Reading some socialist news, most of which I’m on board with, and noticed by he classic throwaway comment that identity politics and proponents of it are to blame for the left’s failures. That the right wouldn’t have the momentum they do if it weren’t for the silly women in gays.
I know the argument is more nuanced than that, and that capitalism and consumerism has created a funhouse mirror version of identity politics that reinforces the worst structures and perpetuates individualism instead of community (plus the in fighting). But a recent citations needed episode really called out left media’s reliance on this myth, which plays right into the right’s hands. I should really finish listening to it as maybe it will help me articulate what I’ve had a icky feeling about in the past. It just seems like the critique is not critique but instead a dismissal of very real violence experience by not white men. And to say that those who advocate for identity stuff are causing our loss in this cultural war is pure none sense, and intentionally or not, seems to have the purpose of upholding the myth that the white cis man is rational and everyone else is frivolous.
just some thoughts.
#identitypolitics #leftism



















