"George and Lily at the Met" by Gordon Slater
The last time he was in New York City, George lost track of time in the American Wing at the Metropolitan Museum of Art and sweat himself wet rushing downtown to miss his train home. His parents were not surprised, and his father only said, “I’m glad I wasn’t there.” It is the European Paintings, though, that usually make George late; at twenty-two he is stubborn enough to say that the
European Gallery is his favorite place in the world. The only thing George hates about the museum are the men in white jeans and black t-shirts who march furiously through galleries, confronting each painting as if to say, “What the fuck are you looking at, buddy?”
Subterranean rumbles follow George out of the 59th St./Columbus Circle station. The warm, piss-y air of public transit brushes away from him with the crushed-leafs of a windy, fall afternoon. Bracing against this fresh gust, he shivers. It is almost Thanksgiving time again, and men are starting to wear scarves under the flipped-up collars of their fall coats. Some women still wear skirts and the bravest one’s strut bare legged, but stockings are more common now. These impervious, long legs impress the young man. Both George’s cold hands, stuck deep in jean pockets, and red ears, half covered by straight blond locks, are early indicators of an approaching frost.
On Central Park South, walking towards Fifth Avenue, George remembers that he promised his mother he would buy a bottle of wine for dinner, “something red that costs at least $20 dollars,” she had ordered. Reaching into his back pocket, George opens a leather wallet and leafs through the bills inside, frowning. Fall is George’s favorite season, and fall in New York is liable to awaken the deepest sorts of romantic notions in his heart. With the sun shining so brightly, George notices that he has a particular spring in his step and this makes him smile, feeling suddenly lucky. He realizes, though, that this excitement really must be hidden, Lily wouldn’t have it. But the thought of her can’t help but turn him on in some old corner of his mind.
Walking uptown now, on Fifth Avenue, George wishes he had a sweater on under his thin, blue button-up canvas jacket. Lily will be waiting for him on the steps of the Met, she has never been late, and George quickens his pace slightly in acknowledgement. On gold posts, green awnings stretch out from the tall, stone apartments along the avenue. Walking past the entranceways, George finds himself making eye contact with a doorman in a black, boxy suit. The doorman, much older than George, is standing behind the glass entrance to a grand, marble lobby trimmed with gold all around. The man’s nose seems almost pressed up to the pane. The doorman’s grey mustache is neatly trimmed and below a black cap, he sports short, charcoal hair. His hands are folded at the waist and he bears the bored expression of a man eternally anticipating someone’s arrival; two blank eyes lack friendship but George can tell by the wrinkles above his cheeks that warmth is easily produced.
The cross streets pass quickly under George’s loping gait, and he whistles a bit, excited now, walking even faster as the blocks up to the Met recede- the 65th St. sign suddenly reading sixty-nine. George hasn’t seen Lily in a few months, and only once since their break-up that spring. They had been talking though, occasionally, on the phone and via email. In the grey light of an early fall afternoon, George could remember clearly what it had been like to walk the avenues of the Upper East Side with Lily, back when they had only just begun to kiss. His chest felt tight when he thought of those days. Some blocks over, a year earlier, George had nervously chattered away to Lily, rambling about his favorite paintings at the Met. He assured her she would love them just as much as he did. How could she not?
It was fun for George to watch the foreign women leave the buildings along Fifth Avenue. George would always try to guess their nationality from their accents and fashions, confirming his assumptions from the gold-bronze plagues on the light-pink stone of, say, “The Embassy of France.” He could hardly help but cheat now, of course, as he knew Fifth Avenue well; when he dated Lily he would ride the train in from Connecticut every weekend, and repeat this walk from Columbus Circle. George liked the stroll because it gave him time to prepare for Lily, who intimidated him always in her natural beauty and grace. George liked watching the wealthy women in furs walking furless dogs smaller than their purses and the drivers who waited outside of black Mercedes and Audis to ferry these women off to somewhere even prettier. Up the block, George walks past doormen who seem somehow more fashionable now, younger and thinner, wearing grey suits and standing, or pacing, under the awnings. A few are talking together, cracking jokes in entranceways.
Before the relationship had cracked-up, George was always thinking of things to do with Lily, special places to take her when he came into the City from Connecticut. It was hard, living so far from her, when at College they had so easily slipped into a routine- lunch together between classes, the library after, maybe the gym at night if they weren’t too tired. Their friends joked that they were like a married couple, but here George was, walking to meet Lily, and he wondered if this was what it felt like to be divorced.
Lily strides down Fifth Avenue, head into a breeze, and long blond hairs blow lightly in her wake. She wears an annoyed expression and walks confidently, her legs half covered by a loose dress that clings to her skin as she moves. Her dress is a grey just darker than the sidewalk, and she ties a tan, cashmere sweater loosely around her hips. The grey marble of the Metropolitan Museum of Art looms a few blocks ahead and behind her a crowd swirls around the white swirl of the Guggenheim. Lily wonders if there is a rule that all museums must be white, but then remembers the red-stone Museum of Natural History and smiles to herself.
It is sunny and bright, and Lily squints, having forgotten her sunglasses in her annoyed rush to leave the apartment. George is always late, she thinks, holding her hand to her brow as she looks down the avenue. Lily wonder’s if he’ll make her wait long- it is cold, even in the sun, and small hairs stand on end along Lily’s arms.
Waiting to cross the Avenue to the museums steps, Lily notices a small dog at her feet, tethered ridiculously to a bright silver collar and leash, which is studded all over with silver spikes. A skinny woman stands holding the leash nonchalantly, talking fast into a cell phone pressed against her ear, “I don’t care what he says, the cabinets have to be done by Tuesday or the countertops can’t be put in… oh fuck him!”
Lily rolls her eyes and kneels down to look the dog, a little white thing that licks his lips at the girl.
“Aren’t you a good little boy?” Lily says, smiling at the dog, patting its head and rubbing its ears between her fingers with a soft, delicate touch.
“Actually, she’s a girl,” The woman says, glaring down at Lily and tugging at the leash, pulling the dog with a jerk out into the crosswalk. Lily sighs, and the pup looks back at her forlorn, in love.
The traffic purrs as Lily bounces across the street, and a man on the corner, watching, thinks that she must be walking on her tiptoes, so barely does Lily touch the ground. The Metropolitan looks positively welcoming, two white dove wings spreading to embrace the populous, which mills around below the central entrance’s pillars, everybody waiting for somebody else. Tourists sit on the steps, looking down at the devices in their hands, scrolling with an even pace through endless streams of pictures and messages. Lily tries not to join them for a bit, until her leg is tapping on the marble step and she pulls out her phone to text George.
[Where are you? I am on the steps, hurry hurry]
A buzz heralds his reply.
[Two blocks away, patience!]
How many times had George nagged her to come with him to the Met? Lily was surprised she had even agreed this time, but she felt the pressure of George’s pleasantness when he had called her, and they hadn’t seen each other for months. Still, Lily thought, she lived a few blocks from the museum and had been going all her life! George’s starry-eyed aestheticism always seemed to rankle her, its not as if he studied art, it was just one of his many “things,” his recipes for how to be happy in life. Lily used to love hearing him say absurd things like, “Museums remind me to appreciate beauty in everyday scenes, all I have to do is imagine them painted and the world seems fresh to me.” Towards the end though, she had made fun of him for those kind of words, laughing when he asked her to go to a new show, “You won’t come to get drinks with Irena and Julie, but you want me to wait on line an hour for this shit?” Lily complained. She felt guilty later, knowing that she would have liked the show, and even more so with George grinning like a child at her side.
It was sad Lily realized, to meet like this with everything so much in the past, no feelings alive and present that could buzz between them. In fact, when George had called she had to warn him, “Don’t try anything,” because their break up had been hard enough without getting the financing together for a sequel. But how could she just forget what she once felt? Just the thought of George made her remember a thousand times she had felt happy and beautiful, but a bitter annoyance lingered too, with these bedside memories.
Lily could see him now, across the street, walking with his awkward gait that came from having legs a bit too long, his head in the clouds, whipping around to look at the people he passes and never fully aware of what is two steps in front of him. Lily smiles, untying her sweater from her waist and pulling it over her head so for a brief moment her blond locks are trapped under the collar, pressed down around her face. George sees her now and she waves with one hand, pulling her hair free with the other. Smiling, waving, and pulled by the tug of unshakeable affection, George crosses into traffic, running between two cabs and up to the steps where Lily stands now.
“Lily. You, well, you look amazing, “ George, his face bright, stumbles around with his words and Lily laughs.
“Shut up, its good to see you,” hugging him, Lily lets herself fall just for a moment into his embrace before pulling back. She motions with her head towards the entrance.
“You’ve been wanting to take me long enough, lets go,” Lily smiles but her eyes are dim, looking down, sad, “I have dinner with my parents in a bit.”
Walking up the stone steps into the Museum, Lily realizes that they must look like a couple, striding close to each other, a well adjusted, attractive couple that does civilized things together, that wanders the Metropolitan together.
“Where are we going first?” Lily asks George, like a schoolgirl on a fieldtrip. She knows this museum just as well as George, if not better, having grown up only blocks from its steps- but she is content to let George lead the way this one time, absolving herself of an old obligation in the process.
“When are you meeting your parents for dinner?”
Suddenly, George is awash in a memory of Lily’s parents. Her father, dark, handsome and intimidating, always asking George what he is reading, wondering if George had a plan for after Graduation. Lily’s mother, who is eternally youthful and as elegant as her daughter, full of small jokes, so kind and charming that Lily actually felt jealous watching George talk and laugh with her. They had taken him to dinner once, to a sushi place on the West Side, when they were first dating. George kept on slipping his hand around Lily’s leg under the table, and she would throw him dirty glances and move her leg. Not mad for long, she would always grab his hand in her own. At dinner, George had spent the whole meal trying to make the family laugh, and he was almost sweating with embarrassment. Lily had an entirely disabling effect on him, and with her George had only the singular focus of making a good impression. George could have relaxed; it wasn’t his charm she loved, but his empathy.
George has been wrapped up in his own thoughts so much that he doesn’t realize they were almost at the paintings he wanted to show Lily. The night before, George lay in bed and mumbled to himself, trying out things to tell Lily, words to explain these paintings that meant so much to him, alone, in his impressionable mind.
“Where are these paintings? You said you wanted to show me a Gauguin or something?”
“This way, just around the corner.”
The Met is crowded, school groups and clumps of European tourists wander, talking quietly, in the hallways that divide the galleries neatly. George likes to watch the crowds, each group maintaining their own pace through the collection. Off the hallway, Lily and George watch a woman standing perfectly still in front of a large Monet, one of his water lily paintings, staring at it with intense, furious concentration. The woman, wearing a black headset like an air traffic controller, appears to be a statue, a new piece of installation art. George and Lily laugh, smiling at each other, both amused by the deliberate dedication of their fellow museumgoer.
“Who do you think she is?” Lily had always liked to ask George questions about strangers they saw together; he always seemed to have an idea.
“Oh her? She is the eldest of ten children that all grew up crammed together in a ranch house on Long Island. She never got enough attention and forever felt like no one appreciated how sensitive she was. The other nine kids played sports, soccer and lacrosse, but she was the artistic one. These days, her husband won’t come with her to Museums, but she doesn’t mind, she prefers the headphones to his complaining. I’d say she is happier than we could imagine right now.”
They walk on, deeper into the gallery, past two men, both curly haired and chubby, who speak fast in Italian and point rapidly at a map of the museum in apparent disagreement. Across the room, George spots one of the paintings and taps Lily on the shoulder.
“There, that’s what I wanted to show you. That one most of all.”
Set against the white, clean walls of the museum, spotted by George from between the shoulders of amateur art critics jostling for the best angles, hangs Paul Gauguin’s “The Siesta.” In the frame, four women lounge with little concern for the viewer. Resting in the shade of roofed-over porch, escaping the heat of the sun, the women have always seemed to George to define the term “casual.”
“What is she doing, the one in the back, in the maroon dress?” Lily waits a few beats, allowing a respectful silence to settle, before asking.
“Ironing. I’m surprised you can’t tell, I seem to remember you taking issue with the state of some of my wrinkly button downs.”
Lily ignores George and wrinkles her eyebrows at the painting, Gauguin is a “post-impressionist,” she remembers from an art history class, and famous for his vibrant, pastel colors.
“It is beautiful, the pink in the wood on the porch and how the shadows are all one shade, no graduations.”
George nods. He has stood in this spot so many times, thinking, for the past few years, of Lily, who he thinks is as effortless in her style as the woman lounging in the foreground. He is tongue tied though, standing there with her, not knowing what to say anymore. Lily always surprised him, knowing more about art than he thought, more than him actually. Lily always knew a bit about an artist or a painting that George was familiar with only in the realm of his personal taste; without any real, critical training in art history, George relied solely on his intuitive aesthetic preferences to form surprisingly strong opinions about his favorite pieces.
“I just love the clothes, the dresses and tops, the blue and white polka-dotted scarf tied around her hat,” George pointed at the mysterious figure in the foreground, “Her shawl is such a dark blue that it almost looks black, no?”
“I love her pose, she seems so relaxed but I can’t tell if she’s tired or bored, or happy. He says so much with her positioning that he doesn’t even need to show us her face!”
“I don’t think that pose is even natural, something is off, proportionally. It is perfect though, especially with that dress, it must be lace or something. The blue of the dress is so soft, light, and with those little flowers on it… I think she is gorgeous.”
Lily rolls her eyes and sighs.
“Of course you think she’s gorgeous, Gauguin was totally imperialist, eroticizing these “exotic” women. He was obsessed with the idea of romantic, ‘simple’, ‘unspoiled’ beauty.”
Lily was always competitive, and she would come at George swinging, hoping to catch him in a moment of ignorance. He really couldn’t argue though, she was kind of right about Gauguin.
“I think they are cool, that’s all. No one dresses like that now, I’d die if I saw a girl in that hat, with the polka dots.”
“Oh, would you? I didn’t know polka dots turned you on like that. When did you become such a critic of women’s fashion?” Actually, Lily had always liked George’s taste in clothes, and used to love when he would compliment her on an outfit in his awkward, earnest manner. George has a good eye, Lily thinks, not that he knows much at all about fashion.
A shrill alert disturbs the gallery, Lily’s phone ringing and she steps away, motioning that she has to take the call. George stands alone now, in front of the painting, and wonders if Lily cares about it at all. Was he stupid to call her and ask her to come with him? Lily has seen this painting before, no doubt, and she was always hard to impress anyway, wary of anything that George was too excited about. George wants to tell Lily that he thinks of this painting when he thinks of her, but it wouldn’t go over well and he knows he cannot. Suddenly the painting seems unbearably somber to him, all these women looking away from him, avoiding his gaze. They are ignoring him, George thinks, tired of his incessant admiration. Lily leans up against a wall, chatting into her phone for a minute, hangs up and walks back to George.
“I’m sorry, that was my mom. I have to go. Do you want to show me something else quick?”
“No, it’s ok. Thank you for indulging me and Mr. Gauguin.”
Lily hugs George, kisses him on the cheek and steps away, thinking that he looks sad, which makes her feel awkward. A part of Lily wants to hug him again.
“I’ll see you soon!” Walking away from George, the positivity in Lily’s voice rings flat and empty, and she feels bad for saying anything at all.
Down the steps and out of the Met, Lily feels strange and almost nauseous. It is colder now, and the sun is beginning to sink down over the West Side and the crowd is still stirring around the marble wings of the Museum. Lily starts walking uptown, staying on Fifth instead of cutting east to her apartment.
George leaves, five minutes after Lily, and starts walking downtown. His step is heavy and he feels colder than before, the setting sun casting long shadows down towards the East River. George doesn’t think much as he walks downtown. Averting his eyes from the doormen standing in long, warm looking coats, George feels embarrassed, something Gauguin has never made him feel before. Walking slowly, George barely notices his progress and without realizing it, he crosses 59th. George walks a few blocks down, scanning the storefronts, looking for a liquor store. He finds one, and inside, George walks down an aisle between long rows of wine bottles, red and white and probably rosé too. Peering at a price tag, George picks a Pinot Noir and carries it over to the counter. The cash register reads, “15.99,” and George pulls out a ten, a five, and four quarters from his wallet, which is empty now, besides for a folded map of the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Uptown, Lily turns into the park on 105th Street, and wanders into the Conservatory Garden. In the summer, thin walkways separate rows of flowers and bushes in bloom. Lily likes to feel the fuzzy leafs on one green bush, and she loves the small purple flowers that she never remembers the name of. A small fountain hosts a family of water lilies and some sickly looking gold fish, when its warm, and Lily pauses for a moment at the empty pool, thinking of Monet’s big canvases. It is the Rose Garden though, circling around a larger fountain, which has been Lily’s favorite since she was a girl. The roses aren’t in bloom anymore, the pink pedals only recently wilted and scattered on the ground by the season’s first frost. Some pedals on the ground are still pink in spots, but most have turned brown like old bits of newspaper. Lily thinks that she would like to take George up here sometime, when the flowers are in bloom and it is warm; she is sure he would like the quiet gardens. The sky is dark now, and Lily shivers. It won’t be warm again for months.