Please bear with me- I started dancing about 11 years ago, but haven’t moved into open or anything (because I sucked for the first few years, and I still suck at timing and rhythm; maybe I’ll begin getting my firsts in Prizewinner this year?). I’m mostly going off of what other people have said, and what I’ve observed.
I think it isn’t just the dresses that have changed, but the style of dance itself. One of my TCs was talking in class a few months ago about how it’s all about the tricks now- who can come up with the best, most amazing tricks in their steps, and execute them best (he was talking about how someone broke their ankle almost a decade ago adding something into her step (on stage at a major) that should be physically impossible, and how he now sees many people doing the same movement without doing so). It makes sense, since dancers have also become better and closer to “the perfect irish dancer”, and need something more to catch the judges’ eyes, but I think this is also really important to think about. He was talking about the tricks in terms of pushing bodies past what they should do, without intensive training, and sort of comparing dancers then to my dancing now, and the dancing of everyone else in my class a while ago. Apparently, if there was a time machine, the dancers from back when I started dancing would look like a Novice/Prizewinner compared to champs today (which I think he meant as a compliment to me, as though to say I would have qualified for something if I had started a decade sooner), due to how much better dancers have become. This is sort of proved by the steps I’ve been learning, in that I can look up recital videos from when I started, and see the champs doing earlier versions of some of the steps I’m now learning, or learned in the past. There were definitely fewer steps available to learn at my dance school in the grades when I started compared to now. I’m probably about on-par with some of the champs of yesterday, but then, I go to feisanna, or even just class, and see other people’s dancing, and suddenly neither those role models’ dancing nor my own looks that good anymore.
Which, it’s great that so many people are trying to better the art form, and so many champs look amazing. But, like the dresses, I think we really should take care to make sure that it doesn’t become so different that it would be unrecognizable, or more easily recognized as another type of dance, or at least realize that is possibly what we are doing to Irish dance.
I doubt those girls in ages past with hair combed and curled for Mass, dressed in their Sunday best, would recognize what Irish dance has turned into with CLRG. I’m not saying I hate what it has turned into- quite the opposite, I love dance- just saying it is different.
And I’ve lost my train of thought for this post… I guess I’d just like people to think about the changes in the actual art form as well, since people often bring up the wigs, the dresses, the spray tans, the crystals, etc, but don’t often mention how very different the dancing itself is from how it used to be.