"You craven devil! Where have you trapped me, and why do you appear before me in this form?"
"Chillax, Captain - it's just a digital cyberspace that connects the two of us via virtual reality."
"Those goggles you're wearing are cameras that allow you to see me in my avatar, just as I can see you in yours."
"So you delivered me the compass and got me going here - 'twas all a trap! I should've known that after frequent visits to the Cursed Cafe you'd soon see me as a threat to be eliminated!"
"I don't want to eliminate you! I wanna strike a deal with you!"
"Alright then, Lightbringer - state your desire and your terms before we get down to the dealing part...if we do at all, that is."
"Well with Toffee out of the picture, I'd like you to become my new inside guy. Not only will you be my extra set of eyes inside the Cursed Cafe, but you will work very closely with me and take an active part in bringing about the ruination of the business."
"Basically, I want you as my parter! For one of the smartest and most powerful figures in the City of Villains' underbelly, what better partner than a fearsome and roguishly charming pirate?"
"See, it's lines like that what make me just a little apprehensive about this arrangement. Anyone with good sense knows that dealings with pirates are ill-advised because pirates can never be trusted! If you're so bloody smart, you'd know that! So why seek me for a deal?"
"I'll be honest with you, Captain....it could be because I'm desperate. Ever since I first laid eyes on that magic cafe I knew that bringing it down would be a race against the clock. And I may well be running out of time."
"About a year ago, I was diagnosed with something....terminal."
"You don't mean to tell me....?"
"I do, Captain. I'm not long for this world. I've tried extending my life and making the most of my time as best I could, but I'm still very much a slave to my own mortality. And in your line of work, you know how it is - death comes for us all eventually."
"Clinging to life through means most unnatural, I came to this City and started up my work through the appearance of charity, but I've really been motivated by a single aim - making money. Amass enough wealth to afford the best life extension serums and medical science research available so that I may either locate or get developed the miracle cure for my illness that I desire to posssess. A way to cheat death and maybe even unlock the secret to life eternal!"
"So therein lies your true interest in the Cursed Cafe. You don't wish to shut it down just to have no competitors - you want to seize all of its assets so that you can create an immortality elixir for yourself!"
"Hit the nail on the head there, Hooky! Whatever science can't bring us, magic most definitely can! And a mix of both is needed for alchemy like the Potionista does. I just know that it's through alchemy that I'll claim my key to everlasting life!"
"You realize that the Cursed Cafe has actually developed a serum that can bring the dead back to life? Made with Revival Jam, I believe. Why not simply wait for your passing and then have someone raise you from the dead using that?"
"I don't want to die and then come back like Jesus Goddamn Christ - I want to avoid dying altogether if I can help it! I've seen that most of my variants don't even make it through the surgery, so I'd rather not reach the point where that has to happen!"
"Now then, I believe I've put across what this means to me. Now let's talk about what I can make it mean for YOU, Captain..."