So, for those who don’t know, I love making these. It’s kind of my thing. When I love something, I almost feel like it’s my duty to share as much of it as possible and make it easier for other people who love it–or might love it–to find it. A couple years back, I used 8tracks to make a similar, but not nearly as comprehensive, playlist. But it fought me, and now there’s more to add, and I don’t feel like fighting with it again. That said, I bring you this collection of links to anything musical that any Jessie Mueller fan should absolutely hear. This will include YouTube links to official cast albums, videos of some performances, and other links to audio that people have uploaded from concerts and such. Sincerest thank yous to those who uploaded any of these.
I will try my best to keep this updated as I go. Also, if anyone is willing to provide/link to anything that should be on this list, I have a few things I could trade, so come talk to me. Also feel free to check out the Jessie audio tag on my blog for extra goodies.
Italics indicates this is a MUST listen
Carousel [2018] - Julie Jordan
Mister Snow If I Loved You Mister Snow (Reprise) This Was A Real Nice Clambake What’s The Use Of Wond’rin’? Finale: You’ll Never Walk Alone (Reprise)
Waitress [2016] - Jenna Hunterson
What’s Inside Opening Up The Negative What Baking Can Do It Only Takes a Taste You Will Still Be Mine A Soft Place to Land Bad Idea / Reprise You Matter to Me She Used to Be Mine [press preview] [2016 Tony Awards] Everything Changes [stripped with original Sara Bareilles lyrics]
Door Number Three [from the 2015 ART production]
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical [2014] - Carole King
So Far Away It Might as Well Rain Until September Take Good Care of My Baby Some Kind of Wonderful Will You Love Me Tomorrow One Fine Day [at the end] Chains It’s Too Late You’ve Got a Friend [NY Times InPerformance] (You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman Beautiful I Feel The Earth Move
Nice Work If You Can Get It [2013] - Billie Bendix
Someone To Watch Over Me Treat Me Rough ‘S Wonderful But Not For Me Hangin’ Around With You Will You Remember Me?
**Need more from this show
The Mystery of Edwin Drood [2012] - Helena Landless/Miss Janet Conover
Moonfall Quartet Ceylon/A British Subject No Good Can Come From Bad An English Music Hall Out On a Limerick Helena’s Confession
On a Clear Day You Can See Forever [2011] - Melinda Wells
Every Night at Seven [American Songbook performance] [The View, Harry Connick, Jr.] Open Your Eyes You’re All the World to Me Too Late Now [2012 Drama Desk Awards] She Isn’t You/Come Back to Me [Broadway Backwards 2012]
Carousel [Lincoln Center 2013] - Carrie Pipperidge
You’re a Queer One, Julie Jordan (When I Marry) Mister Snow Give It To ‘Em Good, Carrie! When The Children Are Asleep
Into the Woods [The Public Theater 2012] - Cinderella
Prologue: Into the Woods Cinderella At The Grave A Very Nice Prince [ft. Amy Adams] On the Steps of the Palace Act II Prologue: So Happy Your Fault/Last Midnight [ft. Donna Murphy] No One Is Alone
American Songbook at NJPAC
The entire show featuring Jarrod Spector. Songs include:
I Feel The Earth Move/Your Song mashup You’ve Lost That Loving Feeling It Might As Well Be Spring Home/New York State Of Mind mashup You Can Close Your Eyes Go Your Own Way
Pasadena Pops [September 9, 2017]
Thoroughly Modern Millie Home Somewhere Out There [ft. Jarrod Spector]
Provincetown [September 3, 2017]
Shy Vanilla Ice Cream What’s The Use Of Wond’rin’/If I Loved You What The World Needs Now You Gotta Get A Gimmick
[All Songs]
Ella On My Mind–Jazz at Lincoln Center [June 8, 2017]
The Lady Is A Tramp I’ve Got A Crush On You Deed I Do [Ft. Michael Feinstein]
Carnegie Hall [April 21, 2017]
Goodbye Yellow Brick Road Jolene Ain’t No Mountain High Enough [ft. Will Chase, Christopher Jackson, and Adrienne Warren] Sir Duke [ft. Christopher Jackson, Will Chase, and Adrienne Warren]
Chicago Voices [February 4, 2017]
The Prayer & She Used To Be Mine [ft. Matthew Polenzani] My Turn [ft. Shemekia Copeland & Rennie Sparks] On Broadway & So Far Away [ft. Kurt Elling] The People Are Coming Together
The Broadway Musicals of 1946 [February 13, 2012]
Anything You Can Do [ft. Tom Wopat] Bitter Harvest I Got The Sun In The Morning
Miscellaneous
Adelaide’s Lament [Guys and Dolls, Marriott Lincolnshire 2011] Agony [from Into the Woods ft. Laura Benanti, MCC Theater Miscast 2015] A Life That’s Good [ft. Abby Mueller at Concert for America, December 2017] All of Me [Drood cast party, May 2013] Always/Good Night [ft. Abby Mueller at 54 Below, January 2015] Being Alive [from Company] Both Sides Now [Voices for the Voiceless, October 2017] Brave [ft. Sara Bareilles and more, November 2017] Didn’t Leave Nobody But the Baby [ft. Sara Bareilles and Laura Bell Bundy, November 2017] Didn’t See It Coming [demo from Scott J. Campbell’s Periscope, September 2017] For You [The TODAY Show, May 2013] Happily Ever After [from Once Upon a Mattress, Seth Rudetsky’s Not Since HS 2014] Happy Medley [Rosie’s Theater Kids 2017] Help Is On The Way [Easter Bonnett 2013] Humble and Kind [Covenant House honoring Sara Bareilles, May 2017] I Feel The Earth Move [full song at Concert for America, December 2017] Indiana Line [ft. Abby Mueller at City Winery, September 2014] I Will Always Love You [Broadway Dreams Supper, December 2017] Johanna [from Sweeney Todd, MCC Theater Miscast 2015] Star Spangled Banner [NYCFC Game at Yankee Stadium, August 2017] The Blues My Naughty Sweetie Gives Me [Animal Crackers, Goodman Theater 2009] They Can’t Take That Away From Me [ft. Kelli O'Hara and Laura Benanti, Kennedy Center Honors 2015] Tuscany [by Alan Schmuckler for the Chicago Shakes musical Days Like Today] What About Love? [Chicago Shakes Gala 2017 ft. Heather Headley] Where You Lead [Gilmore Girls theme for Buzzfeed, September 2014] You’ve Got Possibilities [Vineyard Theatre Gala 2012]
UPDATED 6.12.18
THIS IS HEAVEN













