Weaver Week #4 The Greatest of All Time
"The job of arguing with the umpire belongs to the manager, because it won't hurt the team if he gets thrown out of the game." - Earl Weaver
Amen. Carve it in stone. Shout it from mountaintops. This sentence and “Ice Cube’s a pimp” should be the only two things the lights of the Goodyear blimp should ever read.
This is what it’s all about. Captured by serendipitous circumstance because first base umpire Bill haller happened to be wearing a microphone for a local news magazine show.
Top of the first inning. The game, Orioles vs Detriot Tigers at Memorial Stadium in Baltimore, is 9 minutes old.
Orioles pitcher Mike Flanagan is called for a balk. We could get mired in details here, but let’s not. Needless to say, Earl Weaver takes exception with the call and history is made.
"On my tombstone just write, 'The sorest loser that ever lived.” EW
So the balk is called. Hall of Fame first baseman Eddie Murray begins to argue with first base ump Bill Haller, when Weaver just seems to pop into the frame suddenly, Great Gazoo style.
“You’re here and this whole crew is here to fuck us!”
And Weaver gets the heave-ho at the 18 second mark. Props to Haller for his nice form on his double hop ejection gesture. It was as if he needed to get a running start to eject Weaver as hard as he wanted.
What happens next is the textbook example of what they mean when they talk about a manager “getting his money’s worth” after he has already been ejected. It is fair to say that Weaver and all of us who enjoy this sort of thing get a return on his investment that approaches infinity.
Haller, like several umpires in the American League, had a contentious history with Weaver. Haller’s brother played for the Tigers in 1972 while Haller was an AL ump. Weaver kicked up a stink and Haller didn’t work a Tigers or Orioles game the rest of that season. So there was existing beef along with Weaver’s well-established reputation as a world class umpire tormentor.
Weaver was the man who got kicked out of both games of a double header in 1975. (sourced from this excellent obituary from si.com)
He was the guy who once forfeited a game in September because he thought playing conditions were dangerous and he didn’t want to risk injuring any players during the last two weeks of the 1977 season.
Basically he would do anything that he could do to gain the smallest competitive advantage. And he loved to fuck with umpires. Combine the two and he was in heaven.
That’s why at the 31 second mark he acts like Haller hit him with a sledgehammer when his index finger grazes Weaver’s chest.
Honestly, I could not find anything that said whether Weaver was fined or punished by the league at all. Today that hand slap would surely come with a hefty fine and suspension.
Weaver stays in Haller’s hip pocket this entire clip-except for when he walks away and comes right back three times, a masterful touch. Haller thinks he can just stroll around the infield and ignore Earl and he’ll just go away. Maybe I’m not giving him enough credit. Haller probably just hoped Weaver would walk away.
“You do it again and I’ll knock you right in your nose!”
No one says anything like that anymore, and the world is poorer for it. I’m also a a big fan of bygone threats to “dot one’s eye” or bang ‘em “pow! right in the kisser.” Pretty wholesome stuff considering the prolific cursing Earl lays down.
Oh yeah. Did I mention this clip is NSFW? Okay, cool.
After calling each other liars around the pitcher’s mound, Haller returns to his office. And like the angriest little pug in the pound, Weaver comes yapping. Driving his thesis home. That Haller was here to fuck the Orioles, that old Oriole fucker.
From an excellent si.com feature on Weaver in 2009-
“That one with Haller was embarrassing. We both acted like five-year-olds. 'My dad can beat up your dad' kind of thing. It's terrible."
I respectfully disagree. It just gets better.
I love the “you ain’t no good” exchange where Weaver decides maybe he should call the league office about Haller. Fun to think about all the naugahyde and giant green plastic phones and cigarette smoking going on in the American League office in 1980. And I’m sure they got that call.
And then the moment that made me fall in love with this clip years ago. “You look in five, ten years and see who’ll be in the Hall of Fame.”
You have to give it to Haller. He does his best to stay cool and when that fails, he gives as good as he gets. His dig on Weaver about losing three of four World Series he managed clearly stings. And sets up the classic like about winning more that he’s lost.
And at 2:30, when you think he’s gone for real, he comes back to first one last time. Weaver did more encores in this show than Springsteen was doing in 1980.
Just to hammer home his point about Haller’s vicious assault with his index finger. There’s working the umps and there’s torturing them.
No wonder Haller still held a grudge in 2007. According to the si.com profile, Haller said “When the bastard dies, they'll have to hire pallbearers."
Home plate umpire Ken Kaiser, who (surprise) also had a history with Weaver, puts such a nice cherry on top.
“Jesus Christ! We just started this god darned thing.”
So that’s the story of Weaver-Haller. The one that made me get on hip waders and spelunking gear and dig deep through the youtube catacombs for all things related to baseball manager freakouts.
Whoo. I am spent. I shall retire to my quarters to read Weaver on Strategy and drift off to sleep dreaming of three run homers and chewing some umpire ass.