AO3 Penalty Box Comment Fest Masterpost
What is this? While we wait for our beloved (AO3) to return from war (downtime), we’re gonna find ways to connect in community with COMMENTS! Because this fandom is FULL of incredible creators who pour their blood, sweat, and tears into their art. Let’s celebrate them!
What are the dates for this event? This event will run Nov 1st - Nov 30th, barring any extension of downtime.
Week 1: Nov 1st - Nov 8th
Week 2: Nov 9th - Nov 15th
Week 3: Nov 16th - Nov 22nd
Week 4: Nov 23rd - Nov 30th
I’m planning for the worst (4 weeks) and hoping for the best! If, for some reason, downtime extends beyond 4 weeks, I’ll post an update about how to continue. If downtime is over before this event, you can count & submit comments left directly on AO3.Â
What do I do? Just leave comments about Heated Rivalry/Game Changers fanworks. That’s it. We will have a list of creators, where to find their work, and how to contact them, but don’t feel limited by this list! Any comment you leave for a fandom creator’s work during this fest counts. Comments can be on works you've appreciated previously or on new-to-you fanworks that you find during this downtime. Any comment left during the event timeframe counts.
What kind of comments? NICE ONES. ONLY NICE ONES. If I find out you’re sending mean or abusive comments to creators, you’ll be banned. While solicited concrit can be a great and helpful way to engage with fanworks, in this moment and for this fest we are not including it as an option, to avoid the possibility of accidentally hurt feelings. If you need some comment starters, this post) is a super helpful resource.
How are you tracking my comments? I’m not! This is purely on the honor system based on what you submit. If you’d like a spreadsheet to track your own comment leaving, here is one you can use.
Do I have to participate in every week of the fest? No, not at all. Feel free to participate in any and all weeks that work for you. However, if you do participate in all four weeks of the challenge, there’s a badge for that!
How do I sign up as a commentor? Fill out this Google form! Make sure you sign up with a name (NOT YOUR GOVERNMENT NAME) you’ll remember because you’ll need to use it when you log your comments later.
How long are signups open? Signups are open on a rolling basis for the duration of the event, Nov 1st-30th. Feel free to share this event with friends and sign up any time!
What goals should I set? That is totally up to you. This is truly just a fun challenge to try to engage as a community. Every comment you leave is a win. If goals stress you out, you can leave that section blank! If goals are helpful for you, then set something that feels motivating and not overwhelming. Insert “everything's made up and the points don't matter" meme here. But if you do set goals, the spreadsheet will visually track your progress towards your weekly goals and your overall stretch goal with cool-looking progress bars!
How do I submit my comments for tracking? Just fill out this form. Remember to use the participant name you signed up with. You can submit daily, weekly, or on the full moon. Once AO3 is back up & accepting comments in a stable fashion, I’ll announce the final deadline for submission.
Can I sign up as a commenter if I’m a creator? Yes! Please feel free to sign up as both a creator & a commenter!
Prizes? I heard there are prizes! Yes! There are collective prizes for the entire community! Anyone interested in offering a prize can fill out the form here to offer a prize when the community collectively hits target goals. Prizes can be written fic, podfic, fanart, fic covers, playlists, etc. Feel free to be creative!
How do I track my progress? This spreadsheet will show you the leaderboard, your progress toward your personal goals, and the collective progress of everyone participating in the event.
What happens when the event ends? We all rejoice! We will share our totals, celebrate our good work, and smile with the knowledge that we have helped keep each other feeling connected and appreciated during this hard time. Bonus: If you’re up to it, you can leave retroactive comments on AO3, so that everyone who sees the fanwork on AO3 will also get to see your kind words about it!
Who is the man behind the curtain? It’s me, @ao3anyahollanov with lots of help from friends @hailstormtsunami, @podklb, @mistbornhero and more.
I have a question not answered here, who do I contact? Please direct all questions to the @ao3penaltyboxcommentfest ask box.
Creators, sign up to share links to your work & where you are accepting comments HERE
Sign up to offer a collective prize HERE
Sign up to be a commenter HERE
Log your comments left HERE
Tracking spreadsheet HERE