And I don’t know what this means. For us. For anything.”
Brandon brings her hand to his lips, kissing the back of it before pulling her towards the sofa and into his lap.
“I don’t know either,” he says. “But I’m here. I’m here, Callie. And we’ll figure it out. Whatever it takes.”
They kiss, and she feels his hands beginning to search her body – starting at her thighs, traveling up and beneath her shirt to rest on her abdomen.
Outside, the wind brushes past the tall windows, rustles the ivy on the staircase. Inside, time has folded in on itself—just the two of them, a heartbeat beneath Callie’s skin, and the faint melody still ringing from the piano’s last chord.
They stay like this, the two of them in the stillness of the studio, cradling the beginning of something fragile and real and entirely theirs.
They don’t discuss what they will tell Eliza and Jamie. They both realize that they won’t tell them anything. They will let them believe what they want to believe.
Jamie will believe the baby is his.
Eliza will believe it too – at least for a time.