I've been thinking of getting into a LitRpg book. But I also really don't want to cause I feel it proliferates a "everything is videojame" attitude. Like stats for DND are there to help us understand limitations and of course it is a game. And even in video games, the stats aren't like "cannon". They are a way to give the player control in some aspects, and help them understand abilities/limitations, for the sake of optimizing gameplay. But reading isn't gameplay. And I want to be immersed. I want the magic to feel like if ____ was true, this is possible. While yes I love hard magic, this doesn't mean that soft magic cannot also achieve this. Most of the time, if we are being honest, soft magic systems aren't totally soft, there are hard aspects, and then soft aspects to encapsulate wonder and whatnot. Think Gandalf vs the one ring. The one ring has obvious and repeatable consequences/benefits. Gandalf, while not breaking immersion, doesn't really have these same rules.
But LitRpg to me, just feels like a breeding ground for unchecked power fantasy, that doesn't have a point other than surface level gratification. My guess (I have really no data for this as I haven't read one) is that the genre is a power scalers wet dream. And one of the main reasons I started reading epic fantasy instead of watching shonen anime, was to avoid power scaling fantasy as much as possible. (I truly detest it, I think it's a breeding ground for fascistic thinking and 'might makes right' philosophy, along with undermining good story telling. For everyone who thinks I'm wrong, how many people will say they hate Legend of Korra because she's weak and would "totally" lose in a fight with Aang, as if that is even a valid line of thinking/questioning.) But again I haven't read one, it's just people seem to always compare them to shonen, and unfortunately that's kinda a staple of the genre.
I want to read one, because I want to see if there's anything interesting there, or if I'm wrong and it could expand my horizons. So please give me a recommendation. I know about Dungeon Crawler Carl, I'll get to that one but I'm really not interested in a comedy book, especially not right now. I want a somewhat hard to read, deeply philosophical/political work that challenges my thinking. To me, those are my favorite books. Something akin to Suneater/Dune, or an R.F. Kuang book, or The Deavabad trilogy. Or even something a little lighter like a cosmere book (I realize that may sound wack). Also I'm not entirely against comedy, big fan of the Locked Tomb series, very funny, still challenging, especially Harrow the Ninth. I'm personally just not interested in "turn your brain off shlock", if I want that, I'll just watch some T.V. or like a marvel movie. If y'all have any ideas let me know, cause I'm too lazy to research this. I would rather go through my TBR of books I know I will likely enjoy or at least think critically about, rather than spend my time digging gold in a proverbial landfill.














