Hi, I'm back. I know things became bad towards the ending of Banana Fish. Thanks for withstanding it with all your hearts. I need to say some words myself as a manga reader.
To the people who're calling the ending trashy,
Do you guys understand the definition of Tragedy ? Have you read Shakespeare ? If you haven't then stop talking please. Banana Fish is written in the lights of Shakespearean literature. If you analyze Ash's character carefully, you'll find similarities with Hamlet, just my personal opinion though. But, see how his character developed throughout the show. At first he's obsessed with revenge for Griffin (then Skipper) but soon enough he finds himself in a conflict.
Sometimes he says he's afraid of himself, also sometimes says he's blessed by the love he's experienced through Eiji ( remember his conversation with Blanca ? ).
Well, that's something completely natural to begin with. All of us have two different sides, Chinese call it the Yin and Yang, the dark and the light. Despite everything, Ash is just a suffering adolescent boy who's in a trauma. Eiji's presence somehow made the conflict inside him stronger.
The true beauty of the series is actually the ending. See how peaceful it is.
He's looking above, as if God is smiling upon him. Many of you are saying "he suffered too much, he deserves better"...etc. That's exactly why, he got what he deserved. Here, death is not the fiercely feeling. It's freedom. Ash needed this freedom. He's a murderer too. The world won't give him any sympathy for the crimes he created. There's no place for him. And he can't deny that. Eiji's love can't make his crimes fade away. Cause his body's adjusted itself to murder. Ash hated this self of himself and wanted to be free from the first of the series. At first, it was the freedom from Golzhine, then the agony of Shorter's death, then the trauma of Eiji's injury, his teammates' and Max's capture. Yes, freedom came. Didn't it ? It's the ultimate freedom that gave him rest. That's beautiful. Tragically beautiful. We audience are there for him to cry. But from Ash's perspective, he's completed his purpose of life. Actually, from the first, he never gave priority to his life either. He got his revenge for Griffin, he destroyed project Banana Fish, he got rid of his past , and of course he got the unconditional love from Eiji. That's more than enough for a victim of fate. So he's happy too . The tears he's shading on the brink of death carry both sorrow and happiness. He's sad cause he's dying, he can't ever see Eiji again. He's happy cause he's blessed to recieve the love he always needed. And that made him complete.
The ending is even more beautiful, that Eiji will never see him again (ignore the extra please, I'm talking about the main series). The memory Eiji has of Ash is that of a beautiful, lonely boy. He's returning to Japan with this unique image, not that of the dying Ash. Ash himself would've wanted that too.
That's why, the death is like a savior here. Yes, a savior. From the beginning, there are many ironies in the show which hint the death of Ash, just like the Shakespearean tragedies. Death saved Ash. From the agony of the mundane world. He deserved the rest he always needed. Death gave him his peace. That's why he's happy, he "fell asleep" with a smile.
Lastly : of course we'll still cry for him. For leaving Eiji behind. (TT)(TT)(TT)(TT)(TT)
For me, the saddest moment in the show is this :
Someone not depressed longing for death is a miserable thing. Miserable.