Anything But This
Request: hi! Could you write a Boromir x fem! reader where Boromir thinks that The reader is in love with Faramir but she actually likes him
A/N: Hello! Some love for my man Boromir, hope you enjoy it!
Boromir x Reader
Fem reader
No content warnings
3.5k words
---
The late afternoon air was cool and carried the sharp, almost sweet scent of oncoming rain. The colourful market awnings stood bright against the grey sky. Thunder rumbled in the distance while the shopkeepersâ voices called over one another. You nudged Faramir along, your elbow knocking into his, while his eyes scanned the wares on display.
âFaramir, it is no use. We have searched for nearly an hour now,â you said, throwing up your hands. âPerhaps we should come back next weekend.â
âDo not fret, my lady. There are still a few more stalls yet. I am certain you will find something for my brother.â
You sighed but continued on down the long street. Boromirâs birthday was in less than two weeks and despite your best efforts, you were yet to find a gift for him. What could you give to a man who could have whatever he desired? What could a lady of your station give him that he could not already acquire himself?
âWhat about painting him something?â Faramir suggested as you turned away from another stall.
You shook your head. âI still have to finish the one I am working on now.â
You thought back to the day you had met the brothers. Faramir had heard about you from one of his page boys and had summoned you to the Citadel to paint a portrait of them together. Faramir was handsome enough, but your heart had nearly stopped when you saw Boromir.Â
It was torture, trailing your eyes over his broad shoulders, fixating on the way his tunic hugged his form, staring into his proud grey eyes trying to mix the right shade to capture them. He seemed stiff and uncertain during the first session with Faramir when you sketched them out, but he warmed over the various sittings.
When you were painting the details of his face and clothes, he had sat alone for you, talking while you mixed colours or cleaned your brushes. How strange, how sweet, to see Boromir, the stern Captain of Gondor, lay down his steely exterior. You delighted in the way his eyes would light up when he spoke of the battles of old, how his whole demeanour changed when he laughed, how he would tell you stories of his army misadventures.
There had been a few times where you needed to straighten his tunic, or reposition his arm, and his nearness was almost too much of a distraction. You could feel the heat radiating from him, smell his scent of cedar and musk. How your fingers longed to touch more than the fabric of his sleeve or the back of his hand.Â
You had tried to paint slower, to make mistakes with the colour, but there was no escaping the fact that the portrait would be finished soon enough. And with that, your time with Boromir would come to an end. Your stomach lurched. Boromirâs birthday was perhaps the last time you would see him.Â
You groaned as the end of the market street drew near. âI fear I will have nothing to give him.â
âI would not say that.â A smile played about Faramirâs lips and you arched your eyebrow at him. âI could not help but notice that you call Boromir to sit for you far more frequently than you do me.â
Heat rose to your cheeks and you glanced away. âI do not know what you are implying.â
He chuckled. âNothing, except that I do not believe I have seen my brother in such high spirits as I have seen him these past few weeks.â
Your heart sped up. Was it possible that Boromir felt the same for you? Or perhaps he had simply been happy to enjoy the company of a new friend. âYou⌠you must be mistaken.â
Faramirâs voice softened. âI know my brother. He has been climbing trees and chasing things since he was young. He must truly enjoy your company for him to sit in one place for such a long time.â
âWe are simply friends. Of a sort.â You sighed and crossed your arms. âIt does not matter.â
âWhy do you deny what is so plain to see?â
You thought of all the ladies you saw around the Citadel and the higher circles. Such sumptuous silks, such clean, pretty hands. They were befitting of Boromir's station. You had heard the whispers among the halls, overheard the quiet words in the courtyards â you were fortunate enough to even have the friendship of such a noble family. It would be foolish to think that he could ever be with you, a common painter.Â
âFaramir, I am not of noble birth.â
âSuch things do not matter, not to Boromir and not to me.â
âThey will not allow ââ
âWho?â His words were sharp but his eyes were kind. âThere is only Boromir and I left in our family, and I certainly do not object.â He placed a gentle hand on your arm. âI would be proud to call you âsisterâ.â
Honour and gratitude swelled in your chest and your bit back the tears forming in your eyes. âBut King AragornâŚâ
âAragorn and Boromir have been through much together, and Aragorn of all people will not stand in the way of love. He will not deny the both of you either.â
Your heart swooped and you could not help but smile. It was possible, truly possible, for you to be with Boromir. But could you be certain of Faramirâs words? What if he was mistaken about Boromirâs feelings? The churning in your stomach started up again.
Your eyes roved the last few stands and you paused, catching sight of some carvings at a nearby stall. The spoons were beautifully carved, their handles even more so. Hearts weaved in and out of each other, a dove fluttered above a bell, grapes on vines curled up to blooming flowers.
âLovespoons,â you breathed, tracing your fingers over one with two interlocked hearts. They were common among the regular folk, a heartfelt and inexpensive token someone could present to their lover.Â
âI dare say you have found a suitable gift.â Faramir grinned at you and you smiled back.Â
âWill you help me select one?â
He laughed and patted your hand. âI am not professing my love to Boromir. You pick which speaks to your heart.â
Your eyes drifted to one in the corner. It was less adorned than the rest, with twisted stems that led up to a single heart. An intertwined life, one love, one heart. You picked it up, and the anxious hum under your skin settled.Â
This would be the one.Â
-
Lightning cracked across the sky and thunder rumbled above. Rain mingled with Boromirâs sweat and dripped down his face. He took a vicious swing at the dummy with the wooden sword and let out a roar. His arms burned and his hand stung with blisters, but he carried on attacking the dummy, hoping that each strike would clear the images that had plagued him for the last few days.
You and his brother, looking at lovespoons. Together.Â
He was supposed to sit for you that afternoon, but you had sent him a note an hour beforehand saying that you could not make it. He had sought out Faramir, wanting to alleviate his boredom, but had found his brotherâs rooms and the stewardâs office empty. Restless and unsettled, he had wandered through the city, until he saw you and Faramir in the distance.Â
The memory stabbed at his heart and pierced the dummyâs straw body. What could he do? His brother loved you, and who could blame him?
It had been so easy to fall in love with you watching you work. Passion burned in your eyes, your gaze soft but keen as it swept over him. Your hands were swift and confident, capturing his likeness in a way that felt natural, creating textures on the canvas that he did not think possible.
You were so beautiful in the morning light you enjoyed painting in, the soft yellow glow seemingly radiating from within you. And the stories you told about yourself captivated him. How you covered the walls of your family home in murals, how you once travelled to Dol Amroth to find seashells to make a new pigment, how you would paint portraits of dogs or cats that have passed to ease the suffering of their owners.
Each time you requested he sit for you, his heart would leap in his chest, and more than once he had to hide the heat rising in his cheeks from you. There was a time where he thought that perhaps you returned his feelings, but alas⌠He must have misread the looks you gave him, mistaking gentle observation for tenderness, mistaking genuine smiles with ones borne of politeness. And your touches, the ones he secretly coveted, the ones where he would wrinkle his shirt or mislay his hand for, they were nothing more than that.Â
Perhaps the reason you called him in more than Faramir was simply because he was more difficult to capture. Valar knows his armour has more small parts and embellishments than Faramirâs stewardâs uniform. Maybe all the time spent talking was simply you wishing to know him better, the brother of your lover.
Lover. The word sat like a black stone in his chest. He growled and drove the sword into the dummy again and again.Â
No, he would not tell Faramir of the pain in his heart, of the love he had lost. He knew his brother well, and Faramir would forever look upon him with guilt and pity in his eyes. No, his brother had suffered far too much, especially at the hands of their father. Let him have his love unhindered.Â
Boromir would cope. He had to, somehow.
Your laugh rang out across the small courtyard and his head snapped up to the sound. You were walking with Faramir under shelter, your eyes bright and your lips parted in laughter. His heart wrenched and he glanced away. Hopefully you and his brother would pass quickly. He did not need the sting of your presence, the reminder of everything he could not have.Â
âBoromir!â you called.
He tried to keep his voice even when turned and spoke. âYes, my lady?â
âFaramir and I were wondering if you would like to see the decorations in the hall.â You glanced behind your shoulder to where his brother stood just a few steps behind. There was a small smile on his face and fondness in his eyes.Â
âNo, I⌠I am certain whatever you and my brother have come up with will be sufficient.â
Your expression dropped and you shifted on your feet. âIs anything the matter, Boromir? When you sat for me the other day you⌠you left early.â
It had been too much, to sit there under your stare, to watch your hands and your eyes and your lips. He had faced hoards of Uruk-hai, battled oliphants on Pelennor, faced the Enemy at hellâs gates, but you⌠you just a few metres away, beautiful, untouchable⌠it had been too much. Was this what his men meant when they said that love brought people to their knees? He had sat there, still and stiff, begging, pleading in his mind for some sort of relief from the images that sprung to it each time he looked at you.Â
âI have been occupied recently. The guards require my attention.â He glanced at Faramir, whose brows were drawing together. Could his brother see the love plain on his face? He would need to be better at disguising it. âI trust the both of you.â
You opened your mouth and snapped it shut again. âI see⌠Perhaps⌠Would you like to dine together this evening? When we have finished with the preparations?â
He could not endure an entire evening with only you and Faramir. To see the love in his brotherâs eyes that he himself could not show, to see your warm smiles directed at another, to bear witness to your loving touches. No, he could not abide by that torture.Â
He shook his head. âAnother time perhaps. You should go, my brother is waiting.âÂ
âBoromir ââ
He turned away, finger tightening around the sword. âGo.â
-
The small hall was alight with candles and lanterns. Bunting was strung up between the pillars, the bright colours stark against the black and white stone. A quartet of musicians played a cheery tune that some were dancing to in the middle of the room. You skirted the edges of the crowd, offering polite smiles to those that recognised you, searching for Boromir.Â
He seemed strangely intent on avoiding you for the last few days, spending most of his time in the army barracks where you were not allowed to go. Unease sat in your stomach and you fisted your dress. Was Faramir wrong all along? Perhaps Boromir truly did not have any affection for you. But what of those shared looks, half-hopeful and hesitant? Maybe you simply envisioned it, put meaning to something simply because it was what your heart longed for.Â
You sighed. The portrait was finished. Tonight would be the last time you would be able to see him. There would be no more excuse to go up to the citadel, no excuse to see him in the week. Faramir had said you were welcome to visit whenever you wished but it would be too painful to walk the rooms and corridors, Boromirâs absence reminding you of the love that was not yours to have.
You craned your head around the mass of bodies and found Faramir was standing by the door that led out to one of the side gardens, a worried expression on his face.Â
âFaramir, is anything the matter?â
âIt is my brother,â he said, sending another furtive look outside. âHe has been remarkably sullen this whole evening. And he usually loves his birthday celebrations.â
âHe has also been avoiding me,â you sighed. âI fear there is something bothering him. Do you suppose it could be me?â
âWhat do you mean, my lady?â âWhat if I have made him⌠uncomfortable with my attentions? Perhaps he realised that I could have misunderstood the closeness between us and this is his way of quietly turning me down?â
Faramir shook his head. âI have never known my brother to do anything quietly. Especially for something such as this. He would be direct, even if it was hurtful, so as no misunderstandings would occur.â
You glanced at the dim garden. âWhere did he go?â
âHe said he wanted to get some air. I thought of giving him some time before going to speak to him. I hope he has not already escaped to his rooms.â Faramirâs mouth tightened. âPerhaps you should go find him. I think you will be better received than I will.â
You touched the lovespoon in your pocket, feeling it through the fabric, and nodded. You wandered out into the night, wincing a little at the cool breeze that swept through the garden. The noise of the crowd ebbed away and was replaced by rustling trees and chirping crickets. Sand crunched under your slippered feet as you walked down the path that winded through the tall hedges and shrubs.Â
You rounded a corner and found Boromir standing by one of the trees, head tilted back to look at the stars. There was a look in his eyes. Resignation and anguish, weariness and fatigue.
âBoromir?â you called softly, afraid of startling him. He turned his stormy grey eyes on you and you hesitated. âIs⌠is something the matter? You are missing your party.â
âI am in no mood for celebrations,â he muttered, voice distant and bitter. He shook his head and cleared his throat. His voice was gentler when he spoke again. âDid my brother send you to find me?â
âYes⌠No, well I⌠I was looking for you and he told me where you were.â
He shook his head and glanced away. âI suppose I should get used to the notion of the both of you together.â
Get used to it? What did he mean? Tonight would be the last time you would see either of them regularly, if at all.
âForgive me, my lady. My mood has left me ill-mannered.â He gestured towards the path. âI am not much for conversation tonight. Please enjoy yourself this evening.â
You took a step towards him. âBoromir, what did you mean? About getting used to Faramir and I together.â
His eyes cut back to you, pained and guarded. He let out a puff of air before he said, âYou and my brother. Now that the both of you areâŚâ He swallowed.
âI donât understand.â You reached a tentative hand out and he stepped back. Your heart lurched. He had never recoiled from your touch before.
âFine. I will speak plainly then, as much as it pains me, but I must ask you spare Faramir of the truth.â His voice grew hard and stiff. âI will admit to harbouring feelings for you.â
Your heart thudded in your ears. Feelings? Boromir returned your feelings?
âAnd as much as I am happy that the both of you have found your joy,â he continued. âI must confess it causes me great suffering to ââ
âBoromir,â you said. âFaramir and I are only friends.â
He frowned and crossed his arms. âI do not appreciate being lied to. I saw you that day at the markets, looking for lovespoons.â
You shook your head at him and reached into your pocket. You presented the spoon to him with a small laugh. âIt was for you.â
His jaw grew slack and his shoulders dropped. âFor⌠me?â He unfolded his arms and took it from you. He ran his fingers over the wood, tracing the intertwining vines.Â
Such beautiful hands, such lovely fingers. And yours, finally yours.
âDid you truly think that Faramir and IâŚ?â
âI do not know,â he whispered, pressing a soft kiss to the wood before tucking the spoon into the breast pocket of his doublet, right above his heart. âI could not think of any other reason why two people would look at lovespoons together.â
âI was searching for a birthday gift when we chanced upon the lovespoon stall.â You reached out, your hand hovering in the space between the both of you. He grasped it, his warm fingers curling around your own.Â
He drew you in and his other hand came to rest on your waist. His scent enveloped you and inhaled, melting at his familiar smell. You caressed his cheek, his beard rough under your fingers, and he grinned at you.Â
âFor so many days I have lived in agony, wondering how I should live watching the two people I love most in the world love each other.â
âWhy did you not say anything until now?â
âHow could I? It would have done little good.â
âAnd you would have suffered in silence?â
âFor you and Faramir, I would do anything.â His hand slid up your arm to your shoulder. He cupped your face and swept his thumb over your cheek. His eyes shimmered in the low light, tender and naked in their affection. âYou are so beautiful. For so long I have wanted⌠wantedâŚâ
He leaned down and you tilted your head up. His lips were warm and soft, and his exhale was hot on your skin. He tugged you closer and deepened the kiss. You could taste the tartness of the wine lingering on his lips, the sweetness of the berry pie, and something that was distinctly him. He was solid against you, his chest broad and firm, searing even through the layers of fabric.Â
You drew back and took a breath, flushed and dazed. He chuckled and nudged your temple with his nose. âShould I have known how good you taste, I would have kissed you earlier.â
You laughed and buried your face in his chest. âI would have never finished the portrait then.â
âThen you would have more excuses to come see me.â
âDo I need excuses to see you?â
He shook his head and pressed a kiss to your forehead. âNo, not ever. Speaking of excuses, we should rejoin the party. Our presence will be missed, I think.â
âI think we are more in danger of Faramir finding us⌠occupied.â
He laughed, a deep, warm sound, and led you down the path. âA terrible fate for him, I should think.â
The sounds of the party grew louder and when the both of you emerged from between the hedges, Faramir was standing outside by the door.
âThank Valarâ he said, a soft smile on his face at the sight of your joined hands. âI was going to send one of the hobbits after you. I thought something truly unfortunate must have happened.â
âNo, brother,â Boromir said, slinging an arm around Faramirâs shoulder. âI think I have been given the greatest blessing of my life.â He knocked his head against Faramirâs. âAfter you, of course.â
âWas your ill-mood simply due to pining? It felt too thunderous for it to just be that.â
You shared a look with Boromir and he shook his head. âI will explain another night, little brother.â
Faramirâs eyes darted to you, eyebrows raised in silent question. You laughed and tugged them forward. âWe can talk later.â
âTonight,â Boromir said as he released Faramir and bumped his shoulder, his smile wide on his face, âwe celebrate!â


















