Pairings: Jay Halstead x Antonio Dawson x fem oc
Warnings: threesome (mfm), dvp, oral
Summary: a bet is made before gun training renewal with the intelligence unit that takes some interesting turn of events.
(Author note: I'm sorry for delays between parts. I personally blame ADHD and getting sidetracked for all delays. I was originally going to write this one for just Jay but then I thought maybe Antonio would be better so here's a valentines special with both again. Also this took some interesting turns so please read at your own risk 🫣)
My day was not starting off the best. It started with me being my own enemy and forgetting to get more coffee when I was at the store even though it was on my list. Then when I finally pull up to the district Trudy stops me to tell me I had to go and get my renewal test done for my gun safety. On the plus side she told me I had to bring Dawson and Halstead with me.
"Dawson, Halstead Trudy said you're coming with me today." I announced when I got up the stairs to intelligence. Instead of explaining more I went straight for the coffee maker to get myself a togo cup before we left for the gun range.
"So Carlson, are you going to tell us why we need to go with you?" Jay asked and I glance over to see him leaning on the door frame.
"We all are due at the gun range for renewal today." I quickly explain as I put a lid on my coffee cup. "Now grab Dawson so we can go and get this over with."
"Drink some of that coffee first. I know caffeine deprived Emery when I see one." He tells me stepping into my path so I can't leave the break room. "I don't know about Tonio but I don't want a cranky Em with a gun."
I roll my eyes and huff out a sigh before taking a big gulp of the coffee I just poured. "Happy now?" I ask him.
"Yeah you don't look like you want to kill everyone now." He replies as he steps to let me pass. "Let's grab Dawson and get this over with shall we."
I nod and take another sip of my caffeine fuel and when I make eye contact with Antonio I nod my head towards the stairs. I don't wait to see if either of them are following me as I make my way back down the stairs and to the lockers where all of our guns are kept. The sound of footsteps and mumbling voices is my indication that the boys aren't far behind me.
I let Antonio drive us over to the main precinct that all trainings and renewal tests are done at. "So should we place wagers now on who will have the best shot?" Jay asks breaking the silence in the car.
"We could but you both would be owing me and I know how much you love losing Halstead." I reply with a smirk as our eyes connect in the mirror.
"We could make it more interesting if you want and losers have to do whatever the winner wants." Antonio suggests.
"Dawson I like the sound of that but I'm not sure if you guys would like what I have in mind." I smile at him when he glances up at me in the mirror. Unfortunately I lost the race for shotgun to Jay and got put in the backseat.
"Em that sounds dirty and I'm not sure if that's how you meant it." Jay laughs then turns to Antonio "if Em is in on this bet then so am I."
"I'm in and maybe that is how I intended it to be Jay." I grin at him before drinking the last of my coffee and seeing that Antonio has parked the car. "Now come on so I can kick your asses."
I catch the amused look that the boys share as we all exit the vehicle and head into the range. The evaluator gets us set up and makes sure we all have our ear and eye protection as well as our targets.
"Alright boys best shot wins." I tell them as we all go to our separate stations. I adjusted my glasses and ear protection before grabbing my handgun and adjusting my stance to get the perfect shot. After a few minutes we had all unloaded our clips and were reeling the targets back in.
Even though we were all accurate and on target Antonio and I both sighed when we saw how close together Jay got all of his shots.
“Alright Halstead you win and what would you like for your prize?” I ask him as we turn in our targets to the evaluator.
“Well let me think it over first.” Jay replied as we got back to the car.
“Fine, but you only have until the end of the day. If it takes you longer than that to decide you’re out of luck on your prize.” Antonio tells him. “Let’s go back to the precinct and finish up any paperwork we have and return our guns.”
By the time Voight tells us we can go home for the day it feels like all we accomplished for the day, besides passing the renewal test, was get caught up on what felt like a months worth of paperwork but was actually only the past couple of days.
“Ok Halstead if you haven’t decided yet I’ll extend your time a little bit longer if Dawson won’t. The only stipulation is that you both have to come with me and get food because I’m hungry.” I tell them both.
“That works for me. Em you can decide where we go.” Dawson says and Jay nods his agreement. I grab my phone out and text them both the address of one of my favorite bar and grills, mainly because of the cocktails they have and not just because it’s close to my apartment.
“Since we all drove separately do you guys want to drive together or meet there?” I ask them and they both agree to meeting at the bar. Since I knew parking by the bar could be hard to find sometimes I told them to park by my apartment and we could just walk the couple of blocks to the bar together.
Once we were seated at a hightop table and ordered our food and drinks did I turn my attention back to Jay. “ ok Jay have you given it anymore thought?”
Jay nods slowly giving his words some thought “I have and I think we were on the same train of thought earlier when we placed the bet.” He looked at me before looking over at Antonio to see our reactions but I’m already smirking and trying to hide it behind my drink. Antonio however must have a better poker face and waits for Jay to continue which he does after the waitress places our food in front of us and leaves. “I can tell Emmy already knows where I’m going with this. Do I need to spell it out for you?” He asks Antonio.
“I know where you’re going with this but I just want to hear you say it.” Antonio grins at him.
I roll my eyes and before Jay has a chance to say anything I turn to Antonio “Dawson he wants the same thing that I was going to if I had won. He wants to have sex.” I say and to clarify when I see his confused face “with both of us.”
“I figured that’s where he was going to say and it would have been the same thing I would have asked for as well.” Antonio replies and takes a drink of his beer. “I’m in if you are Em.”
I grin at both of them. “Is that really even a question Tonio? Of course I’m in.” I see the surprise on both of their faces. “You’re both hot and clearly interested in me what girl wouldn’t want both of you especially at the same time.” Both men choke on their beer at my words.
“Emmy I think we can both agree that you’re the one who’s hot here. But it’s nice to know you think we are too.” Jay smirks at me. He pays for all of our food and Antonio and slip a few bills out for a tip before we finish our drinks and walk back to my apartment.
“Ok if we’re going to do this I think we all might need to take a couple of shots first.” I announce once we’re back in my apartment and I’m taking down a bottle of tequila and some glasses. “Here’s to friends.” I pick up my glass and the boys do the same before we all toss the clear liquid back.
We all do one more shot to calm all of nerves before Jay is the one to make the first move by coming around my kitchen island to stand in front of me. He brings one of his hands up to cup my cheek and make me look at him.
“You’re sure about this? because there’s still time to back out.” Jay asks looking for confirmation of everything we went over at the bar.
I nod “I’m sure Jay.” I barely get the words out before his lips crash into mine. He works his hand to the back of my head running his fingers through my hair and moving his other hand to my hip pulling me into him. I feel him run his tongue over my bottom lip causing me to open for him and tasting the tequila on him.
The kiss feels longer than it probably actually is and is broken when I feel another pair of hands on me and Jay letting me go so Antonio can spin me around to face him. As soon as I do his lips replace Jays on mine. This time however they are working together with Jays lips on my neck. I’m not sure whose hands are where anymore and I’m not sure I care as they both are working together to get me out of my clothes.
As soon as the only thing I’m left in is my panties Antonio lifts me onto my kitchen island where Jay who’s now shirtless takes them off as he kneels in front of me and kisses up my thighs. Jay puts both of my thighs over his shoulders and pulls me to the very edge of the counter. Our eyes meet just as he kisses my clit before running his tongue up and down my folds before concentrating just on my clit again and sucking it into his mouth. My hands start running through his hair holding his face against my pussy.
Tipping my head back in pure bliss from the ministrations Jay was doing between my legs. I’m met with Antonio ,who’s now standing behind me on the other side of the island from where Jay was kneeling. I feel Antonio place a hand on my neck tilting my head back further until he places a chaste kiss on my lips before helping me lay all the way across my counter. The second my head is back I notice that Antonio only has on his boxers. I grin up at him as I remove one of my hands from Jays hair so I can pull the boxers down just enough to release Tonios cock.
Antonio stepped closer to me as I gripped his cock and after licking from the base to the tip before taking him in my mouth. The sounds in my kitchen were now a mix of everyone’s moans, two of which were now muffled by the actions they were performing, but all three of us were completely consumed in each other.
My thighs tightened around Jays head and I released Antonio’s cock from my mouth. “Jay” I moaned out. “Jay I-I’m coming.” I gasped out as I felt the familiar sensation in my lower abdomen and felt Jay moaning into me as I came all over his face. Jay kept licking and sucking my clit working me through my orgasm.
I sit up as Jay moves out from between my legs and stands up his eyes now dark from lust. I can see his face glistening from my come as I watch him undo his pants and take them off along with his boxers releasing his cock from its confines.
“There’s something I’ve always wanted to do but I only want to do it if you both are ok with it.” I start and can tell that I have both men’s full attention. “I want to take both of your cocks in my pussy at the same time.” I watch Jay raise an eyebrow at my request and hear Antonio groan behind me.
“Fuck yes.” “I’m surprised that’s something you’re into sweetheart.” I hear Antonio say followed closely by Jays statement. “I think we have Tonios interest in it and I’m not saying no to that.”
I reach out and pull Jay into me crashing my lips into his and moaning as I taste myself on him. Like we have the same thought he picks me up as I wrap my arms and legs around him. He carries us over to the couch where he sits down and pulls me on top of him.
“Antonio get your ass over here.” I say before reaching beneath me and grabbing ahold of Jays cock and running my hand up and down it eliciting a moan from the man beneath me.
“Right behind you nena .” Antonio tells me as he moves my hair to the side to kiss my neck. “Ride his cock and just let me know when you’re ready for me.” I just nod as a response as I slide Jays cock into me. I bounce on top of him letting out little moans at the feeling of having Jay inside me, his mouth on my nipple, and Antonio behind me kissing my neck.
“Tonio I’m ready.” Is all I can get out as I lean forward into Jay to give Antonio better access.
“Alright Emmy I’m going to go slow. Let me know if it’s too much.” Antonio says to me. I feel him run his tip over me before he lines himself up and very slowly starts entering right beside Jays cock causing both of us to moan. As Antonio pushes more of his cock in I meet Jays eyes just before his start rolling and I close my own. I start kissing Jay to muffle some of the noise coming from both of us that is a mix of moans and groans. Antonio must be all the way in now because he stills behind me giving us all time to adjust to the new sensations as he starts kissing my shoulder and neck again. I know I’m about to be covered in marks from how Antonio keeps kissing and sucking my skin and how Jays fingers are digging into my hips.
Once I felt adjusted enough to both cocks in me I start rocking my hips eliciting moans from both men and one of them grabbing my hips to stop my movements. It was only for a moment though before they both started moving and found a good rhythm. The sounds in the room were some of the dirtiest I’ve ever heard. The moans, the wet squelches of my vagina, and the high pitched sounds coming from myself. I was no longer kissing Jay but resting my face in his shoulder. All coherent thoughts have left my mind and it’s just sex. The pure pleasure that I was feeling and that both men were feeling right alongside me.
There was no warning that I could give them that I was about to come. No words could come to mind instead my moans got louder right before my toes curled, my walls squeezed around both cocks, I was sucking Jays neck trying not to bite him, and to my own surprise I squirted as I came. I was the start of the domino effect and I’m not sure who came first just that both men were coming and coming hard inside me.
It took us all a long moment to catch our breath as we stayed connected before Antonio pulled out of me and helped me to sit next to Jay on my couch.
“Where’s your bathroom Emmy so we can get you cleaned up?” Antonio asked.
“Down the hall and on the left. Washcloths and towels are in the closet in the bathroom.” I reply still out of breath. I barely register the nod he gives me or that Jay stands up and heads into my kitchen.
“Here drink some water.” Jay hands me a glass of water and I note that he must have cleaned himself up because he had his boxers back on. Right as I take the water Antonio comes back with a couple of washcloths and a Tshirt he must have found in my room.
“Thank you both. Not just for the amazing sex. Which was really fucking good but the water and everything else.” I tell them both as Antonio cleans me up along with himself and puts his own boxers on as he hands Jay the shirt that gets slipped over my head. “ you guys don’t have to leave if you don’t want to. We can watch a movie until we’re all up for another round. Because I definitely want to do that again.”
They both laugh as they take seats on the couch beside me. “ we can stay and we’re not looking for another round if you aren’t ready for it.” Jay tells me as I hand him a remote to find a movie.
“Yeah it was fun but we can wait it doesn’t have to be today that we go again.” Antonio adds.
“I don’t care when as long as this gets to happen again sometime.” I let them both know.