I saw the confession on the jwcc-confession blog about Brooklynnās prosthetic, and I completely agree with them. There has always been something off about that plot line to me, and itās just because itās an ableist take.
But itās not ableist because the story itself is ableist, itās ableist because, from my research, Brooklynn is the franchiseās *first and only* physically disabled human character that could use and has used a prosthetic.
Sheās the first, of hopefully many, and they decided to start off with a prosthetic being forced onto her by the villain and associating the device itself with the evil, morally wrong side. They turned it into a symbol of how deep into the gray Brooklynn was, and thatās part of the problem.
It is important to show ableism, especially the harsher realities if it. Iām disabled myself use mobility aids on and off, and Iāve been forced into treatment that wasnāt helpful and only further traumatized me, so I do understand the need for this kind of representation, but it has to come in layers, especially for franchises.
The first physically disabled character that they couldāve given a prosthetic should not have been the one used to show how treatment and aids can be forced or pressured onto someone without any room for them to breathe or make a decision, and their rejection of that treatment and/or aids shouldnāt have been be part of the climax.
For a comparison, imagine if they went a similar route with Yasmina, having her forced into therapy, fully admitted against her will, only for it to have hurt her more.
Would it have been realistic? Yes.
Should it be the story of the first and only character from that group youāre representating? Absolutely not.
There were other ways to introduce the idea of Brooklynn using a prosthetic for that season without having the prosthetic itself be solely associated with the evil side. She couldāve conned one out of Santos, so at the very least it was her idea, either because she was testing the waters of what she could get from her or because she genuinely wanted it, and then have Santos hold it over her head later and display the exact same ableist behavior, like pressuring her to wear it more. Brooklynn wouldāve had control, lost it, and then the mobility aid becomes a device for Santos to exert dominance and control over her, except itās not done in a way that villainises the mobility device itself and that way her ditching it later wouldnāt have felt so off and anti-prosthetic.
And if they absolutely had to go with the āit was forced on her, she had no choice,ā plot, they couldāve had an extra with a prosthetic to show that itās right for some people, but not others, and maybe not for her (either right now or ever).