Remus couldn’t hide his relief when Mary made it clear she wasn’t offended. The last thing he wanted to do was hurt her, especially when she was trying to share something with him that she obviously cared very much about. He just couldn’t bring himself to agree. He always had been nervous, hesitant to toe the line when it came to situations and environments he was unsure of. He smiled warmly at the offer of learning how to swim, wishing it was the happy medium it would be for other people. If he struggled to let the Marauders see the scars on his body when they didn’t need to, he couldn’t imagine feeling any more comfortable in front of Mary, and it would only lead to questions. How could it not? “I’ll think about it?” He tried, being genuine in his offer. It was the least he could do now after such a show of kindness. Mary was an incredible friend, she had never once asked him about his visible scars and he knew she wouldn’t ask him about the ones that she didn’t usually get to see. The thought still made him nervous, but perhaps there would be ways to explain them or draw her attention away from them.
He laughed when she agreed he had terrible luck, glad she was happy to run with the joke. “Exactly, and don’t try and spare my feelings. I don’t exactly have a great track record when it comes to luck. You were doomed the moment you met me.” He smiled when she fell silent for a moment, knowing she was thinking on his words. He wasn’t sure there was any information to reveal, but it would come with time, when she was ready to tell him. Which was why he wasn’t disappointed when she very carefully brushed him off. “And so are you… one of the best.” He assured her, his smile growing as he caught her eye. He wanted to reach out and take her hand, or pull her into a hug, but then they were talking about his mother again and he found himself withdrawing, wanting to avoid the contact if he could. He didn’t feel deserving of it. He didn’t feel deserving of much. “I’m okay… I’ll be okay, we all will.” He said quietly, despite knowing it was a promise he couldn’t make. Lily was losing her mum, and though the doctors couldn’t understand what was causing Hope’s illness, he couldn’t help but feel as though he might be losing his mum too.
Swallowing his emotion, he ducked his head. He wanted to agree with Mary but knowing what he knew, he just… couldn’t. A lot of perfectly sane, capable, and loving parents would have turned their child over to Greyback if he attacked them. That was simply the way of their world. If you weren’t considered Human, you had no worth, and the amount of misinformation was staggering. He had met many witches and wizards convinced that Lycanthropy warped who you were, made you violent and bloodthirsty and dangerous. If your child was bitten, your child was as good as dead. As badly as he wanted to take Mary’s side, he couldn’t see the parents who abandoned their children as bad parents. They didn’t know any better. That being said, it didn’t take away from the sacrifice made by his own parents when they chose to keep him, to work with their new situation, to shoulder some of the blame and do everything they could to ensure he was safe and protected. “That isn’t always true…” He admitted. “But you’re right about Mum and Dad being incredible… everything in my life has always felt so… complicated, but they’ve always been there. Supporting me, keeping me safe. I can’t even begin to imagine everything they gave up just to raise me. Sometimes it feels so- so unfair.”
He glanced up at James again as he continued to walk away, only looking back to Mary when his friend was no longer in his line of vision. He was grateful for the distraction, worried he may have said too much. “Very much so… I think he feeds on attention in the same way a plant feeds on sunlight.” He teased, his smile faltering at the question. He already felt too vulnerable, as though he had given away too many details of his home life. Now he was being asked about his life at school, which was equally as personal. What could he say? Why had he never considered a false answer to the question? He could lie, of course. But he never had been very good at lying. He could deny the nicknames… no, that was stupid. He could pretend he hadn’t heard her… that would only make her more curious. He wasn’t quick witted enough to think up explanations for each name, he just couldn’t do it. But he needed to think of something. He needed to say something. “Oh- I- I don’t know-” Merlin, was that really the best he could come up with? “I mean- it was a long time ago, they just kind of- of happened…” He took a shallow breath, intentionally avoiding eye contact. “Who would believe you anyway?” He tried, offering a half smile in an attempt to draw her away from his vague answer. “I’m supposed to be the one chasing after everyone and keeping them under control.”
Despite her love for sailing, she knew it wasn’t something everyone enjoyed. Water could be as unpredictable as fire could be, and sailing wasn’t exactly a safe hobby. Mary had always been one to push the boundaries, but she knew that not everyone lived like that. Even as she posed the offer, she knew it was unlikely he’d take her up on it, and that was okay. It didn’t bother her in the least bit that this wasn’t something he wanted to participate in. Mary’s offer was genuine, but she could understand some people’s aversion to the water and Mary wasn’t going to push. Nodding, she gave a hum, “You let me know” she replied, wanting him to know that she wasn’t going to push the matter. Mary knew with each of her friends were different and so they needed to be handled differently. With Remus, she knew that sometimes it was just better not to push.
Rolling her eyes, Mary gave a laugh, “Oh please, you’ve hardly doomed me.” Mary didn’t put much stock in luck if she was being honest. Fate had never interested her, and she didn’t believe that someone high in the sky had some grand plan set for everyone. For Mary, actions were what drove outcomes and that luck had nothing to do with it. Grinning, she replied, “Aw, well I’m certainly glad you think so. I plan to keep you around for a very long time Remus Lupin,” she answered. Mary was certain that she and Remus would be friends for years to come, and if she had her way, she would still be by his side after Hogwarts. Her eyebrows knitted together in concern, an unconscious reaction, as she gave a soft hum, “You will be, of course, but it’s okay if you have to break down now and again. If you ever need to talk about it, or just have a good cry, I’m always here. I know you and Lily will both be okay, but that certainly doesn’t mean it will be easy” she reminded.
Mary could see that he was battling his emotions, but she didn’t push him. It was clearly a painful topic and she didn’t want to make it any worse for him. Mary knew that there were cases in which giving up a child was necessary and even the merciful thing to do, but that didn’t necessarily make them good parents. The idea of abandoning a sick child was on the list that made a person unforgivable in her eyes. A parent’s job was to take care of their child and abandoning them because they became ill was essentially the exact opposite of what a parent ought to do. Mary found parents that couldn’t be assed to take care of their kids to be the worst kind of people. Shaking her head, Mary disagreed, “It is. A parent’s job is take care of their child no matter what. Abandoning them because they’re sick or become more difficult to take care of makes them bad parents,” she replied. Her eyebrows knitted together in thought as she tried to work out where Remus was coming from. She couldn’t imagine Remus believing that abandoning a sick child was acceptable, but that begged question, what ailment did? Her mind circled back to her theory, and as he continued to explain she wondered if maybe she was right. What illness would cause him to be in danger and need to be kept safe. Mary pushed her suspicions away and replied, “Well, it’s good they’ve been willing to do all of that for you. You deserve to be loved and cared for Remus.”
Laughing, Mary nodded, “Of course he does. Somehow though, we all still put up with him.” She could see the smile falter and wondered what about the question had him pulling back. Was it the reason for the name or the name itself. Either way, Mary carefully gaged his reactions before she finally got her answer. Remus had always been a shit liar, but this was impressively bad even for him. Mary had to wonder what made him feel the need to lie to her, but she shrugged her shoulders and nodded none the less, not wanting to call him out on it. “Oh, that’s understandable. I mean, I know some nicknames come from the smallest moments and just stick” she shrugged. Mary gave him a smile in return, showing that she wasn’t upset or offended by the obvious lie. “No one, but that’s okay. I wouldn’t tell even if they did,” she teased. Shaking her head, she laughed, “You are, but we all know who is the real mother over you boys”.