What are your thoughts on Aelin and Manon?
Aelin’s arc is the most heroic in the traditional sense—chosen one, heir to the throne, savior of her people—but Maas does not shy away from imbuing that heroism with real cost, manipulation, and moral ambiguity.
She’s clever, prideful, charming, self-sacrificial to a fault—but also controlling, secretive, and at times deeply unfair to those who love her most.
Her tendency to shoulder everything alone is both her greatest strength and her most frustrating flaw. She builds these elaborate plans in secret, keeps people in the dark, and then expects them to understand when everything is revealed. While it’s often framed as necessary because “no one else could have endured it,” that justification wears thin when you consider the emotional fallout on her court.
The fact that Aelin planned to use Aedion—her cousin, her most loyal ally, the person who loved her most unconditionally—as a breeding tool to produce children with Lysandra disguised as Aelin is deeply disturbing. It’s not just manipulative. It’s dehumanizing.
Even if we understand the political logic—ensuring a lineage, protecting Terrasen, etc.—the coldness with which this plan was executed, without his knowledge, reframes Aelin in a way that’s hard to walk back from.
It doesn’t mean she’s a bad person. But it does suggest she’s a character who believes that the ends always justify the means, even if it means crossing sacred boundaries. And unlike other anti-heroes or gray characters, Aelin is still portrayed as the triumphant, admirable queen—and that cognitive dissonance can grate.
She saved the world. But she also hurt the people closest to her. Both can be true.
Manon’s arc is the most subtle but arguably the most emotionally satisfying. She begins as an agent of death—a creature molded by violence, rigid rules, and bloodline supremacy—and ends up choosing compassion, choosing to unmake the monstrous legacy she inherited.
Where Aelin’s journey is about reclaiming a throne and protecting a kingdom, Manon’s story is about reclaiming self. She starts with no name but “Manon Blackbeak,” no love in her life, no softness, no self-determination. But bit by bit, she builds a soul.
She doesn’t “fall into” goodness. She fights her way toward it.
Manon is cold steel and slow-burning evolution. And ironically, that makes her the more emotionally resonant for many readers. Her transformation feels earned. There are no shortcuts to her humanity. Every act of kindness costs her something. Every shift in loyalty is a battle against her own programming.
And perhaps most importantly: she listens. She learns. She changes based on how others are treated—Elide, Abraxos, even Dorian. She is not immutable like Aelin, who often doubles down. Manon bends—and in doing so, she becomes real.
I admire Aelin. I respect her cleverness, her perseverance, and her willingness to burn for the people she loves. But that moment with Aedion pulled the curtain back too far for me. It made me see how she sometimes views others as chess pieces—even the ones closest to her. It’s not that I hate her—but I mistrust her.
Manon, by contrast, is someone I grew to love. I didn’t expect to. But her story was about learning to feel, learning to choose.
ellievsbear
stormborns
titsay
origamiaround
areudirty
germansingergirl
gracieabrams
theartofmadeline
