You would think people have never heard of disliking a character before just because not every character will be liked by every person, except it’s coming from people who actually understand this perfectly when it’s Shane.
It has been acceptable to hate Shane in this fandom for years. It has been acceptable to say every horrible thing you can think of about him. It has been acceptable to do it on every platform, even fucking goodreads. It has been so acceptable that it is not even uncommon for readers who hated him to say they hope he gets killed off. I have seen this multiple times.
And when his fans protest, it is not simply because they can’t tolerate their favorite character being hated by others, it is because they recognize that this level of hatred is inspired by racism. Even if you want to insist that it’s not, you can’t deny that the people who are protesting this treatment obviously believe it is.
So Shane fans have had to deal with the hatred much longer, and the hatred is much more extreme, and coming from people who aren’t making any effort to avoid yucking Shane fans’ yum, and in fact in many cases are going out of their way to spread that hate as far as possible and it’s racist AND Shane fans still get treated like they have no right to be angry when people hate Shane at the SAME TIME they act like nobody actually does, like the reason there’s not a Shane Hollander critical tag on Ao3 isn’t because being critical of Shane is so ubiquitous in this fandom that tagging for Shane criticism or Shane bashing would never even occur to the people doing it, and in fact is not even recognized as criticism or bashing and not simply a perfectly accurate portrayal of the character.
They have to deal with all this as their favorite is being thoroughly mischaracterized and bastardized too. The primary case being by the author herself, who decided to frame Shane as selfish for not wanting to go public with his relationship at the same time he was being threatened NOT TO by the commissioner of the NHL, who decided to frame him as oblivious, despite the fact that everything he was supposedly so oblivious to he thinks about often and takes note of often and says something about often (he notices Ilya is depressed, he knows Ilya wants to come out, he checks in with Ilya often, and REPEATEDLY goes outside his own comfort zone to meet Ilya halfway [going out to eat with Ryan and Fabian, going to Fabian’s concert, touching Ilya’s back in the club] even as Ilya never does the same, and even as Ilya continues to resent him for not giving him everything, and even as Ilya did not even at any point inform Shane that he no longer want to follow the fucking plan HE AGREED TO. In fact, sometimes he’s even granted temporary mind reading powers so that he can simply intuit that even though Ilya just shoved him against a wall in anger, Ilya obviously doesn’t want to hurt him!). The other many cases coming from how the author talks about him in interviews, how she talks about him in her Discord, how fans insist on headcanoning him as a misogynist, a gay queerphobe, and even someone who is incapable of seeing other people as human beings. It is, again, ubiquitous to make Shane selfish, to make him self-centered, oblivious, compassion-less and bigoted and that is not even an exhaustive fucking list.
But when it’s Ilya? When it’s been a handful of weeks? When it’s been thoroughly tagged to prevent it from spreading to people who don’t want to see it? When nobody is going out of their way to yuck any Ilya fan’s yum? When it’s discussions of thoughts Ilya canonically has and actions he canonically took? When it’s just people of color venting, again, about the racism at work in how his character is written, and how his character is favored and pedestalized and coddled by the narrative, the author, and the fandom?
[Image ID: Screenshot of three tweets that read:
Cyn Rozanova: No, you don’t understand that you made Ilya unlikable to yourselves in your echo chamber, giving him flaws and intentions he doesn’t have in the book,you completely rewrote Ilya in your mind. He is loved outside your fandom, deal with it.
Necog: What kind of nonsense is this? Who doesn’t like Ilya? 😂😂😂
Ro: You people tell yourselves this, hype it up in your echo chambers and when real reactions from real people pop your bubble, you start to crash out.
You will never learn. End ID]
Apparently WE’RE the ones giving him flaws and intentions he doesn’t have. WE’RE the ones rewriting Ilya. WE’RE the ones who have to “deal with it.” WE’RE the ones who can’t handle real reactions from real people. WE’RE the ones crashing out.
Note that the person commenting in the middle is coming across Ilya hate for the first fucking time. They’ve never even seen it before. I promise you there are zero Shane fans who have never come across Shane hate before. You can’t even casually participate in this fandom without coming across Shane hate.
And note too that THIS is the tweet they’re responding to:
[Image ID: Screenshot of a tweet that reads:
Rachel doesn’t understand how much she has made Ilya unlikeable.
like I have zero sympathy or interest left in that white, privileged, self centred man’s journey.
First note that their primary complaint is with how Reid wrote him. Then note that it’s implied they originally liked Ilya. Then note that the only thing this person said that is even up for debate is that he’s unlikeable and that he’s self-centered. The former is something that is inevitable in every single fandom. A character could be the platonic ideal of universally likable and there would still people who do not like them because not everybody is going to like every character. The latter is one of the primary reasons people hate Shane and are, apparently, allowed to hate Shane for even if his fans disagree that he’s self-centered, and it is being said so tamely, so simply, and is not going out of its way to spread hate further. Note lastly, that this tweet has just over 600 likes, and less than 200 retweets.
I have fucking had it with this racist fucking fandom.
People have a right to hate Ilya. They have a right to say whatever they want about him. And though none of them even are, they have a right to mischaracterize him.
People have been doing all of this and much worse to Shane for much longer and now it is their turn to even the score.
And it is YOUR turn to fucking deal with it.