Why didnât Durinâs Bane seemingly have any ambition of his own, like his fellow Maiar in Sauron or Saruman? Obviously Gandalf, Radagast and the Blue Wizards all had their own thing going on as well, but the Balrog was seemingly content to chill in Moria for thousands of years, for some reason? In theory, would the Balrog have been cognisant enough to seek rehabilitation in Valinor, as Sauron was offered during the First Age?
Omg another question about Maiar! I could speculate on this stuff all day. Also, I am a Tolkien textwall waiting to happen Iâm so sorry.
So Iâm not sure Durinâs bane would have been offered the same deal as Sauron, and hiding was probably their best bet for not being thrown into the void.
First, Sauron had to pretend to repent to get offered that deal, and there is no reason to believe the Maia later known as Durinâs Bane would have been willing to do that, or that he would be able to pull it off- Sauron being absolutely unmatched when it comes to persuasion is a plot point multiple times, thus âSauron the Deciever.â
Second, even after obtaining mercy Sauron just uses seemingly coming quietly as a smoke screen to escape and do basically the same thing as the Balrog for a while- lay low and lick his wounds.
I do think the Balrog from Moria has more agency than we might think. Theyâre definitely not a brainless monster, itâs just we only see them for like, a page, and Durinâs Bane was a mystery prior to the Fellowship encountering them.
But I donât think itâs unfair to say Melkorâs original Maia might be more intrinsically tied to his will than Sauron, who was originally Mairon, Maia of Aule, and defected in the years of the lamps. At the very least, despite how loyal Sauron was (and he was pretty loyal, he gets Numenor to worship Melkor, not him) he did have thousands of years of existence outside of Melkorâs service, which makes him probably more versed in making his own decisions and plans.
Whereas Melkorâs Balrogs were the Ainur who sang along to his theme of discord in the original music, so they are more directly tied to him, never existed as something not his servant, and I doubt had much hope of not being thrown into the void to join their master, even if they went to Valinor to be judged.
I do have a theory with no real textual support about what the Balrog was doing down there, and it was not just chilling.
I have mentioned this tinfoil hat theory in another post about the âNameless thingsâ that âgnaw at the worldâ under Moria that Gandalf mentions only to be like âbut I am not gonna talk about that.â
So the theory is based on the fact that in the second age, the world is flat. So if you were trying to create a pathway back into the world from the void, down is a legitimate direction to go.
The idea that barriers of the world are thin beneath Moria is really backed up by those nameless things gnawing at existence like parasites down there- if this is a weak spot in the walls of the world, either because of those nameless things or perhaps the nameless things are there because it is a weak spot, then I think itâs very suggestive that the last Balrog, one of Morgothâs original servants, is there.
Trying to make a path back from the void for their master perhaps? And it seems like they might even be making progress if those creatures that are OLDER THAN THE AINUR (Gandalf says they are older than Sauron, and this means they must have dwelt in the void before existence) are slipping through the cracks into Arda.
But then at the end of the second age, the world is made round by Eru Iluvitar. Ostensibly so Valinor cannot be invaded like Numenor is attempting, but why canât it serve numerous purposes? If a servant of Morgoth is close to creating a means for his return at the bottom of the world, folding existence around that point so that now instead of being at the edge of the world they are at the heart of it, with nowhere to go? That solves that problem. And some void creatures, nameless things, get trapped there too.
After all, the sinking of Numenor does feel pretty harsh. If you can sink a continent you can sink a fleet just as easily, and that spares the innocent. Hell, the Valar barred the shores of Valinor on their own in the first age pretty easily, and Numenor didnât have a Silmaril to cheat with like Earendil.
But if there were multiple reasons for the rounding of the world and the sectioning off of Valinor, then Numenor could be a victim of just being too close to the point where the world doubled over itself. Two seas become one with a tidal wave that conveniently drowns Sauron.
Note: I do not think Tolkien intended it to be seen as an overreaction, this sort of thing happens in the Bible Old Testament all the time, and he has a very âtalk shit get hitâ attitude to going against divine power. But it doesnât sit well with me personally if you want me to see Eru and the Valar as compassionate, which he clearly does intend, so Iâm tacking on the idea that the world needed to be round for more than one reason and Numenor was in part collateral damage to preventing the possible return of Morgoth for my own enjoyment of the story. This theory doesnât need this detail to float, but I like it, this entire thing has no proof anyways, and you canât stop me.
It would also make sense that we werenât aware of this, because we are reading about the rounding of the world in the histories of the elves, and this plot to burrow out of the world would have taken place in the dark, with none save Eru the wiser.
So thatâs my completely unsubstantiated take on what the Balrog of Moria was up to. They were digging Morgoth an escape tunnel, were foiled, took their frustration out on the dwarves who discovered their operation, then slept with no better options available than to bide their time. They probably had no knowledge of Sauronâs shenanigans, but perhaps awakening to the greater part of Morgothâs old lieutenantâs power being carried under their nose was enough to stir interest in what was going on in the world.
Certainly if theyâd gotten hands on the Ring middle earth would have been screwed, so moral of the story is:
Glorfindel would have been very useful at this point and itâs hilarious that Gandalf shoots down his inclusion in the fellowship and pats the price by having to fight the Balrog himself.