HUGE emphasis on your last couple of paragraphs. irt the holocaust, a lot of people seem to think it was a fluke event that’s over now so it’s fine and jews should just get over it. but the holocaust wasn’t a fluke. the fluke was the few decades of the world feeling guilty afterward.
jews have been persecuted, massacred, expelled, and subjugated for over 2000 years in the diaspora. there has pretty much never been a time in history since the roman expulsion where jews have not been oppressed in some way in the places we’ve lived, whether that was being segregated in shtetls or ghettos or living as dhimmis. europe in particular was extremely brutal to jews because of how different we were than the existing european populations. i once spent a depressing afternoon adding up all the known massacres and genocides of jews and it added up to the tens of millions.
so when you think about the holocaust, you cannot start in 1930. you have to start around 70 AD and pay attention to the ways antisemitism morphed and grew over 2000 years, hatred that eventually led to tens of millions of europeans being completely and totally fine with the systematic murder of millions of jews. we weren’t people to them. we were heretics. then we were baby killers. then we were rats. cockroaches. then we were shadowy figures controlling the banks and the media. we were the cause of [insert country here]’s problems, in every era, always. and hitler had a solution.
but that solution wasn’t unique. hitler was far from the first person to say “hmm there’s problems in society. let’s kill all the jews about it.” the holocaust wasn’t unique in its brutality. it was unique in its efficiency. hitler was just doing what gentiles, europeans in particular, had been doing for centuries, but with a lot more technology and resources. there were waves of pogroms in eastern europe leading up to the holocaust that killed upwards of 120,000 jews. the only reason it wasn’t more was because they didn’t have the technology or manpower. the nazis did.
someone mentioned in another reblog that the reason the nazis moved from just shooting jews and tossing them into mass graves was because it was cheaper, but that’s not the full story. the rest of it is that it took a lot of manpower and time to go to all these villages, round up the jews, shoot them, and toss them in a ditch. it was also taking a toll on the soldiers who had to do the killing. the purpose of the gas chambers and the camps was to remove as much human interaction as possible. to automate our deaths. the camps were horrific and brutal, but that wasn’t the primary goal. the primary goal was to kill as many jews as possible as quickly as possible in the most efficient way possible with as little resources and manpower expended as possible.
and when it was all over and two third of europe’s jewish population, one half of the total jewish population, and upwards of 90% of some jewish communities had been completely and totally eradicated, the survivors went home…..and experienced pogroms. their neighbors who had turned them in didn’t want them back so they slaughtered them. or they refused to give back their houses and property and possessions. or the government wouldn’t allow them to come back. these people who had survived hell on earth were faced with further dehumanization. many of whom are still alive today to tell us about it. many of whom wrote extensively about it and have left their stories as their legacy.
and i just….. i wonder if people can imagine what it’s like to live in fear for decades, to try to fight back against oppressive regimes that try to persecute you, then to be carted away in train cars made for livestock, to watch thousands of your people be murdered and burned to ashes, literally watch, to smell and see and walk by a mound of ashes that used to be your mother or your brother or your child. and then somehow you manage to survive, you go back home…and your neighbors drive you out again. you are homeless and starving and have nowhere to go. your family is dead. you have nothing. and every night in your dreams you see a pile of ashes. and then a couple of decades later, people start saying it “wasn’t that bad”, that other genocides were worse, that it was so long ago so why do the jews keep milking it??
the holocaust was the culmination of millennia of oppression, persecution, and genocide against jews that cost tens of millions of our lives. and you really think 80 years is enough time for that to fade from our communal memory and no longer be relevant to us?