The stupidest thing about this adaptation is they moved the setting to Seattle and yet people are like âwell Asian people have to earn the roles tooâ (I seriously fucking saw that argument, like somebody actually posted to that to like an i09 comment or something??) and like the reviews are already saying the two white leads are MEDIOCRE in it anyway, so
Lemme point out
1.) The entire US West Coast has a LARGE Asian and Asian-American population, I think the highest out of any US region AT ALL. Like, to the extent Tagalog (a language spoken in the Philippines, for those not familiar with Filipino culture) is the third most common language in California (beaten out only by English and Spanish, people. In Cali-freaking-fornia!). Los Angeles? One of the most goddamn diverse cities/regions in the entire United States, has not just one Asian ethnic enclave, but at least three that I can think of just off the top of my head:
-a Koreatown (suffered heavy damage during the 1992 Riots but still there as I understand it)
- a world fucking famous Chinatown (definitely still there last I checked)
- AND a Japantown (though thanks to WWII-era fuckery, mostly not actually Japanese-populated today as far as living places go, the original Japantown does still have a Japanese temple though).Â
Also fortune cookies were invented, IIRC, in California and I believe specifically in LA??Â
2.) Do you want to know where Seattle is? DING DING. ITâS IN ONE OF THE THREE US STATES THAT MAKE UP THE WEST COAST.
In fact, lest someone even so much as think âokay but you keep talking about California, California is not Seattleâ; ah, no, see, the diversity of California ainât a damn fluke: Seattle has SUCH a high Asian population/Asian influence that there is literally, no joke, a massive store from a Japanese bookseller chain, Kinokuniya, located in it. It includes many many imported books IN JAPANESE, and has been there for YEARS. Years!!! Boba/Bubble tea made it big in Seattle (and possibly LA, not sure which had it first) YEARS before you started seeing it pop up elsewhere, straight up from just the Asian influence on Seattle cafes and restaurants.
3.) Let me repeat that: the CITY IT IS SET IN, IRL HAS A HUGE ASIAN POPULATION/INFLUENCE. And!! This is not even counting the fact that Japanese and Chinese and Vietnamese and Filipinx and Korean and Indian etc etc people live ALL OVER the USA, in fact thereâs a significant Japanese-American diaspora spread throughout the South/Bible Belt of all places, and I went to middle/high school in FLORIDA with:
- a Korean-American girl (cool and confident and witty and stylish af and ridiculously pretty, and boy, I had such a low-key crush on her in hindsight haha)Â
- a Vietnamese-American boy (pretty sure he had ADHD, Predominantly Hyperactive Subtype and I say this as someone with ADHD. Smart. Boisterous. Slightly annoying. Yelled âcut his [thing you donât want cut off] off!â during a field trip to Medieval Times, and got permanently banned from the facility. Fluent in Russian, I think, so he may have had mixed heritage too??)
-a first-gen Chinese-American girl (didnât speak any English at first, I was put in a room with her to try and teach it to her which wtf even I was a KID I had no training?? isnât that what ESOL is for?? Desperately tried helping her learn English by using cartoonish drawings and pictures, and got Very Protective over people being snotty about her pronunciation of âcatâ though I couldnât really do anything about that. I hope sheâs doing well today, she was nice and people kept fucking butchering her name because they didnât even really try :\ She seemed to at least progress through the grades at the same rate I did, since I saw her again in high school, so thereâs that)
- at least two Indian-Americans? (One was named Ravi. He wasnât annoying, kept to himself. Maybe was into anime because kind of all our class was, but not sure? The other I donât think I had too many classes with)
- depending on your definition of âAsianâ, the Saudi Arabian friend I had in middle school counts too (she, like much of the classes I had, liked anime and missed being able to catch it uncut via satellite, because to my surprise, even a lot of pretty raunchy anime was getting translated into Arabic at the time and totally available if you had satellite TV).
âŠsoooo donât tell me that even if it WERE set outside the West Coast (which itâs not!), that you couldnât find it perfectly logical to cast an Asian actor in ANY OF THE CAST WHATSOEVER because that logic doesnât fly but itâs especially STUPID when your setting is off places fucking SEATTLE!
4.) Tldr: this means even if they cast âlocalâ from Seattle, they could probably have gotten an at least decent Asian-American actor, no prob, YET THEY DIDNâT
5.) This also means that if they used any of the major casting/production centers for TV/film in the US - those being Los Angeles (which I have thoroughly covered lol), Vancouver (also on the West Coast, sometimes referred to as âHollywood Northâ, this is where a lot of TV productions like Stargate: SG-1 have been filmed, has its own famous film school and everything, STILL diverse), or New York City (which is LAâs biggest competition for âmost diverse city in USAâ, and has, itself, A WORLD FAMOUS CHINATOWN)âŠAsian actors would have been available if they had bothered to cast them. Yet they didnât.Â
6.) Letâs also point out that people arenât even saying it had to necessarily be a Japanese actor in Specific (though yes, again, SEATTLE HAS A HUGE JAPANESE POPULATION); Asian, period! Over 60% of the world population is fucking in ASIA, do you know how many cultures are âAsianâ?? Give us an Indian-American or Filipino-American Light! Vietnamese! Fucking anything but goddamn white??? Tons of options???
7.)  The idea that an Asian should have to âearnâ a ânon-race-specificâ role MORE than a white actor sounds particularly ridiculous when the reviews Iâve seen seem to indicate that aside from Willem Defoe, the white cast members werenât that great anyway, or at least nothing special. Tell me: WHY does even a half decent Asian actor have to âearnâ that more than a mediocre white one did??
8.) Iâll tell you âwhyâ, itâs because even when the story was Asian originally, people find a way to interpret âwhiteâ as âdefaultâ unless they think they canât avoid it.
9.) To the extent that itâs supposedly âprogressiveâ to their minds, gives them some sort of brownie points, that L was cast as black, when heâs LITERALLY from the sounds of it the only POC in the entire damn cast.  Thatâs not progressive, thatâs better than ânothingâ for POC rep overall, but itâs basically tokenism, which is only marginally better than zero rep, if that.
10.) Which is bullshit. As Iâve pointed out: thereâs no fucking reason for this view in American film and TV. Thereâs NO reason not to have at least ONE Asian cast member. Of any Asian ethnicity/background whatsoever. If they had made him Indian or Filipino-American or Korean-American I doubt people would have complained but no, they just made him fucking white. For no other reason than âwhiteâ is their DEFAULT MODE, even though itâs only ingrained, racist, white-privileging bias that makes it so.
This frankly needs to stop. I forget where but there was a study someone did in relatively recent years, where it was found that even though Asians make up about 5% of the US population (which means about 15 MILLION people), they were represented at a rate of about 2.5% in TV/Film EVEN IN BACKGROUND ROLES.Â
Stop fucking?? Ignoring Asian people in your goddamn casting??? Theyâre more fucking common than you think and you have NO excuse to completely pretend they donât exist in MOTHERFUCKING! SEATTLE!!!
Like, beyond just whitewashing the charactersâŠthey basically whitewashed the setting in order to do that, too. :\