stay strong. survive. š š§” ā”ļø šŖ¬ this is a sideblog run by Jewish women with disparate backgrounds.šŖ¬ā”ļø jumblr and allied friends, we love you š am yisrael chai
Cara Drook, Reclaiming La Belle Juive, (2022 ā).
'"La belle Juive" translates to "the beautiful Jewess." It is an archetype of Jewish women that is repeatedly shown in paintings and media throughout history. "La belle Juive" is rooted in antisemitism and misogyny. My goal with this collection is to have Jewish women take control of their narrative and reclaim "La belle Juive." I want to return dignity to the subjects and show what truly makes Jewish women beautiful.'
WHEN social media influencer Chris Caresnone made his first trip to Israel just over a year ago, he knew very little about the country ā including nothing about the events of October 7.
But he is a fast learner and has embraced all aspects of Israeli society, including Jewish, Muslim, Christian and Druze, on his quest for good food.
āAbout a year ago, I was invited by a group called Reality to go to Israel,ā the Chicago-based food blogger told me. āA lady named Debra Feinberg reached out and was like, āChris, Iāve been following you for a while, and I think youād be great for this organisation that gets people to Israelā, because my Jewish audience was starting to grow.
āI was thinking that I need to get to Israel because it would be good for the energy, ethos, brand, and content.ā
Chris, who has hundreds of thousands of followers across social media, continued: āIāll be honest, I had heard stuff about Israel and Palestine, but I was ignorant. I didnāt know much about anything until I was in Israel. I was wet behind the ears. I didnāt know about the bombs or October 7. All I knew was, Iāve got to get to Israel.ā
Chris, whose real surname is Campbell, said the first thing that struck him about Israel was that it wasnāt all Ashkenazim.
āWe ignorantly think that all the Jewish people on Earth are eastern European,ā he told me.
āItās not from a place of hate, just that we donāt know. But then when I went to Israel, Iām like, man, thereās people my colour who are Jewish and Israeli.
āAs far as food, I would say excellent. It all felt fresh, even the fried food.ā
Chris, who is known as the Babka King, was a little surprised about the lack of babka in Israel.
āThereās some, donāt get me wrong, but itās not really Sephardic, Mizrahi,ā he said.
There was another aspect of Israeli life which surprised him ā the driving.
āItās a little hectic,ā he laughed. āI donāt know if I want to drive over there. I personally thought the vibe of Israel was super cool, and I plan on going back as often as I can.ā
Despite being a six-foot two-inch black man with a beard, Chris said he has never encountered any problems getting into Israel, apart from being stopped constantly by people who recognise him.
āThe reach is getting so big now, so many people notice me in the airport, and itās not even just Israel, itās back home too, New York, Chicago,ā he smiled.
āI have to stop and take pictures every few minutes, so thatās not really a problem, but itās something thatās a slight disruption.ā
Although it was never his original intention, Chrisā social media feed is now heavily Jewish, leading to many Jewish dinner invitations, including from rabbis for Friday night dinner.
āIām kind of Jewish now,ā he joked, āIām embedded and I see whatās going on, but my first time in Israel? I heard that this is apartheid, but I see all kinds of people there walking freely. Iām a black America dude, clearly not Israeli, clearly not Jewish and not only do I walk perfectly fine, people come up to me and show me love.ā
Chris, who says he grew up Christian but is not very religious, had his babka obsession started by a Muslim.
āAnd that turned into this movement, so to speak, of humanity, which I think is the most beautiful thing ever,ā he explained.
āI started making culture content, showing love to different cultures. I did like 50 cultures. I didnāt even make any Jewish or Israeli content for seven or eight months.
āI feel like I get so much love within the community, and Iām just treating yāall normal like how I treat everyone else.
āI was told the way you have to look at it is, imagine if someone gives you a glass of water every single day.
āEventually, itās just another glass of water. But imagine youāre walking through the desert for four months, and then someone gives you a glass of water, itās a bigger deal. And itās not because the glass of water is any different, itās because the context of the situation.
āItās so big and powerful, yet itās a matter of just being human and showing humanity.
āAnd the whole food, the babka was really just lifeās way of Hashem, the universe, God, whatever we wanna call it, it was the Trojan horse to get my energy amplified.
āItās more than food. I donāt feel like a food guy at all. I feel more like a bridge builder.ā
During his trips to Israel, he has also spent time with Ethiopian and Druze communities.
He described Ethiopian food as āridiculously goodā, adding: āI have tried other cultures that are mixed within Israel. Thatās what makes Israelās food scene so unique. Itās almost like the opposite of what people are trying to say.ā
The 42-year-old was raised around the North Shore of Chicago, which, he said, has one of the largest Jewish populations in America.
āI didnāt really have a lot of Jewish cuisine outside of matzo ball soup,ā he explained. āWhen I got a little older, I started working in restaurants in different areas, and sometimes affluent areas.
āI started trying things that I probably would not have tried had I not worked in a restaurant. So my horizons got expanded because of that.ā
He said what he realised about kosher food was that the food was still good despite the restrictions (apart from gefilte fish, which he has never been fond of).
As expected, his videos from Israel, while garnering mainly positive comments, do receive a number of hateful comments.
He had changed his name to Caresnone to reflect the fact that he wasnāt letting hate get to him, but it is a situation that has provoked a lot of thought.
āHereās something Iāve been asking myself a lot recently,ā he said. āAm I trying to be right or am I trying to solve the problem? I have learned that a lot of times I was trying to be right, not trying to generally solve the problem.
āOn my birthday, February 2, I went out with some people and I had a buddy bring a girl he had met like once or twice.
āHe should not have invited some girl he had just met to my intimate personal birthday dinner, but it is what it is. So weāre all sitting there at this restaurant and itās a good 10 of us. We were talking about food and Iām like one of my new favourite cuisines is Israeli food. Iāve been going to a lot of Israeli restaurants.
āAnd this girl whoās sitting next to me, she goes, āoh, excuse me, what did you say?ā
And Iām like, āI like Israeli cuisine, itās fire, I love itā. And she says, āthereās no such thing as Israeli cuisine, itās all stolen, they steal everythingā.
āShe invited this new energy when we were just talking about food.
āIām with my buddy Kareem KWOE Wells, whoās considered King of the Mitzvahs, a black Christian in Chicago whoās known for doing the most epic and powerful mitzvahs in the country. Me and Kareem went at her. We werenāt rude or ignorant, but I was starting to feel myself losing composure, because Iām part of the humanity tribe, but Iām also very entrenched in the Jewish community and Israel.
āThen she made a comment along the lines of āI should be able to say whatever I want to sayā and then I matched her with that.
āIām a pretty intimidating figure. And I looked at her, and Iām like, āwell, I can say what I want to say, tooā. I was giving her energy that wasnāt welcoming. I didnāt cuss her out or anything. And everyone else at the table thought I handled it well.
āBut I was trying to be right. I wasnāt trying to solve the problem. So much so that she said, āmaybe I should get out of hereā. And I looked at her and go, āyeah, maybe you shouldā.ā
He continued: āFast forward. Iām on the way to Israel, on a 10-hour flight. I get a DM: āF*** Israel, f*** you, you black monkeyā.
āI was immediately reminded of my birthday. I thought about that moment and I asked myself, do I want to be right or do I want to solve the problem?
āBeing right would be to either call that person a racist or antisemite, or to ignore the person, or to call them an idiot, that youāre wrong, you donāt know anything about nothing. Or am I trying to solve the problem genuinely?
āSo I typed to that person āI love you, brotherā. Then weāre going back and forth, but Iām always bringing it back to humanity. Iām trying to solve the problem.
āAnd instead of looking at this person as a racist and antisemite, which heās showing himself to be, I saw him as this person whoās hurt, who believes a narrative, who thinks he understands something, he obviously doesnāt know me, and thatās what I saw now.
āSo I was able to not take it personally because I want to solve the problem. I donāt care about being right. I donāt care that he thinks Iām this. Iām trying to solve this.ā
He added: āThat guy who called me a black monkey. He equated me being aligned with Israel as equal to hating Muslims.
āI know Jewish people for a fact do not hate Muslims. But this person believed that all Jews and all Israel, or anyone who stands for that, hates Muslims. Iām like, brother, a Muslim sent me my first babka.
āA Muslim has created a lot of this, you know what Iām saying? He was the one who sent me the babka.ā
The guy eventually apologised for his āblack monkeyā comment.
Chris has also received death threats because of his Israel content.
He joked: āHow you gonna hate me because Iām eating the babka? Iāve never once come out and said Iām pro-Israel or pro-Jewish. I said Iām pro-humanity, which includes Israel.
āI donāt think thatās controversial. Iām looking at a Jewish person, you got arms, you got a head, you got feet, youāre one of us. If the aliens come down, I donāt care if youāre Jewish, Muslim, green, yellow, itās us versus the aliens?
āLike I said, people coming at me crazy for eating the food, which is interesting, because whoeverās throwing out that slur or that energy, Iāve probably done their culture too.ā
Chris describes his job as to move āin a light, which is very Jewish! Very tikkun olam, from what Iāve been learning. And I feel like before I even knew what tikkun olam was, and before I even knew what being chosen people was, and before I knew any of the core premises of Judaism, I align with a lot of this stuff.ā
Chris is hoping to spread his wings more. He is keen to āget my butt out to Europe, I know thereās a lot of people telling me I need to go to Australia and Mexico City, where thereās a big Jewish population.ā
One of his favourite restaurants in Israel is called Pitmaster.
āI have learned that the Israeli community loves to dance,ā he said. āPitmaster is an experience. Everyoneās dancing. They stop between the meals and they dance and itās like a vibe. They are gonna bring two more to the United States. And in America, youāre gonna have to make alcohol more of a thing, because these people werenāt dancing because they were drunk, they were dancing because they were joyful. In the States, youāve got to get people drinking.ā
He added: āSo when you ask me, am I aware of how what I do affects the Jewish community and the people of Israel specifically. I want to be clear and say Iām not a Jewish content creator. I am not an Israeli content creator.
āIām a humanitarian creator who happens to also include Jewish and Israel on the humanitarianism, and also, I just happen to be really cool with them like anyone else.ā
In one of his newer videos, Chris talks about volunteering in Jerusalem with Colel Chabad.
āIt reminded me that sometimes the best part of travelling isnāt just what you experience. Itās what you can give back. If youāre visiting Israel, I genuinely recommend adding this to your itinerary.ā
You can follow Chris on all social media platforms @chriscaresnone
what she means: just sobbed over this because so many musicians are catastrophically failing us by increasing hatred and division, indulging in useless performative boycott lists, and helping (whether purposefully or not) to isolate and dehumanize Israeli and Jewish artists and listeners alike, when if they wanted to use their artistry to foster peace and understanding, they could, and it would be so much kinder and more beneficial than what weāve seen happening
(ironically some of the rest of this paper is framed very poorly and has a clear, specific bias against Judaism, but thatās irrelevant to the way this introduction resonated)
the bias in pieces like this is actually worth analyzing in itself but itās depressing, for example:
Israel is framed only as the cause of oppression and strife, and the trauma felt by Israeli children due to the conflict and terrorism is never mentioned, even though this is a broadly humanistic piece:
I think the reason for this disconnect is because the papers are researched and written by people who are entirely outside of the conflict, so the default critical perception (Judaism being regarded as inherently more violent and exclusionary, Israel not being diverse, Israel being the constant aggressor and at fault, Palestiniansā actions are denied agency) is never questioned. this is an ongoing issue with peace advocacy, the acknowledgment of shared pain, shared responsibility, and thus a need for actual change and constructive dialogue towards peace from both sides for it to even be possible isnāt considered, because only one half is held accountable. Iām not sure how we can take even very earnest hopes for peace-building seriously when the perspectives are held in that ideological lock.
the only time thereās more balance on this is when itās coming from the region itself:
all that said, the arts, and especially music, are most beautifully realized when theyāre treated as a way to bring people together, to unite and uplift. instead weāre seeing things like the film boycott list and āno music for genocideā and the PEN America report about Israeli and Jewish authors facing discrimination being met with rage that they were allowed to speak about antisemitism at all and this:
it just feels so hopeless when even the humanities, the artists, arenāt centering humanity, compassion, and togetherness at all.
it is functionally insane that jews are expected to be deferent and piously self deprecating while we are only intermittently treated as human beings.
some of the most powerful global institutions on an economic and social level are the dominant religious powers that have denuded the narrative of the jewish religion.
they have regularly denied us being its makers when it was convenient in order to depose us our positions of influence and security.
and weāre expected to be delicate and graceful when people slaughter us in the name of the religions that built over our memory? reprehensible
dude. tell me you know nothing about the holocaust without mentioning the word holocaust. please for the love of god learn. about anything regarding antisemitism. please. please stop assuming every jew talking about antisemitism is a zionist. you are an uneducated, ill mannered fucktwit
āwhen jews talk about their oppression itās jewish exceptionalismā
āweaponizing antisemitismā
āweaponizing the holocaustā
āessentializing antisemitismā
āeternal victimsā
āvictim card declinedā
^^some of the most insidious antisemitic concepts i encounter because their goal is to kneecap our ability to even talk about the bigotry we face. iāve included both nominally left-wing and right-wing versions.
I think I've said this before, but there's one thing that's become extremely apparent to me from the last two and a half years of dealing with Western Leftist Jew-Hate.
Specifically, a tremendous amount of the assumptions, conclusions, and general arguments made by them make much more sense if they--implicitly or explicitly--believe that:
there was a break of continuity, both in religious practice and ethnic descent, between modern Rabbinic Judaism and Second Temple Judaism.
that modern Rabbinic Judaism is a modern, post-Reformation/Enlightenment reconstruction of an extinct religious tradition composed of post-Christian converts (akin to neo-pagans)
the sole group who can claim ethnic descent from the Second Temple-era Jews are Palestinians.
There's a lot of cross-pollination with Khazar Theory, obviously, in there, but it stands on its own to at least some extent.
Yeah, this about sums it up, and what I find especially interesting about it is that a lot of the cross-pollination with Khazar Theory seems to be happening when Leftists who have casually absorbed all of the above then later encounter Khazar Theory in the wild, and just kind of go "hmm, well sure, that fits right in with my existing worldview, so I guess I'll go ahead and incorporate it into my belief system without any further inquiry!" Which is kind of odd when you consider that it's about as buck wild a fringe theory as Fomenko's New Chronology, or the Bosnian Pyramids.
Like I think that an area where a similar thing often occurs (but where the stakes are maybe a little bit lower) is the phenomenon of people learning bad Egyptology from TikTok, and then accidentally falling all the way into ancient alien conspiracy circles, just because those are the main other groups which jive with, eg. the based-on-literally-nothing claim that they heard from someone on TikTok (who was not in any way an archeologist) that Hatshepsut's name was censored due to transphobia. You don't need to be an eg. "radiocarbon dating skeptic" in order to get taken in some unsupported pop Egyptology theory... but once you're there, man, you're quickly going to have to either consider why it is that so many proponents of this quirky little academic theory are radiocarbon dating skeptics, or else become one yourself. And it seems like on average, it's a lot easier for folks to fall all the way into the pseudoscience than it is for them to admit that the first thing they swallowed was wrong and that they fell for it.
tiktok posts even mentioning Jews, just Jews, NOT zionism or Israel, NOT Gaza, JUST JEWISH PRACTICES: *comments with 100k likes about how ALL Jews are "z*o baby killers"*. *comments with 140k likes about how at this point "all Jews are guilty by asssociacion and should accept it".*
tiktok post about an ACTIVE RUSSIAN SOLDIER CONFESSING HIS FRIEND RAPED A UKRAINIAN WOMAN IN FRONT OF HER YOUNG CHILDREN: *commemt with 130k likes about how "Russian Soldiers just wanna go home and live peacefully with their families"*. *comment with 285k likes about how "both sides are tired of the war".* *0 comments about how the rapist's actions are wrong in a any way shape or form*.
Never. NEVER. EVER. let anyone tell you they "care about all genocides equally" or "would absolutely speak up about war crimes and atrocities committed against Ukrainians as well". Even posts by Russians themselves condemning ONE specific active combatant for RAPE dont get actual rapists an ounce of criticism for their act. Not even one comment about anyone's heart breaking for that Ukrainian rape survivor and her babies. NOT ONE. and before you assume, all those highlighted ccomments are in English, not Rrussian. Where is the outrage? wheres the baby killers comment? wheres the "all Russian soldiers deserve to die for this" comments? nowhere.
These people do not care. These people have never cared. These people only care when they can bully Jews for existing. It's never been about ANYTHING else. PLEASE stop falling for what morons say on tumblr about how *they* absolutely would show empathy to all war crime survivors eually. They're deflecting. They do NOT care about the innocent, they do NOT care about war crimes, or the civilians these crimes affect, they do NOT care about the wellbeing of babies or toddlers, they don't even think that specific soldiers actively raping civilian women are bad. It's NEVER been about that. EVER. Stop letting people convince you otherwise.
justice for that civilian survivor whos trauma is not even worth mentioning in the eyes of the west and justice for her toddlers who had to be in the room and witness it.
i think that when people call israeli bomb shelters ābunkersā itās intentionally to conjure up associations of āwealthy privileged people being cowardly and hiding from the consequences of their harming The Peopleā (bc that is what they believe) instead of ācivilians taking shelter from warā
but theyāll call them bomb shelters again when itās time to spin a different narrative. for example, āthe israelis arenāt letting indian migrant workers into bomb shelters, so theyāre sleeping in the train station!! theyāre all white supremacists/jewish supremacists!!ā
when, actually:
- anyone is allowed in any public bomb shelter
- the train stations are bomb shelters
- lots of white jewish israelis were sleeping there too
and similarly, i think a lot of people look at october 7th as basically fyre festival (a group of wealthy privileged people getting their just desserts)
Can we talk about the lack of critical thought in these claims?
You have 15-90 seconds to make it to a bomb shelter once you receive an alert. Some people run there in nothing but a towel because they were in the middle of a shower.
What are the logistics of banning certain people? Is there an Israeli bouncer?
Are they at the door like
Bitch please.
What about the vast majority of Jews being Mizrahi (as in, their families have never set foot outside the Middle East?) Do they check IDs on people who are too brown for their liking?
What an amazing feat to filter out hundreds of people in 15-90 seconds!
And they complain about 50K+ Palestinians killed in Israeli strikes, yet never point out that Hamas wonāt let civilians into shelters? Theyād rather complain that *checks notes* Israel does?
It reminds me also of the claims that Israel has a space laser that vaporizes entire human bodies, but that Israel also harvests human organs from killed Palestinians.
So the magical space laser vaporizes everything, but leaves the organs intact?
Beyond the Golem & the Dybbuk lies a forgotten world of Jewish magic and folklore myths!
After many preparation we are launching a 50-page, fully illustrated zine exploring the hidden creatures, spirits, and myths of Eastern European Ashkenazi folklore. If you love dark, whimsical lore and handmade art, check it out!
You can grab a digital copy, a premium physical zine, or limited-edition art prints.
Please reblog and support the campaign here:
Beyond the Golem and the Dybukk lies a forgotten world of jewish magic. This 50 page, fully illustrated zine unearths the lesser-known creat
On July 9th, after a rocky relationship with Jewish writing since 10/7 (to put it mildly), PEN America actually decided to interview Jewish and Israeli writers and put together a relatively thoughtful piece about it. It included Jewish and Israeli writers noting that publishers have told them it is not the right time to publish Jewish stories, insisting a name be changed from Yael to Sue, and other pretty damning evidence that the industry has become openly hostile to all Jewishness.
If you read the Instagram comments, it's a hellscape. Poet Mohammad el-Kurd, who in January 2024 said "we must normalize massacres as the status quo" wrote "boo hoo." More upsetting to me was Molly Crabapple (writer of a recent bestseller glorifying the Labor Bund as a reasonable path forward for contemporary Jews) who basically commented that her success as a Jew in the writing world proves the discrimination is bogus. But of course what she fails to note is that you can only succeed in the Jewish writing world right now if your writing is *explicitly anti Zionist.* and I don't mean just an antizionist writer, but a book that forwards antizionism as an argument. Several of the interviewed Jewish and Israeli writers weren't writing about Zionism at all. They simply weren't writing about *antizionism specifically* which is the only way to publish Jewish writing right now.
To make matters worse, the article, for the crime or suggesting that cultural boycotts that treat Israelis as inhuman are bad actually, was so heinous apparently, that Pen America's President, Dinaw Mengestu, immediately resigned, outraged that it was published at all.
Writer Elissa Wald, who is quoted in the PEN article even notes that they didn't publish much of her actual criticism that would surely have further angered readers:
"They left out the part where I said I thought PEN America's capitulation to antizionists -- by which I mean, among other things, their surrender to cultural boycotts, their amplication of the genocide libel, their shift in focus to issues like "free speech on campus" which are outside the scope of their (literary- based) mission, and the intense internal pressure on Suzanne Nossel to step down as leader of their organization was contemptible and pathetic, especially since their primary purpose is to defend freedom of expression." She wrote on Facebook.
The fact that a relatively sanitized "refusing to publish Israelis and Jews based on their nationality and ethnicity is bad actually" has caused this kind of uproar is unsurprising but another reminder that the writing world is rapidly closing itself off to Jews. Who knows, maybe we'll invent a new art form again like we did with comic books last time.
from here
Interviews with Israeli and Jewish writers who report facing rising isolation and exclusion.
Jerusalem-based literary agent Deborah Harris represents dozens of leading voices of Israeli literature, from established titans to debut authors of āliterary gems.ā Her agency typically sells five to 10 literary novels a year into the United States. Since Oct. 7, 2023, they have not sold a single one.Ā
Harris told PEN America that editors with whom she has worked for years simply donāt respond to her submissions, or reject them outright. She has been asked by some editors not to submit Israeli authors in the future.Ā
āThe standard line is, āI wouldnāt know how to publish this author right now,āā she said in an interview with PEN America. āRight now, weāre completely in this place where no one will even look. No one believes they can get a book that they love through an editorial meeting.ā
In interviews with PEN America, more than 30 Israeli and Jewish writers and literary professionals described a widening cultural isolation since the attacks of Oct. 7 and the subsequent war in Gaza. Many spoke of rising hostility and exclusion both domestically and internationally that has taken a heavy and worsening toll.Ā
The horrors of the Hamas-led terrorist attacks and the devastation of Israelās war and what human rights organizations and experts have determined to be genocide in Gaza, have had catastrophic human costs. The political and cultural debates around the war have fractured communities and families and spurred conflict in institutions worldwide, from corporations and cultural organizations to campuses.
The war has also had serious repercussions for free expression globally, including in the United States, as PEN America has documented and spoken about extensively. Palestinian and pro-Palestinian writers, artists, and activists have faced dire consequences for their expression including arrests, harassment and threats, deportation attempts, and detention, in addition to cancellations and exclusion in the literary and cultural spheres; Israeli and Jewish writers and artists on all sides of the conflict have been silenced and faced a range of threats and repercussions.Ā
In this piece, we share the stories of Jewish and Israeli writers who feel that the mainstream literary world is increasingly shutting them out because of their identity, nationality, or views. They describe an environment that has impacted their reputations and livelihoods, led people to self-censor, and created an overall chilling of their ability to write and create freely. This silencing and exclusion of writers is a threat to what PEN America is fundamentally committed to defending: a culture of free expression for all.
Rising Isolation and ExclusionĀ
Writers and others in the Israeli and Jewish literary community, in interviews with PEN America, reported event disinvitations and cancellations, and new and growing barriers to publication. They also recounted being harassed on social media, review-bombed on Goodreads, and subjected to online calls not to be read, platformed, or engaged with if they had ever shown support for Israel or Zionism. Some writers described being ignored by agents, publishers, literary journals, and magazines. Many requested anonymity to protect their safety and careers.Ā Ā
It is difficult to assess how much of what the writers PEN America spoke to are experiencing stems from cultural boycotts and broader efforts to protest the war; how much from anti-Israel, anti-Zionist, or antisemitic sentiment; and how much reflects matters of business or taste, which are also shaped by geopolitics.
But the writersā accounts revealed the blatant hostility, discrimination, and hate that some Jewish and Israeli authors are facing, and the impact on their freedom of expression. Writers PEN America interviewed shared that they have been told by their agents to remove Jewish characters and references to Israel from their novels, or downplay Jewish identity because it wonāt sell. They related stories of publicists having to be replaced because they refused to work with Israeli writers. āI do think that we have essentially been hounded out of literary life,ā one author said.
One example writers cited of this hostility is a spreadsheet that circulated online in May 2024, titled āIs your fav author a zionist???ā which includedĀ authors to be boycotted, based on whether they had expressed āZionistā views and whether they had sufficiently criticized Israel. The list included a wide range of Israeli, Jewish, and non-Jewish writers. Authors were included on the list for a host of reasons, for example, based on a single Instagram post, attendance at literary events, posting āboth sidesā statements, objecting to boycotts, visiting Israel, or writing about an Israeli fictional character.
Two years ago, the Jewish Book Council opened aĀ hotlineĀ for reporting āantiĀseĀmitĀic litĀerĀary-relatĀed inciĀdents.ā They define antisemitism as āprejĀuĀdice against or hatred of JewĀish peoĀple,ā which ācan take many forms, such as verĀbal or writĀten lanĀguage, in-perĀson or online harassĀment, vanĀdalĀism, and vioĀlence directĀed at a perĀson or instiĀtuĀtion because they are JewĀish.ā Ā The Council told PEN America they received about 350 self-reports by July 2026, including incidents related to boycotts, literary events, submission guidelines, cancellations, and social media.Ā
āI can tell you unequivocally, I am surrounded by writers who are telling me that (they are being fired by) their editor, their publisher, their agent, their publicist,ā said the writer Elissa Wald, who created a book club calledĀ Never AloneĀ and two other substack magazines for the Jewish community. āOften theyāre being dropped not because of any Israel stands or any Zionism. Theyāre being told itās not the right time for a Jewish book.ā
For agent Deborah Harris, the hardest part is having remarkable Israeli writers denied a chance to make a mark in world literature, and having readers denied books that reflect important perspectives.
āLiterature is what breaks down the walls,ā Harris said. āOnly literature can do that.āĀ
A Chilling Effect on Israeli Writers
For many Israeli writers and translators, the loss of opportunities has been devastating. One translator who has been involved with trying to bring 20 to 30 Hebrew-language projects to international markets said he did not know of a single project that sold.Ā
āIt was the international market that gave them some hope for some recognition beyond the borders of a very small state,ā he said. Harris, who has sold foreign rights for her Israeli clients for four decades, explained that books that canāt find a U.S. publisher are unlikely to sell in other countries.Ā
U.S. publishers have, unquestionably, released some books by Israelis, including prominent post-Oct. 7 memoirsĀ Hostage,Ā by Eli Sharabi andĀ When We See You Again,Ā by Rachel Goldberg-Polin, the mother of murdered hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin. But the agents and writers PEN America interviewed said fiction is another story. The chilling effect on the market for fiction titles might not be immediately obvious because only a handful of Israeli authors are published in the U.S. each year, and contracts are typically signed years in advance and confidential.Ā
William Kolbrener, an English professor at Bar-Ilan University in Israel, said his creative writing students feel hopeless. āAll of our students feel right now, what am I going to do with my manuscript? Itās not even that our students are getting rejected. Thereās just nobody out thereā who is interested in reading their submissions, he said.Ā
A creative writing PhD student at Bar-Ilan, Ronit Eitan, said she finished a novel two years ago, but has not tried to submit it. āI held it back for the past year and a half because nobody wants to hear my voice,ā she said. Eitan has attended protests and demonstrations against the government and fits what she has long considered the markers of a liberal worldview. āBut what I found out is it doesnāt matter how I define myself. Itās not up to me. Iām a Jew first for everyone else,ā she said.Ā
In March 2024, the literary quarterlyĀ Guernica retracted an essayĀ by Israeli writer Joanna Chen after several staffers resigned in protest of its publication, with one editor saying the piece ā about Chenās experience driving Palestinian children for medical care ā made the magazine āa pillar of eugenicist white colonialism masquerading as goodness.ā
In an interview with PEN America, Chen said although the criticism felt personal, she quickly realized it wasnāt about her. According to her, the bigger issue is the extreme polarization of public opinion. āYou can be pro-Palestinian, or pro-Israel, or whatever, you canāt be somewhere in the middle, and I am somebody who tries very hard as a human being to at least acknowledge the narrative of people who are not exactly like me,ā she said.
The award-winning Israeli writer Etgar Keret describes himself as having āthis unique status of being boycotted both in Israel and overseas.ā After heĀ signed a petitionĀ urging Israel not to starve civilians in Gaza and calling on soldiers to refuse immoral orders, a right-wing TV channel called for a boycott of the petitionās signatories. Municipal leaders in Beersheba, where he has taught at Ben Gurion University and volunteered for years, barred all signatories from speaking in municipal venues. He said both he and his wife have faced death threats and found an X marked on their door.Ā
Outside of Israel, Keret had planned a live interview in Australia with Ira Glass about Keretās mother, a Holocaust survivor. Amid warnings of protests and threats, Keret and Glass, in agreement with their hosts, decided to decline. And Keret recounts festivals where organizers told him that other writers would resign or refuse to share a stage if he appeared. Some of the writers, he said, insisted that they had no issue with him or his positions but feared that āoutside the hall, everyone will know that we sat with the Israeli writer.āĀ
The very phrase ācultural boycott,ā Keret insists, is an oxymoronāātwo words that shouldnāt be together,ā like āmilitary intelligenceāāand argues that when artists and institutions police which texts can be read or which writers can be heard, they echo the very traditions of censorship they claim to oppose.Ā
Keret warned of a world in which every writer is sorted as āyour artist or my artist,ā and where cultural boycotts become a way to avoid the risk of being changed by what one reads. āLiterature is not there to fortify your ideas,ā he said. āLiterature is there to confuse you. And if you donāt have the courage to be confused, then donāt talk to me about culture or cultural boycotts.āĀ
Several writers interviewed by PEN America said theyād been discouraged from writing about Israel by agents or editors. They noticed other writers de-Israelified their books by not mentioning their country of origin on the book jacket, for example. They said there seemed to be an appetite for only a certain kind of Israeli story.
āThereās basically a silent moratorium, or at least it seems like that, about Jewish material thatās not explicitly anti-Israel,ā one author said.
Harris said because she has been unable to sell literary fiction, she has focused on nonfiction for now. She has big books coming out about bats and the brain and the alphabet ā all of which have nothing to do with Israel, though they are written by Israeli authors. But she says even nonfiction books arenāt immune from pushback. āI have had nonfiction books where the team of publicists and marketing had to keep being replaced because people would not work on those books, because they were written by an Israeli writer,ā she said.
Two Israeli writers for U.S. general interest magazines said articles they submit are put through a series of ideological checks, such as whether they use the word genocide. One said he gave up journalism as a result. āItās not worth being punched in the face for that. I left the conversation.ā
Yossi Klein Halevi, a U.S.-born Israeli author and journalist, is among those whoĀ signed a letterorganized by the Creative Committee for Peace opposing the boycott of literary and cultural institutions. Halevi, who has written for years for leading U.S.-based opinion outlets, said he now prefers to write for Jewish publications.Ā
āIāve always written for mostly liberal left-of-center publications. And I no longer felt that I could trust the readership. ā¦I didnāt want to write for people who thought that Israel had become Nazi Germany. ā
In interviews with PEN America, Israeli and Jewish writers described a climate where Zionism is treated as a slur. While there remains no popular agreement on what it means to be a Zionist, recentĀ survey dataĀ suggests that one-third of American Jews self-identify as Zionist and nearly nine in 10 say they support Israelās right to exist as a Jewish and democratic state. Calls to exclude Zionists from publishing could therefore mean excluding people with a wide range of voices and views. āThereās a lot of lack of clarity of what Zionism even means,ā one author said.Ā Ā
Some voices within Israel have expressed dismay that the boycotts in literature, film, and other arts will hamper the ability to tell stories critical of the current Israeli government, at a time when the Israeli government is also restricting the space for dissent. In early 2026, the culture ministry under Miki ZoharĀ canceled dozens of annual arts prizes and grantsĀ that support independent writers and artists. Zohar at first cited budget cuts, but later said that the awards were biased toward the left āwhile clearly ignoring artists whose views represent the majority of the public.āĀ
Many of the writers interviewed by PEN America who spoke about feeling blacklisted by the industry have publicly criticized Israel, signed petitions, and protested against the Israeli government. Several writers expressed frustration that those who are being silenced are people like Chen who have worked towards coexistence and peace.Ā
Broader Impact on Jewish Writers Outside IsraelĀ
No organized boycott has called for targeting writers solely because they are Jewish. But in writersā groups and online forums, Jewish authors outside of Israel have described losing agents, publishers, and book events since Oct. 7, because they are Jewish, they identify as Zionist, or they are sympathetic to Israel.
The spreadsheet of authors who were labeled as Zionist that circulated online in 2024 shook the Jewish community. ItĀ went viral on XĀ and listed authors who had been published in Israel, posted pro-Israel content on social media, or had any connection to Israel, however indirect. One novelist was listed for creating a social media post expressing concern for Jewish friends after Oct. 7 and failing to mention Palestine. Another was listed for giving a talk to Hadassah, a Jewish womenās group, and including a character in her novel who the spreadsheet describes as āalso zionist lowkey.āĀ
Kathleen Schmidt, a publishing veteran who blogs atĀ Publishing Confidential, criticized the list and those who would punish authors over the actions of the Israeli government. āSingling out Jewish authors and telling others to boycott them is antisemitic. If you donāt believe in book bans, you shouldnāt be okay with boycotting authors for being Jewish,ā she wrote.
Some Jewish writers we interviewed said that what they felt were worthy books that cater to Jewish readership have failed to find publishers since Oct. 7, for reasons they canāt explain. Even established authors are hard pressed to prove the reason their book was not picked up or did not get reviews or sufficient marketing attention, as some say has happened to recent Israeli and Jewish-interest novels.Ā
āNo one is getting a rejection thatās delivered like, āWeāre not going to publish this because youāre a filthy Zionist,āā one writer said. And yet, āeven from a purely mercenary sales perspective, these things should have found homes.ā
Zibby Owens, founder and CEO of Zibby Media, hasĀ statedĀ publicly that she has ābeen told directly that select authors wouldnāt come on my podcast and certain bookstores wouldnāt stock the books I publish due to my public support of Israel and the Jewish people.ā
Many Jewish authors who do not consider themselves Zionist or support Israel have been affected, according to PEN Americaās interviews. But the chill is especially profound for Jewish authors who write about their identity or about Israel.Ā
Thereās a feeling that is very hard to pin down, that the cultural and publishing world, and to some extent the art world and the academic world, divide Jews into what in effect are āgood Jewsā and ābad Jews.ā The good Jews are anti-Zionist, and the bad Jews are Zionist,ā said a prominent Jewish author who has written on a broad range of topics including antisemitism. āIf your work puts you in the category of Zionist, you feel a chill in the air in your dealings with publishers.ā
At the same time, some Jewish writers have expressedĀ concern about their exclusion from Jewish literary spacesĀ for their pro-Palestine advocacy or criticism of Israel. Other Jewish publishing professionals and Israeli writers and artists have joined in endorsing a cultural boycott as a tool to force the Israeli government to end the war and change its policies. Judith Gurewich, publisher of Other Press, believes itās appropriate for publishers to be responsible for the ideas they publish. She said opposition in publishing is not about identity, itās about the message. āIf you have an Israeli that takes an anti-Zionist stand, theyāll be picked up immediately. You can send them to me,ā she said.
Yehudit Singer-Freud, who specializes in book publicity for Jewish-interest authors, said clients have had trouble getting their work reviewed and planning events for their books. It is hard to know whether the lack of promotion is targeted. At the same time, she said, āThere have been people in these writing groups who have said that their editors have told them to remove certain characters or to not mention the Jewish identity or to play that down because it wonāt sell.ā
The author Meg Keene received multiple offers from agents on her romance novel with Jewish themes. One agent told her that in order to sell, she would need to strip all Jewish references from the book. āThe best friend character was named Yael, and she said we cannot sell a book with a character named Yael, we need to rename her, like Sue. And I didnāt do those things, and the book didnāt sell,ā sheĀ told Canadian Jewish News.
Another writer told PEN America that their agent advised them not to write about antisemitism, explaining that no one wants to acquire a book about Jewish victimhood. āHe wasnāt endorsing the situation. He wants me to get a good deal,ā the writer said.
Several Jewish writers have reported beingĀ dropped by their agents. Lee Kofman, author of an upcoming biography of Golda Meir, said she and other writers haveĀ heard the same phrase: that the agent ācannot champion your career.ā Harris, the literary agent in Jerusalem, said she gets requests every week from Jewish writers in the United States who are seeking new representation because of perceived bias from their U.S. agents.Ā
Hate and Harassment Online
A number of writers described facing intimidation and harassment on social media platforms. Zibby Owens and other Jewish writers have reported beingĀ āreview bombedā on Goodreads.Ā Once More with Chutzpah,Ā a young adult novel about a high school seniorās trip to Israel, was inundated with dozens of one-star ratings a year before it came out.
āI saw members of the book community act like my debut getting attacked online was something I deserved because I was said to have done things or shared sentiments that are, in reality, directly opposed to how I feel ā comments like, āThis book supports genocide,ā assumptions about the context and content of my story,ā the bookāsĀ author, Haley Neil, told Kveller.
Jewish-American author Lisa Barr said her novelĀ Woman on FireĀ received 450 one-star reviews as a result of an organized review bombing. At its peak, sheĀ received up to 50 hostile messages a day, including āDie Jewā and threats that her daughter should be raped.Ā
Jewish authors we spoke to said part of the problem is the silence of allies who may be afraid of being targeted themselves on social media. The result is that many Jewish authors feel excluded from conversations in the literary community.
When childrenās author K. Marcus posted a Facebook ad for her new picture book,Ā Frankensteinās Matzah: A Passover Parody,Ā it was targeted with comments accusing Jews of supporting genocide. Marcus is American and the book is about a child who brings passover matzah to life. āIām pro Jewish joy. You know, Iām a childrenās book writer,ā she said.Ā
Some Jewish writers told us the intensity of online discourse had led them to stop posting, or to delete their social media accounts altogether. Author Susan Shapiro said she stopped posting political statements that might be considered polarizing on social media. āSome of my agents, editors, and bosses basically begged me to not post the kinds of things that I used to write,ā she said.Ā
Others said theyād self-censored in deciding what to write about, or what outlets to pitch.
āI know that I and other people have tried to figure out, what does it mean to continue to participate in the literary public sphere with integrity?ā one author said. āFor those who havenāt been frozen out, the cost of staying in is one of giving in to censorship as the price of inclusion.āĀ
To counter these headwinds, there has been a concerted effort to create spaces for Jewish writing. Author Alison Hammer gathered writers into a group chat that eventually expanded intoĀ The Artists Against Antisemitism. New outlets for Jewish writers include OwensāĀ On Being Jewish Now,Ā WaldāsĀ Never Alone Book ClubĀ community and substacks, and Kolbrener and EitanāsĀ Writing on the Wall. The Jewish Book Council establishedĀ marketing grantsĀ that Jewish authors can bring to publishers to help get books acquired. Singer-Freud created a digital platform,Ā Jewishbookvillage.com, to help Jewish authors promote their books.Ā
Celina Spiegel, publisher of Spiegel & Grau, said itās especially important to stand up for a diversity of stories as books are being banned in the U.S. atĀ rates not seen in our lifetimes. āIt is painful sometimes to allow opinions that you donāt like hearing to get airtime. But I think that encouraging debate and conversation is the only way to move forward,ā she said. āYou canāt be selective in which books are okay to have available or not. And itās a very dangerous line if youāre going to draw one.ā
Chen, the writer whose Guernica piece was taken down, still sees herself, and all of literature, as a bridge. She wants to understand great authors, including those who signed on to the boycott. āI donāt have to agree with it. I think people today have these ever-widening blind spots,ā she said. āI think literature requires us to stay in the room, all of us. To stay in the room and continue the discourse.ā
* * *
PEN Americaās president resigned over an article detailing the isolation and exclusion that many Israeli and Jewish writers feel after Octob
archive link
[ā¦] From their perspective, the leader of their organization was arguing that merely reporting on the stifling of one groupās free expression amounted to suppressing the rights of another.
Some PEN staffers came away feeling that his worry about the free speech of pro-Palestinian protestors and student activists foreclosed any defense of Israeli and Jewish writersāeven writers, such as the Israeli novelist Etgar Keret, who have condemned the war in Gaza and have suffered consequences both outside and inside Israel. (It should go without saying, though maybe it needs to be said, that it would be meaningless to have free-speech organizations if they defended only speech they agreed with.) These staffers also expressed sadness that even a small effort to fulfill PENās mission by describing the experiences of writers under political stress was met with such a dramatic gesture of rejection, seemingly because of those authorsā identity.
[ā¦] PEN does not muse that the removal of a Toni Morrison novel might be a matter of taste,ā Allison Lee, the former head of PEN Americaās Los Angeles office, told me, referencing the groupās many reports that have condemned book bans over the years. āOnly one group of writers, it seems, must have the case for their suppression respectfully contextualized before the harm done to them can be acknowledgedāand even then, only provisionally.ā
Most discussion of Israel and Palestine has devolved into a zero-sum game. The simple act of drawing attention to what Israelis and Jews might be experiencing was always going to be read as a position statement for the organization. āThe blog post was brave and right,ā Andrew Solomon, a former PEN America president and current honorary board member, told me. He opposes the current Israeli government, but he does not see why that should preclude him from defending Israeli writers. He has also done work in Ukraineāhe risked his life to deliver vehicles to Kharkiv earlier this monthāand said he would still speak up against the mistreatment of Russian writers, regardless of what Vladimir Putin does.
āWhy would anyone complain of acknowledging the suffering of anyone else?ā he asked. āIs the lie that some peopleās suffering matters more than that of others the role of an organization dedicated to free speech and truth? I donāt deny Palestinian suffering and donāt see that acknowledging and representing it means I cannot acknowledge suffering in Israel too.ā
Solomonās position is shared by others on the board, a fact reflected in the decision of the organizationās leadership to stand by the article. But Mengestu was named president in order to solve a serious problem at PEN America, one that this new crisis threatens to expose again.
In 2024, PEN America went through something like an internal revolt after a large number of prominent writers, including Naomi Klein, Michelle Alexander, and Lorrie Moore, issued a series of letters making escalating demands that the group take a harder line on Israel, and specifically that it characterize the war in Gaza as a genocide. (The new article uses the wordābut among Mengestuās objections is that the designation was attributed to āexpertsā and other organizations.) A group of writers attacked the then-CEO, Suzanne Nossel, calling for her resignation. InĀ one of their letters, they describe Nossel as having ālongstanding commitments to Zionism, Islamophobia, and imperial wars in the Middle East.ā So many writers pulled out of the 2024 World Voices Festival and that yearās literary awards that both events were canceled, and the annual gala was nearly called off too. (Nossel, who ran the organization for more than a decade andĀ leftĀ in October 2024 partly in response to the protests, had grown PEN Americaās membership and influence as well its revenue, which increased fivefold.)
An organization that had prided itself since its creation in 1922 on protecting free speech and the defense of writersāno matter who they wereāwas thus overtaken by a passionate and sizable contingent that demanded the group become vocal advocates on behalf of Palestinians and in opposition to Israel. One of this constituencyās central demands (they called themselves Writers Against War on Gaza, or WAWOG) was that PEN America be more accepting of BDS and not condemn writers who joined calls for a blanket cultural boycott.
When Mengestu assumed office, WAWOG announced in an InstagramĀ postthat it had achieved āVICTORY AGAINST PEN AMERICAā (the same group todayĀ offeredĀ a āsaluteā to Mengestuās āprincipled decisionā to resign). But in one earlyĀ interview, the new president promised to āmend and rebuild.ā Since then, PEN America has focused considerable attention and resources on Gaza. In addition to its extensive Gaza report last fall, the organization has spent as much as $500,000 dollars, according to several insiders, on helping Palestinian writers and artists.
Besides helping Palestinians artists, PEN America has made other efforts to keep the protesters inside the tent. In January, the group released a statementĀ condemningĀ the cancellation of performances by the incendiary Israeli comedian Guy Hochmanāin keeping with its general stance against āideological litmus testsāābut laterĀ withdrewĀ it in response to backlash. At this yearās World Voices Festival, which included more than 140 writers from more than 40 countries, not a single Israeli was part of the program.
In light of these shifts, last weekās article came as a genuine surprise, including perhaps to Mengestu. The PEN America board does not have any editorial control over the work of the staff. But after the release of the report on the cultural destruction of Gaza, the organization decided to share potentially controversial publications in advance with board members. They saw the article two days before it was published, and a number of them decided to meet to discuss it. I could not confirm whether Mengestu was part of these conversations. When I asked him about it, he didnāt respond to the question. Board members are held to confidentiality about their internal discussions. (Among these members is the Atlantic staff writer George Packer.) Mengestu delivered his judgement on the article and decision to resign in emails to the board.
The next president of PEN America will decide the group's courseāand that course is hard for anyone to predict. The decision by Lopez and Shariyf to publish the article was described to me by many people I spoke with as an act of ācourage.ā (I should acknowledge that others, who declined to speak with me, might feel very differently.) And yet they expressed no desire to return to the tumult that the organization experienced in 2024. The younger members of the staff who, according to Mengestu, were upset by the articleās appearance, and the hundreds of writers who have signed petitions opposing PEN America in the past, cannot be ignored without imperiling the organizationās future.
Maybe the most revealing aspect of this eruption, though, is just how little it took to set it off. Thursdayās article nodded to the curtailed freedoms of Israeli and Jewish writers without taking any ideological side. It was far from a battle cry or a shift in priorities. It was just a way of acknowledging, in the measured but principled language common to PEN America, that the past three years of discourse have had an effect on a large group of writers. For anyone who has spoken to Israeli or Jewish artistsāas I haveāthis is undeniable; you hear it everywhere. This reality does not neutralize the cause of pro-Palestinian writers or the suffering in Gaza and elsewhere. The fact that the article was perceived that way, and that it led to the resignation of a president, tells us all a great deal about the hair-trigger moment we live in, and about the precarity of the liberal principles on which PEN America was founded.
The pro pallie party line is "once US aid to Israel is cut off it'll disintegrate in weeks! Months tops!"
It's stupid conceptually, but do you know who proves it wrong?
Ukraine šŗš¦
Since the turd got back in office aid to Ukraine has been slashed
And in the last few months Ukraine has made russia its bitch
Ukraine did not collapse as trump his cronies and putin bet it would, they adapted, they found new partners, relied on their own know how, embraced the fact that no US aid means less leverage and more freedom to strike russia as they please
This is exactly what would happen with Israel if aid were cut off, except Israel is starting out wealthier, better equipped, and with weaker enemies
The most likely scenario is that without iron dome help or American easily targeted smartbombs for cheap, Israel starts attacking threats even more proactively with even less care for civilian casualties on the other side, and such becomes the new status quo for decades. Far more innocent Palestinians and Lebanese who committed no crime or violence and heck probably other neighbors too once they get the war bug again die and Israel stays exactly where it is.
But human lives never entered into the equation, only Keeping Our Souls Pure, so the ones advocating for more Palestinians being killed "in the name of Palestine" don't care.
Prev got it exactly. Israel is so small geographically that they have no choice but to be proactive, and the iron dome allows them to be more measured in their strikes. Get rid of the iron dome, and suddenly Israel canāt afford to be as careful.
Thinking about the kid I was in upper primary school with (so a 12 year old), who truly believed that Jews came from Mars and had a war with Atlantis. Not a cool sci-fi/fantasy story he was writing, he believed it was world history.
Also that there is a spaceship buried beneath the Great Sphynx in Egypt.
CW: femicide, murder, drug use/abuse, murder with a bladed weapon
Hey, so... That conspiracy theory obsessed kid from my childhood ended up being a Conspiracy Theorist Podcaster and was just convicted of murdering his girlfriend. The podcast is still running just without him. This is all horrific and I honestly don't know how to feel right now.
IMO the deciding factor is that she was leaving him.
There's a lot of focus on how this murder was "meth fuelled", but I really think there should be more focus on how conspiratorial thinking warps the mind.
I want to write my condolences to the family but I don't know how to contact them.
Tobias Nuttall is sentenced to at least 18 years behind bars for murdering his girlfriend with a 25-centimetre dagger in a "vicious" attack
i have started just treating all anti zionists as conspiracy theorists and its made it significantly easier to deal with them. them saying "zios" are running the country, controlling everything, pedophiles, monsters etc becomes a lot less headache inducing when you realize these people are on the same level (if not worse than) flat earthers or antivaxxers...
Women shouldn't have had to have their personal unpleasant and traumatic experiences with him paraded and judged publicly for him to be considered an inappropriate candidate. Because, HE HAD A NAZI TATTOO! and that should have been enough.