So the first episode of Surviving Earth has been released! If you missed it, it should be available on Peacock tomorrow. I was able to watch it thanks to a live TV streaming site, which, funny enough, I had to switch servers a couple times because it was initially streaming from Chicago which is currently under a tornado watch. Fitting for a show about natural disasters, I hope they're safe but it was very frustrating trying to watch my show while a weather map with a big red spot was on screen instead!
This series was run by Tim Haines of Walking With Dinosaurs fame, so I think everyone was expecting (or at least hoping) this would match the highs of that iconic series. So, did it? Well...
The episode was structured like a WWD episode at least, following along a protagonist species (this one an old male Gorgonopsid and his harem) with occasional scenes given to the other animals of the environment. I very much appreciate that it didn't shy away from showing off some weird and unique permian critters like Suminia and Elph.
The actual storytelling didn't quite match the classics though, it's mostly just the Gorgonopsid climbing a mountain while being tailed by a rival male. There's a part where one of the females dies by Scutosaurus trampling ala Mufasa with her son watching on and... That's it lol. We never see the male react to this nor that baby again. This gets repeated a few times, just sort of disconnected little moments that don't really lead into anything.
The main draw of the show is focused on extinction, and it's starting with the absolute biggest? Did it do a good job depicting it? ...sure! I mean, it was nowhere near as dramatic or memorable as Walking With Monsters, but the narration did a good job explaining why it was happening and how it was affecting the animals. The most unique part here, and my favorite, was that it actually explained how the Earth recovered and what animals were able to bounce back, with a depiction of the early Triassic that seemed almost like a paradise with some really fun species like a hypothetical proto-pterosaur and feathered dinosauromorphs. I wish this bit was longer, as it was really only the last few minutes of the episode.
Overall, while I did really like it, I found it rather lacking and not quite up to expectations. If the rest of the show is about the same quality as this first episode, it'll probably end up being a solid 7/10, not bad at all but still very much in the shadow of series like Walking With Dinosaurs and Prehistoric Planet. The next episode premieres next week, and I'll be right here to watch it again!