👀 I would LOVE to hear more in the way of trans girl Keith headcanons and how it plays into your characterization. I've been really big on agender Keith for a while, but lately I've also toyed with there being a streak of biker girl in there too, or K lowkey counting Joan Jett as a style inspiration for gender reasons. We all bring something a little different to the characters, and Keith gender stuff is just. Good.
aw thank you for asking! my big old masterpost about it is here, but that’s a bit more like a fic than general headcanons. i cant quite explain why ive always hced her this way, but it is pretty key to my overall interpretation; i think a good amount of it is just projecting my own trans feelings. namely in the sense that, yeah, biker girl/joan jett is absolutely the type of vibe that’s always been on my mind for her, like a ‘girl keith’ would really not look hardly different from canon... but that’s a sort of complex thing when youre trans, right? the pressure on us to play by the rules of gender to prove we ‘really are’ or can ever start to be recognized the way we want. being an effeminate trans guy (as i am) or tomboy trans girl (like keith) is really, really difficult.
and i think that the sort of core questions of keith’s character, “who am i really,” “is it safe to get close to others,” “can anyone understand what i am,” “how can i prove myself,” are like... very trans questions! i wouldn’t say that keith is trans-coded or canonically legible as having a trans narrative, the way i would for pidge, but the sort of... general emotional state? is very much present, for a certain closeted/pre-transition stage especially. trying to reconcile a lot of different ideas and wants within yourself; a certain sort of erratic approach to social relationships (heavily relying on known Safe Persons, anxious avoidance of others); a kind of emotional hyperawareness somehow coexisting with heavy detachment, and the self-flagellation that comes with that state (seen mostly in keith’s vlog, and like, it feels silly to put that much weight on a small additional-content thing, but! it wouldnt have been written like that if it wasnt what we were supposed to be reading into canon!).
i suppose it’s not necessarily a very happy reading of canon, but, keith did go through a whole lot and... not really get any particular resolution. there wasnt really an endpoint to her apparent ‘forging connections with others’ arc besides, like, ‘still a good team with the other paladins! which was established a long time ago! and the bom keith arc, which shouldve been a point of conflict and development, just kinda ended instead of actually resolving!’ yknow. so hey, not my fault. and i do just generally like the notion of keith getting to happily be someone’s girlfriend, and have girl friends. i think that a lot of things about keith are particularly satisfying to have in a female character-- incredible piloting skill, adhd traits, determination, a certain sort of social awkwardness, a repressed emotionality that isnt the “callous” or “doormat” types, a heroic sense of obligation that’s also clearly self-destructive, a cool jacket, a cool knife... not that it’s a substitute for canon female characters with those qualities, we need them plainly visible, but yknow. it’s neat to think about! all the heavy stuff aside, i just Like keith as a girl, and i wish different-gender trans hcs were more common.