it’s really interesting how the end of the Barry the Chopper episode in 03 seems to contradict the core message/theme of Brotherhood
note: this isn’t a critique of either series or even saying one’s stronger/better than the other here, but of all the episodes so far, I think this is the one that most strongly takes a different stance than Brotherhood/the manga and starts sowing the seeds for how differently the brothers of each series (and their relationship with each other and other people) turn out
so Ed’s just been chased by a madman - armless, unable to defend himself with alchemy, with no one in sight to help him. it’s very, very similar to how Ed’s first introduction to Scar plays out in Brotherhood (and I haven’t gotten to Ed’s realization that Scar is a serial killer in 03, so I literally can’t remember if it’s the same scene or not). in both cases, Ed thinks he’s going to die and in both cases, other people show up to help
but this is what Ed says to Al afterwards:
“When I was certain I that he was going to kill me - my mind went blank, and I didn’t have any hope any more. The only thing I could do is scream my lungs out. I felt so helpless. I couldn’t even bring myself to believe someone might save me. And then you showed up Al. And I realized that if we don’t take care of each other, no one else will.”
and at that last line, it cuts deliberately to this shot of the others watching them
while none of these people helped Ed at that moment, they’re probably (excluding Hughes and Pinako) the people who have most notably helped the Elrics and Ed himself so far.
and yet, Ed dismisses them completely - he doesn’t focus on the other people who have been helping them since they lost their bodies, he only focuses on Al. he literally says that if he and Al don’t help each other, nobody is going to help them - which is clearly not the case. (at the very least Winry should be counted in the people who have helped him, considering she’s his best friend since childhood and helped build his automail, if he wasn’t going to include Hawkeye and Roy, which I can understand)
I’m not sure if the show is agreeing with Ed by putting the others at a distance or pointing out that Ed’s wrong and blind to the people around him - but either way the result is the same: Edward believes it is him and his brother against the world, and the only person he has in his corner is Al.
in Brotherhood, where a very similar scene happens with Scar, the conclusion is different. after Scar is gone, the focus is first on the brothers, but very shortly afterwards is this moment:
we end with the brothers surrounded. they’ve had their moment, their relationship with each other is always going to come first and be the strongest, but ultimately, they’re not alone. there are other people that care about them and want to help - and they know that.
but in 03, we end that scene with the others at a distance and the brothers alone
my main point is that the brothers end up with too very conflicting beliefs in both series that will ultimately shape their relationship with each other (leaning towards co-dependency if they believe they can only rely on each other and only form strong relationships with each other), their relationship with others (much more distant and closed off), and who they are as people
and while I don’t remember everything about how 03 ends and I’m not quite sure where we’re headed, it’s clearly not to the same place Brotherhood left us, because the importance of relying on others and forming relationships is basically the main message in Brotherhood and something the brothers have to learn over the course of the series
but here, we’re headed off on a different and much more bleaker course
this has all been to say that it’s interesting how both series end on a much different note and with Ed coming to a different conclusion, but both execute their respective points well
(side note - it’s also important that there’s literally no focus on Winry and Ed’s relationship during this conclusion, despite the fact she just went through the same traumatic experience with Ed. in fact the only focus is on Winry WATCHING Edward, without him seeming to have any realization that she’s there or cares
because the focus isn’t on Ed’s relationship with Winry - the point is that Ed is ONLY focusing on his relationship with Al. and hooooo boy does that start to show some signs of a very unhealthy relationship indeed)