A California State-of-mind
Matt Thompson, International Sales and Buying
(Above: Mountain vineyards in Caiforniaâs Napa Valley.)
âWhatâs the best wine youâve ever had?â
âWhatâs your favourite wine?â
Iâm sure many us have been asked these questions time after time. For me, they are impossible to answer: I could probably tell you the five most memorable wines Iâve ever had, and the style or region Iâm most enjoying at any given time, but never anything as specific as one favourite wine.
However, if it came to the crunch and I could only fill my cellar with wines from a single region, I would answer âCaliforniaâ in a heartbeat. This often raises an eyebrow or two among Bordeaux drinkers, and inevitably leads to questions and statements about style, quality, age ability, Robert Parker⌠Itâs definitely a case of looking beyond the label, literally and figuratively.
Recognising the heritage and spiritual home
The wines of California are too often overlooked or dismissed by those of us who might stick to Bordeaux for their Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot blends. Given Bordeauxâs prestigious history and roll-call of famous Châteaux along both banks of the Gironde, why settle for anything less than Cabs and Merlots from their spiritual home? With centuries of experience behind their belts itâs not unreasonable to suggest the Bordelaise winemakers have the know how to produce the best âBordeaux Blendsâ.
However, there are some interesting parallels between Bordeaux and California. Not only have they played a vitally important role in each otherâs history with the exchange of root stocks and vines, both have bounced back from the brink of devastation. For Bordeaux, it was the devastation caused by the phylloxera pest in the late 19th century that destroyed virtually every vine across Europe and meant replanting the vineyards from scratch. For California, it was a man-made influence that all but killed the production of quality wine, in the guise of prohibition! Before this law was invoked there were incredible wines being produced in the vineyards planted by the 18th century Missionaries, but production came to a grinding halt once prohibition came in to effect. Even when the law was repealed in 1933, economic depression and the impending war meant that the industry remained all but forgotten. However, in the 1960s, riding on a wave of national positivity and economic growth, California began to rediscover its identity and the first generation of wines worthy of their peers in Bordeaux were produced.
David vs. Goliath tasting
The famous (infamous?!) Judgement of Paris Tasting in 1976 proved beyond a doubt that the best Bordeaux blends and Chardonnays could compete with Franceâs elite Châteaux and Domaines, and a string of incredible vintages through the mid- to late-1990s â and eye-catching scores from Mr. Parker â saw the region back in business when it came to fine wine.
Itâs also telling that some of the great producers and Château-owners of Bordeaux have looked West for inspiration in the last few decades. From Baron Philippe de Rothschildâs collaboration with Robert Mondavi to form Opus One and Christian Moueixâs (of Petrus) purchase on the Napanook vineyards to establish Dominus in early 1980s, to Francois Pinaultâs (of Château Latour) much publicised purchase of the Araujo Estate in 2013, the Bordelaise have seen how far the region has come and what a wealth of diversity is on offer.
(Above: Hundred Acreâs Few and Far Between Vineyard)Â
Itâs this final point that has fuelled my passion for the wines of California. With the best will in the World, a drive through the MĂŠdoc doesnât exactly offer a wealth of beautiful views. Itâs essentially a series of rolling, fairly featureless hills and woodland with the occasional, albeit it often breath-taking, Château along the way. It doesnât scream âterroirâ in the quite the same way maybe Burgundy does. However, what a contrast the Napa Valley is: the regionâs vineyards are located within 16 distinct AVAs (American Viticultural Areas â the equivalent of Franceâs AOC system) spread along a 30 mile valley floor flanked by the imposing Mayacamas Mountains to the west and the Vaca Mountains to the east, at elevations of up to 792 metres above sea level. The variation and diversity in soils and microclimates in unimaginably big, and the cooling effect of seas breezes and fogs from either end of the valley add to the winesâ complexity.
(Above: Vineyards on Bordeauxâs Left-Bank)
View More on Napa's Sub-Regions (AVAs) Âť
Howell Mountain AVA - Located above the fog line on the eastern side of the Napa valley, the AVA is warmer and drier than other AVAs. Noted for Powerful, firm, blackberry-currant flavours and good tannins, with excellent acidity for ageing.
Mount Veeder AVA - Cooler climate, with most vineyards above the fog-line, meaning warmer nights and cooler days. Low yields give red wines a firm, tannic structure with strong earth-berry aromas and rich, but powerful flavours.
Oakville AVA - Moderately warm, but also still strongly affected by night and early morning fog, which helps keep acidity levels good. Ripe currant and mint flavours, rich texture and full, firm structure tempered by rich fruit.
Rutherford AVA - Moderately warm, still marginally influenced by early morning fog and tempered by afternoon marine winds. Flavours are full, ripe, and notably currant with firm, but supple tannins for extended aging.
Saint Helena AVA - This, the narrowest part of the Napa Valley floor, is warm, due to greater protection from western hills, with less fog or wind incursions. The wines are deep and ripe, with firm tannins for structure and acid for long cellaring.
Yountville AVA - Moderate, with cool marine influence and fog contributing to cool summer mornings and the strong breezes of San Pablo Bay. Yountville favours Cabernet and Merlot with ripe, violet aromas and rich, but supple flavours and firm tannins.
Throw in significant vintage variations, and youâd be forgiven for wondering what all the fuss was about Bordeaux!
View Vintage Notes 
2009 - âA charmingly irresistible vintage, with plenty of front end-loaded fruit and purity, and the cooler year meant that lots of very perfumed wines have been produced.â - Robert Parker, The Wine Advocate
2010 - âA very cold year, and the harvest dates were pushed back considerably, but there is no question that many of the wines have turned out to be brilliant. This should be a long-lived vintage.â - Robert Parker, The Wine Advocate
2011 - â2011 is the most site specific vintage I have tasted in Napa. One big advantage of 2011 is that the successful wines are very precocious and evolved with soft tannins and low acidity. The best of them are endearing, charming wines.â - Robert Parker, The Wine Advocate
 2012 -âA great vintage that appears to be a no-brainer. Not a hot year by any means, this is a vintage for followers of classic, big, fruit-dominated Napa wines.â - Robert Parker, The Wine Advocate
Thereâs also a great sense of freedom, passion and adventure in California that is expressed in the wines and the winemakers â a level a charm and bonhomie thatâs rare to find in other corners of the globe. For me, the combination of history, innovation and ever increasing quality is irresistible.
So, whatâs the best wine Iâve ever had? Iâd be hard pushed to choose between Château Margaux 2009, Hundred Acreâs Ark Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 and Leflaiveâs Le Montrachet 2011. Or maybe Harlan Estate 1996⌠Or maybe Château Mouton Rothschild 1986⌠or maybe VĂŠritĂŠâs La Joie 2008 (I think you can see where this is going)âŚ














