You made me nervous. Every conversation we had, I was always worried about the phrases I used, whether my accent would be noticeable when I said specific words or if the ideas that sounded intellectual in my head were just straight bullshit when I said them out loud.
I don’t want to make excuses but I developed a sort of wall. When I allowed myself to be free in front of him, when I showed my vulnerability, my insecurities and my passions, he took them for granted and showed no appreciation for them. It made me worry if anyone ever would. So, I convinced myself I wasn’t special. I didn’t have much to offer and from that moment on, I kept all my most intimate thoughts and feelings in my head. You didn’t though. You threw those words around so easily it made me anxious. It was “I love you” every time you said goodbye, and at random points in a conversation. I questioned whether you knew what those words meant, and if they had any value to you.
I always felt like I tricked you into liking me. I still believe that you never had a genuine interest in me and that you simply went along with the situation because it was convenient. That’s why I was always so push and pull, because I never felt that you had the overwhelmingly consuming feelings I did. I went months suppressing the attraction I had towards you. I naively hoped you had mirrored me in that sense, but that was not the case. I don’t know if your treatment was a method to infiltrate my mind in order for you to be able to manipulate me or if it came from a genuine place, but that uncertainty always scared me. That’s why I always rejected it, because I was scared it all part of some overly elaborate joke.
I pushed you again. This time I didn’t pull, but neither did you. Instead you turned around and left. I don’t want this to come off the wrong way but, all I know is that, when I was fifteen, my mind was somewhere else. If I had a boy like you approach me at that age, then my self-esteem would’ve sky rocketed. Not because I had any genuine feelings towards him, but because what he represented. I would have accepted any boy who was older, smart, funny, passionate, well-mannered, like you at that age for no other reason other than the pride that he instilled in me. I don’t mean to claim that she feels the same, I’m sure she is a lovely girl, but in reality, she’s just a kid.
Part of me is praying that you’re doing it on purpose. That you stand around her knowing that I’ll walk by just to spite me. That you’ll post your little inside jokes just so I can see them. I hope that every time you hold her hand you’re thinking of me and that it kills you that it’s not me simply because the mere thought of you not thinking about me at all is breaking me from the inside out. I hope your goal is to make me as jealous as you possibly can so that I understand how you felt. I get it, I fucked up. I’m a horrible person for it, but that doesn’t change the fact that I’d do anything to be next to you right now.
You don’t even answer my texts anymore. It’s gotten to the point where I’m scared to talk to you out of fear that you’ll laugh in my face. I can’t walk into that classroom without thinking about you and feeling a stabbing pain in my chest. My best friend is worried about me because she says every time she’s called me recently I’ve been crying. I know you tried your hardest to erase me from your life, but I can’t do that. I can’t forget the smell of your shirt, or all the nerdy tangents you’d go off on. I can’t forget how nervous you made me and how my brain was always working at hyper speed when I was with you. I’m sorry I can’t erase you and I’m sorry I don’t want to.
I’m sorry I was too quiet. I’m sorry for being distant, for not responding and making you feel like it was on purpose when in reality I was just dealing with my own shit. I’m sorry for not asking for help when I needed it. I’m sorry for not telling you that I loved you when I realized and I’m sorry for realizing it too late. I’m sorry for making you lose sleep because I didn’t want to hang up the phone and for making you question my intentions. I’m sorry I was so hard to love and I’m sorry I was cold towards you whenever I felt cold on the inside. I’m sorry. I’m sorry I’m sorry I’m sorry.