Letâs talk about those Raven Boys
So, I said I was going to do some book reviews, and I lied, itâs not really book reviews, itâs more like âbook ramblings.â
Letâs talk about those Raven Boys.
In early January, I *devoured* Maggie Stiefvaterâs Raven Cycle (the Raven Boys/The Dream Thieves/Blue Lily, Lily Blue/The Raven King). So, to get it out of the way, these books are so, so enjoyable. Itâs one of those worlds where you just want to live there and be with the characters and read about them going to, like, the grocery and stuff. These books got me through the social anxiety of a week-long work conference. They are *electric*.
But are they good? Well⌠itâs not great literature. Itâs more like⌠extremely good fanfiction. And donât get me wrong, thatâs a good thing in its own right! Itâs just different. Is this the next Earthsea? No. Should you read it? Absolutely. So we can talk about it. (My husband is in the middle of a different book series, and I canât get him to read this and it is k i l l i n g m e.)
Anyway, itâs about a spunky heroine who comes from a family of psychics, but is not herself a psychic. She finds herself mixed up with a found-family of private school boys looking for a sleeping king in the forests of Virginia. Itâs teens, itâs ghosts, itâs NERDS, I love it.
Now Iâm going to talk about the things I want to talk about, but itâs under the cut for spoilers.
So, here are some of the things that bothered me:
- The books are really pretty white. The is one black character (who I didnât realize was black until the second book) and a group of Koreans later on. They are enjoyable characters, but Calla isnât given a big enough role for my tastes (especially compared to Maura and Persephone⌠I felt like the three of them should have had very balanced roles), and Henry never quite seems to penetrate the core group of characters.
- Adamâs resistance to taking âhand-outsâ from Gansey and Ronan got real old, real quick for me. The two of them inherited wealth from their parents. Ronanâs dad *made money from his dreams*. They didnât do anything to deserve their money any more than he deserved his poor circumstances, and if I were one of the richer boys, I would have felt extremely judged by that.
- Artemus was extremely disappointing. I wanted to know more about what Maura saw in him in the first place. To be honest, I was really, really hoping for a meaty flashback about everything that went down. His wishy-washiness sort of conveniently bypassed any tension vis a vis Maura and the Grey Man, too, and I felt that was a loss.
- Speaking of the Grey Man, his entire character and presence in the book should have been ridiculous and yet it -worked and I loved him. Likewise, Ganseyâs willingness to talk about dead Welsh kings with like, the mailman. It was great. I loved it.
- Okay, with that out of the way, here is my biggest gripe. This is super-spoiler level, so if you havenât read the books, go read them and come back.
I didnât like the end. Sometimes ends of books really piss me off, and it wasnât that bad. I just didnât like it, and the longer I thought about it, the less satisfied I was. Gansey sacrificed himself to save Cabeswater, but then Cabeswater sacrificed itself for Gansey? Sacrifice endings are a Big Deal to me, and I hate when people get out of them. Sacrificing Cabeswater was a big deal, it was a sacrifice, so it wasnât as disappointing as some other works of literature I will name, but⌠but what if Gansey had never looked for Glendower in the first place? None of this would have happened, right? What even was the point of all these? Did these boys just destroy a pocket of magic in the world because they couldnât leave well enough alone? Also, so many other characters died. Why are we supposed to care about Gansey more than, say, Persephone or Ronanâs mom or any of the trees in Cabeswater? I love my preppy, anaphylactic nerd-boy son, make no mistake there, but I was basically ready for him to die, really die, at the end.
But here is the worst part, the thing I am maddest about: When we first âmeetâ Gansey, Blue asks him his name and he replies, âGansey. Thatâs all there is.â This line is *haunting*. His affect as a ghost is SO unlike Gansey as a living person. As a ghost, he shows no recognition of Blue, despite the fact that he loved her and she killed him (also, I expected the prophecy to be more like⌠she kisses him and then he dies later, I did not expect her to kill him *by* kissing him. That wasâŚsomething). I expected his death to be a Big Epic Deal full of Teen Emotions and Magic and Shit. I expected him to lose part of himself, I expected âthatâs all there isâ to take on more meaning. And that didnât happen. The ending was just⌠about what you would expect. I was ride or die for Gansey and Blue up to this point and honestly, I just feel let down.
It wouldnât have been so disappointing if the book werenât otherwise so enchanting, and I hadnât been so utterly drawn into it. (Although it had that problem throughout. I got to end of the first book and said to myself, âWow, what an amazing book! Except that basically nothing actually happened.â) Maybe people who are 36 shouldnât read books for teens. Maybe.
Anyway, if you love Supernatural Teens as much as I do, you will have a good time reading these. Then letâs talk about them. I have opinions.