My thoughts on reanimal’s lore 😛😛😛
@caramsels is the main mastermind behind a ton of the stuff in this post, we talked a lot about our thoughts so please make sure to give her the credit she deserves, especially because she’s planning to make a post too about her thoughts as well.
The way I saw it was that they killed the girl because she was a sacrifice in order to A: win the war which would mean it would end, B: keep their island safe from the war.
These kids are already in an orphanage and it’s very possible that their parents are dead/MIA due to it. The girl is also shown in most art and also the secret coffin gathering thing to be always below/far away from the other kids- excluded. It’s possible they killed her because she was innocent too, ie the rabbit and lamb symbolism.
All the kids have been stated to have been defiled in some way or something along those lines- unclean in their own eyes. But maybe not the sister.
Something brought her back, maybe it’s a “monkey’s paw curls” type thing or the ritual simply went wrong, but regardless she came back, and something came with her. The sheep growing is a representation of this secret they’re keeping, they all are stated to want redemption, but even the one who makes the most effort- the brother- never comes truly clean to her. Every time they get the chance, they don’t take it, and the sheep grows. It’s fed by their silence, because the secret will come out eventually, and she will learn what they did.
The pregnancy metaphor is because the girl was “violated” by her friends- not literally as in she was sexually assaulted but they took advantage of her kind nature ( her brother calling for her to lead her out) and her compassion for the dead lamb, which was a distraction. They violated her trust and her love, and the sheep is the result. An undeniable result, the consequence of what they did to her, presented as a pseudo pregnancy fed by their continual refusal to come clean.
(This also leads back into how reanimal comments on gender. Women and girls experience some of the most awful treatment during war; rape, molestation, sexual assault, ect. Characters like the sniffer are clearly sexual predators, and hood being the only other girl other female child, a very androgynous one at that, I think is very intentional. Especially with the sniffer having an intense interest in her specifically. I do feel like hood’s distance from traditionally feminine expression is possibly a result of the fear of predation, or a response to past experiences. In one of her cut lines when they first meet her, she says “he knows you’re here” referring to the sniffer. This implies that they are already familiar with the sniffer in some way, and as mervik I think it was said, some of the antagonists, IE almost certainly the sniffer, are past tormenters of the children.)
I want to make something clear that might not be a very popular take, but I do think that the kids are meant to well. Kinda be little shitheads tbh. First of all they are all canonically made older, and besides the darker themes I think that they are also older to in order to make their actions more conflicting. I do believe that it’s very intentional that these kids are morally quite a bit more grey than the ones in LN.
The ambush sound file is literally children laughing mockingly, and I want to say that this might be because of how the sister saw it, and not that they were necessarily laughing, but it highlights the cruelty of the actions regardless. They used her empathy and compassion against her (caramsels is going to cover this part more in her post and how empathy is seen culturally and technically in statistics a trait associated with femininity)
what separates them from the kids in LN isn’t that they made the wrong choices but that they had actual choices in the first place unlike the children in LN who, by the nowhere itself, are literally set up for failure. The Reanimal kids on the other hand were given the choice to not go through with it, the choice to come clean, and it is their refusal at every turn which makes the lamb grow.
Obviously these are kids. I don’t think they are monsters, but this was also a premeditated action, and really it makes you think above all else though, how awful everything is about their world. Awful enough that they saw what they did to the girl to be necessary. One of hood’s cut lines is even “ what for?” When one of the kids says they’re being punished. I don’t think that this is supposed to make you think that they’re evil and remorseless, I think it’s because ultimately they’re trying to convince themselves what they did was justified, or at least necessary, and I think that’s incredibly sad.
I want to make a second thing clear. All the kids are stated as wanting redemption, they know the did something wrong, but ultimately it’s only the brother who truly makes an effort, yet he still doesn’t come clean. In the cut ending he would of been the only one to stick with her. I also think that his box death could definitely be interpreted as him hanging himself. The boy and the others clearly feel guilt, why else would they not say anything? The sister is very compassionate, that’s shown a lot especially through but dialogue. It’s not like she’s going to kill them in a 1v5, their hesitance to tell her is because they, deep down, know what they did was wrong. But not a single one comes clean, and in the end, the girl is shown what happened, what they did.
She was led out by her brother calling her, she found the little shack, and she found the dead/dying lamb inside. That was the bait, and as she was distracted she was ambushed, and they killed her. But it doesn’t matter now, it’s too late. They’re all dead and gone, nobody can apologize or make it better. It’s over, and the secret has been exposed, and the sheep is free.
Also more of an aside but I do wonder if the girl was originally meant to be stabbed in the eye. Her mask is broken in one area around her eye, and I believe there are some cut lines that hint to this. I think this makes the scene with the whale make a lot more sense too- he’s trying to atone, to fix what he’s done, but he still doesn’t tell her. I could also be absolutely on some bullshit though so like. This is just an additional thought.