⠀⠀⠀⠀elijah regarded her in silence for a long moment after her explanation, his expression remaining composed, though there was something increasingly scrutinizing in his gaze now. every answer she offered seemed to resolve one inconsistency only to create two more in its place. and he noticed it, meticulously. she was very contradictory. contradictory in a way that opened up many questions but at the same time aroused his suspicion.
⠀⠀⠀⠀"perhaps," he finally answered, "but were that truly the case, i suspect the circumstances of our meeting would be... considerably different." if she had been mistaken für katherine pierce more than this time, then he'd argue that the outcome would have been different.
⠀⠀⠀⠀"if someone had genuinely mistaken you for katherine pierce long before now, there are only two likely outcomes." a slight tilt of his head followed. "either you would have already been delivered to my family... or others would have attempted to use you themselves. a resemblance to miss pierce is not the sort of thing that leads to a peaceful existence." in short: elijah would have known sooner about her, or she would have been already dead for one reason or another. yet she was still alive despite there being countless individuals who would have viewed such a resemblance not as coincidence, but as opportunity. from what he had learned, katherine pierce did not have many friends, instead she had a lot of enemies or people who held a strange obsession for her; provided that they had survived her. she was reluctant to leave loose ends that could point to her, which also made it so difficult to determine where she was. another reason why elijah didn't believe katherine had actually died in a fire in 1864.
⠀⠀⠀⠀and yet this girl, this supposed human, stood before him not only alive, but composed. it did not fit.
⠀⠀⠀⠀"so yes," he continued evenly, "i can imagine several reasons why you might choose to lie regarding her whereabouts... or the extent of your knowledge." he did not elaborate further. he did not need to. the implication alone was sufficient.
⠀⠀⠀⠀his gaze lingered on her as she spoke of death again, of vampires, of familiarity with their kind. and once more that same dissonance settled beneath his composure. nothing about her reactions aligned with what experience had taught him.
⠀⠀⠀⠀a human in her position should have been terrified by now. overwhelmed. desperate. bargaining, trembling, pleading for assurances that would never come. most mortals broke long before reaching this point. some cried. some begged. others dissolved into denial so profound they could scarcely form coherent thoughts.
⠀⠀⠀⠀she did none of those things. instead, she challenged him. she negotiated. she observed. and she did so with a levelness that belonged far more to someone accustomed to surviving monsters than to someone recently introduced to them. again, it did not fit the expectations, and it made him suspicious; made him feel like something was profoundly wrong. made him doubt whether she was actually a mere human or not, even though she smelled like a human. a hunter, perhaps? unlikely, considering the fact that most vampires, especially in this area where katherine pierce seemed to have left a footprint, would recognize a doppelgänger. indulging with them wouldn't be smart.
⠀⠀⠀⠀"then should i take this to mean," he asked calmly, "that you were prepared for this moment?" there was no mockery in the question, only clinical precision. "because your composure suggests either remarkable adaptability... or prior expectation." his gaze narrowed almost imperceptibly. "and if your life has truly involved as much contact with the supernatural as you imply…i find myself wondering how you managed to survive it." if she had, perhaps, a supernatural protector, she wouldn't be here. she would have some support or would not be in the situation in the first place. unless it was what she had planned from the beginning.
⠀⠀⠀⠀humans did not simply brush shoulders with vampires for years and emerge untouched. not unless they were protected, extraordinarily fortunate... or far less human than they appeared.
⠀⠀⠀⠀something about this entire situation continued to feel fundamentally wrong to him. not visibly so. not enough to expose itself plainly. but enough for instinct to persist like a splinter beneath the skin.
⠀⠀⠀⠀when she referenced his spectacle, his gaze shifted briefly past her shoulder toward trevor's body. the blood spilled across the floorboards had already begun to darken and dry at the edges. the scent lingered heavily in the room still. then his eyes returned to her, unmoved.
⠀⠀⠀⠀"and what would this spectacle tell you?" he questioned, wanting to know to what conclusions she came when she apparently already knew everything.
⠀⠀⠀⠀his attention remained fixed not merely on her words, but on every subtle alteration in her demeanor. and when he extended his hand, he noticed it immediately: that moment. it was brief. nearly imperceptible but nonetheless present.
⠀⠀⠀⠀for the first time since this conversation began, her certainty appeared to fracture. not fully, not enough for a lesser observer to notice, but enough. a hesitation that did not align with the confidence she had displayed moments earlier. as though agreeing to his terms carried a weight beyond the obvious. as though something else lingered beneath the surface of her decision. however, he could no tell what it was.
⠀⠀⠀⠀his expression did not shift in response. it remained perfectly composed, masklike in its restraint, though his gaze sharpened almost imperceptibly as he studied her through that fleeting pause.
⠀⠀⠀⠀and then her hand met his; the coldness surprised him.
⠀⠀⠀⠀not because cold hands were unusual in themselves. humans often carried chilled skin from fear, poor circulation, winter air, illness. but none of those explanations felt appropriate here. not after the fire she had shown only moments ago. not with the steadiness of her posture or the controlled cadence of her voice. and yet her touch was unmistakably cold, colder than it should have been.
⠀⠀⠀⠀furthermore, there was something else. for the briefest instant something flickered through his eyes in response; something strange and wholly uninvited. not recognition exactly and not memory. merely the sharp and inexplicable sensation that the contact had stirred something buried impossibly deep beneath centuries. it vanished almost as quickly as it appeared.
⠀⠀⠀⠀his grip remained measured and precise; firm without aggression, controlled without softness. "then we have an agreement," he said at last.
⠀⠀⠀⠀his hand released hers smoothly thereafter, though his gaze lingered on her for another second before he stepped back.
⠀⠀⠀⠀originally, he had come here intending to retrieve katherine pierce. that had been the plan. instead, he now found himself leaving with a human (albeit questionable, suspicious) doppelgänger.
⠀⠀⠀⠀"come," he said calmly, turning slightly toward the exit at last. "you may accompany me to my vehicle." the phrasing itself carried finality. rose-marie was no longer required. whatever usefulness she had possessed ended the moment this agreement was secured, and she was free to go.
⠀⠀⠀⠀elijah adjusted the cuff of his sleeve with unhurried precision before his gaze settled briefly upon her once more. still watching and still assessing. because despite the agreement now standing between them, his suspicion had not diminished in the slightest. || @xnokturn