Buttons, Bee Stings and Butterfly Effects: Chapter 9
Taglist Form
Series Masterlist
Ao3 Link
Wattpad Link
Bridgerton Masterlist
Previous Next Chapter
Pairing: Regency!Anthony Bridgerton x Modern!Fem Reader
Summary: A ball, a few important conversations and the return of a certain gentleman. The Viscount has absolutely no feelings about any of this (he absolutely does)
Word Count: 3.6k
Warnings: 18+ for the series but for this part, nothing. I will put this up on Ao3 and Wattpad so please do not repost my work elsewhere
Authorâs Note: Here we are, it's the longest chapter so far! Please do enjoy! Thank you to @fayes-fics for serving as beta and @eulalielatibule for the inspo for this fic
Chapter 9: Jealousy or, The Redemption of Mr. Harley
London, 1814
That night, in your finely appointed bed in Danbury House, sleep does not come easy. When further pressed, Agatha had revealed that, after your sudden departure the previous season, the Viscount had seemed sad, almost despondent, refusing to take up any other dance partners for the remainder of the season.
The Ton at large had attributed his sullenness to the loss of his mistress, but Agatha and, she admitted, Lady Bridgerton herself were certain it was because of you. For several weeks after you had left, Lord Bridgerton had quietly asked Agatha if she had news of you. He had even prevailed upon Eloise and Hyacinth to ask after your address so that they might receive news of you through your own letters. Agatha had gently rebuffed both requests, informing them that you were traveling between various estates and couldnât be certain where you were at any given time until you reached out to her first.
It was an ingenious lie, for if, as originally planned, you never returned, you were meant to have simply faded from their memories, remembered as a friendly acquaintance they had known for a brief time -Â a mere footnote in their lives.
But that, apparently, was not the case for Anthony Bridgerton. And so it seemed, to Agatha and his mother, at least, that rather than explore whatever he had felt for Miss Addison, he pushed all feelings away and decided the best course for his life was to take on a loveless, but amenable marriage.Â
Which would ultimately lead to his death. And the sorrow and decline of his family.
As you rolled over and at last felt the tug of sleep, the final thought in your mind was simply this: not if you, Agatha and Coral had anything to say about it.
Over the next few weeks, though, there was not much opportunity to say or even do anything. Whenever you came to call on the family, Miss Hunter was right there, pride of place, sitting between Violet Bridgerton and the Viscount.
You could only watch with increasing anxiety as Miss Hunter slowly won over the rest of the Bridgerton family. She charmed both Colin and Gregory with tales of her travels. She delighted Hyacinth with stories of the gowns she wore to glamorous balls across Europe. She even managed to gain Daphne, the new Duchess of Hastingsâ support when she tenderly held her newborn son and declared him, âThe handsomest baby she had ever seen.â
All of this was done under the proud, almost warm eyes of Lord Bridgerton, who, at every smile and approving nod from his family, seemed to preen a bit more.
At balls, it was much the same. She seemed to hold the Ton in the palm of her hand. Everyone waited for her arrival to see what she would be wearing, and then surely, the young ladies would be dressed in a similar fashion at the next soiree.
And just as the Viscount had vowed, he never danced with you, his waltz firmly held for Miss Hunter, who, you begrudgingly had to admit, floated around the dancefloor in his arms like she was born to it.
The only holdout to her charms, though, was Benedict Bridgerton. While he smiled winningly at her praise and nodded at the appropriate places when she engaged him in conversation, you could see it in his eyes; he was not impressed by Miss Eulalie Hunter.
If only you could tell him just how right he was not to trust her, but frustratingly, you knew you couldnât.
But you would get the chance to come as close as possible to informing him thus soon enough.
To everyoneâs surprise, the Harley family had decided to host another ball. Despite, or maybe because of their recent family scandal, an invitation to their ball was a hot commodity. And naturally, Lady Danbury and Miss Addison were among those on the guest list.
The ballroom at Harley House was nearly identical to when you had attended their ball the previous season, as if Lady Harley was summoning a less scandalous time in her familyâs recent history. And indeed Lord Harley and his wife seem relieved to see Agatha and, by extension, you. As you attach your dance card, you realize that by attending, Lady Danbury, who as a close confidante of The Queen, was signalling to the Ton that the family was once again safe to associate with.
A few gentlemen write their names on your card, and then you seek out the Bridgerton family, who had arrived shortly after you. As Agatha makes small talk with Lady Bridgerton, Colin and Benedict add their names. You are pleased to see that Benedict has chosen the Somerfield Set, which means you have a pair of consecutive dances to gauge his true feelings about Miss Hunter and share your own thoughts in return.
You try to ignore Lord Bridgerton, which is difficult because he looks exceedingly handsome in his cropped black velvet jacket, choosing instead to chat with Eloise. Itâs while you two are talking that Mr. Harley approaches. You havenât seen him since the Trowbridge Ball, and he certainly has changed. He has an air of confidence he didnât have the season before, and you remember that, because his elder brother fled to the Americas with Siena Rosso after he won the duel that had originally ended the Viscountâs life and thus been disowned, the younger Mr. Harley was now the heir.
All of his familyâs inheritance was his. You almost feel sorry that such a weight is now on his shoulders. He is different physically as well. Not only is he dressed in a fine suit, but his complexion is also clear, and his blonde hair longer and tousled in a way that makes him look quite handsome.
He offers you a bow, and Eloise steps back, as if using you as a human shield to escape his notice. She has no need to worry, though; his eyes are only on you.
âMiss Addison,â he begins, âIf you would be amenable, I would very much like to claim a dance with you.â When he finishes speaking, he holds your gaze with clear, calm eyes, waiting for your consent.
You had purposely worn an older pair of shoes, expressly in case this scenario presented itself. But the fact that he has asked for your permission rather than just taking up your card is a new and welcome development.Â
As you offer him your wrist to write his name, you say, âIt would be my honor and indeed a pleasure, Sir.â Afterwards, you find that you genuinely mean the words.
As you and Agatha take your leave of the Bridgerton family to make the rounds, you catch the Viscountâs eye, and heâs clenching his jaw, looking displeased.
But then shortly after, Miss Hunter and her uncle arrive, and you watch as he puts on a charming smile and takes up her dance card.
Once the dancing starts, you are obliged for most of the evening. Soon enough, though, Benedict Bridgerton is offering you his arm and the pair of you begin the first of your two dances. He is always an excellent partner, both attentive and a good conversationalist, when the dancing allows.
Luckily, this set does. You spend the first one engaging in small talk, gossiping about a ladyâs garish gown, a gentlemanâs unfortunate choice of cravat and chatting about an art exhibit you both attended that he has strong opinions about.
Sometime during the second dance, Lord Bridgerton and Miss Hunter glide past you, and Benedictâs expression changes, a sour look on his face, before he catches himself and softens it to one of bland neutrality.
âI saw that,â you chide him, not unkindly.
Benedict looks momentarily surprised before he relaxes. âIt is nothing, Miss Addison. I assure you.â
âIf it is about Miss Hunter, then I assure you, Mr. Bridgerton, it is not nothing.â
He appears taken aback and then impressed that you so thoroughly turned his own words around on him. He opens and closes his mouth a few times before settling on, âIt would be ungentlemanly to speak ill of the lady my brother is courting.â
You canât help the sharp grin that overtakes your face. âIt would be unladylike of me to do the same, but shall we do it anyway?â
Benedict lets out a loud laugh, which draws curious looks from the couples dancing around you. Once everyone looks away, he smiles and leans in. âI suppose we shall.â
At your answering smile, his face suddenly grows serious, and he spares a glance in his elder brotherâs direction before he speaks again.
âThere is something about her. I cannot put my finger on it, but she seems too polished, too perfect. And it is strange that she has so thoroughly charmed my entire family, if not the whole of the Ton.â
In one sentence, Benedict Bridgerton has given voice to exactly what you have observed over the last few weeks.
âNot all of the Ton,â you tell him. âBut you are correct, she does appear to be incredibly polished, unnaturally so. That she has been to all the places and done all the things she claims is extremely suspect to me, and indeed Lady Danbury thinks so as well.â
He nods. âI had wondered if anyone else had found her stories as incredulous as I have.â
You squeeze the hand holding yours as you turn. âI assure you, Mr. Bridgerton, that is most certainly the case.â
You take a few more turns around the floor before you speak again. âHave you mentioned your concerns about her to your brother?â
Benedict lets out a humorless laugh. âI have tried on several occasions. But the stubborn ass refuses to listen to me, saying only that she is âmore than suitableâ and then walks away from me,â he pauses as his words catch up to him and says, âMy apologies, Miss Addison, for the colorful language.â
You smile. âI assure you, Mr. Bridgerton, that in my head, I have called your elder brother far worse things than merely an ass.â
Benedict laughs. âI have always liked you.â He glances at his brother and then back to you. âI had thought too, so had Anthony.â
Before you can respond, the dance ends, and you acknowledge each other. As Benedict leads you back to Agatha, he leans in and says, âI have done all I can to dissuade him, but perhaps heâll listen to you. I hope youâll try.â
âI shall, Mr. Bridgerton,â you tell him, âI swear it.â
When the next dance commences, you join Mr. Harley on the dancefloor. As the music begins, you offer up a silent prayer that your toes remain unharmed. But as you step together, you realize your prayers are unnecessary.
As he spins you under his arm, you are astonished as you ask him, âMr. Harley, have you taken dance lessons?â
He ducks his head, turning a familiar shade of pink. âI have indeed, Miss Addison. Mother insisted, especially after how things ended last season.â His eyes widen, as if realizing he has said too much.
You change partners and dance away from him. When you come back together, you tell him, âYou can speak as freely as you like with me, Sir. Lady Danbury has apprised me of the situation.â You choose your next words carefully, not wanting to offend him. âI hope your brother is content in the Americas.â
Mr. Harley looks at you with surprise and, after sparing a glance at his parents, says, âHe is quite well. He sent a letter to his best friend, who then secreted it to me. He is newly married to the young lady he fled with and has started a business. He seems most content with his newfound freedom.â
You nod. âAnd how are you enjoying being the new heir?â
At your question, he looks sad. âIt may sound silly, but I would very much like to marry for love. I had hoped that, as the second son, it was something that could be afforded to me, but now as the heirâŚâ
âAll the voracious, fortune-hunting mamas are eying you for their voracious, fortune-hunting daughters,â you finish for him.
He laughs. âPerhaps not in those exact words, but yes.â
You are forced to dance away from each other again, but once you return, you entwine your fingers with his as you make your way around the floor.
âMr. Harley, I owe you an apology for last season, for allowing Lord Bridgerton to take the waltz that was rightfully yours at the Trowbridge Ball.â
He looks thoughtful for a moment. âIt was rather bold of me to claim the dance you always reserved for him. I should have expected no less of such treatment, really.â
âAll the same,â you begin, âI think itâs only fair that you take my waltz tonight. In fact, Sir, it would be my honor if you did so.â
He smiles broadly at your request. And indeed, as the dance ends and you acknowledge each other, and after escorting you back to Agathaâs side, he fills in his name beside the waltz before bowing and taking his leave.
As you take a refreshment break, you fill Agatha in on your conversations with both Benedict and Mr. Harley.
Agatha watches the Viscount and Miss Hunter talk, a frustrated look on her face as she tells you, âI am pleased that Mr. Bridgerton has reservations about Miss Hunter, even as his brother is willfully oblivious. And as for Mr. Harleyâs plight,â she pauses to look around the ballroom, a considering gleam in her eyes. âBy the time he leads you back to me after your waltz together, I shall have assembled a few good candidates for his love match.â
You can only nod and smile as Agatha goes off to work some matchmaking magic. Youâre pleased to give her a much-needed distraction.
You turn to watch the dancing couples, and across the floor, the Viscount catches your eye. That feeling you stubbornly continue to refuse to name thrums through your core as he stares at you, his eyes hot and intense, even as you notice Miss Hunter stands beside him, her arm in his.
You turn away, the hair prickling at the nape of your neck, a sure sign that penetrating gaze of his is still laser-focused on you.
Later, Mr. Harley finds you for the waltz. Once on the floor, he keeps a respectful amount of space between you, another new trait of his that gains your admiration. You glance around as the music starts and are surprised to find that Lord Bridgerton and Miss Hunter are the couple on your left.
As you begin to move around the floor, Mr. Harley inquires after your absence, and you tell him the story you and Agatha concocted, but you find yourself embellishing a little, the details of which delight him.
As you continue to twirl together, he regales you with stories about the various lessons his mother has engaged him in. Your favorite by far is how he once, while practising with his dance instructor on the dock of his family estateâs pond, accidentally knocked the poor man into the drink and spent the better part of an hour trying to fish him out, even as they both kept slipping on the sandbar and falling back into the water.
Youâre both laughing as the dance finishes, your arm steady in his as he leads you back to Agatha, who, true to her word, is holding court with a variety of young ladies. She introduces each of them to Mr. Harley, whom you watch with genuine happiness. He deserves his love match, you determine. And judging by the quality of the young ladies your partner has assembled, he is certain to find it.
You excuse yourself to freshen up. Leaving the ballroom, youâre about to open the door to the water closet when an arm snakes out and pulls you into a side hall. Rather than scream, your instincts kick in and you stomp down hard on your would-be assailantâs toes, while also elbowing them hard in the solar plexus. They release you instantly, and the groan you hear is all Lord Bridgerton.
Wheezing and doubled-over, he stumbles over to a table and lights a candelabra, which casts a gentle glow around the hallway. As he leans against the table, palms flat, catching his breath, you stalk over to him, your anger causing you to abandon Regency speech.
âAre you crazy? Why would you put your hands on a woman? You are so lucky I didnât go with plan b which would have been me kicking you in the junk and breaking your nose.â
He stares at you in shock, even as he holds himself around the middle and tries to catch his breath.
âI onlyâŚunderstandâŚaboutâŚfour ofâŚthose words,â he stutters before standing and stretching, breath still heaving as he continues, âMy apologies all the same. You are correct. It was foolish of me to take your arm without permission.â
âTo say the least, My Lord,â you huff.
After a few moments of silence, the Viscount seems to have regained his stamina, standing to his full height. You feel a bit calmer and turn to him, momentarily taken aback at how handsome he looks in half shadow, half light.
He gazes at you for a long moment, and you donât miss how his eyes stay firmly on your face, not once flicking down to your cleavage.
âYou and Mr. Harley seem quite close.â His tone is measured and calm, even as his eyes blaze.
You cross your arms. âNot that it is any of your concern, My Lord but, Mr. Harley and I have reached an accord. Dare I say it, I now consider him a friend.â
The Viscount lets out an indignant snort. âA friend indeed. Surely, he has put on airs to entrap you. You are an heiress with vast wealth and properties, and he isâŚâ
âNow the heir to his own familyâs fortune,â you say, cutting him off. âIt is true that he has improved in both countenance and humor, as well as in his skills as a dancer. But that,â you pause to push into his space in an attempt to emphasize your point, âIs where his charm ends for me. He desires a love match, and I wish him well in his endeavour."
Lord Bridgerton stares down at you, his face mere inches from yours. Voice nearly a whisper, he asks, âAnd what is it, Miss Addison, that you desire?â
Your brain screams danger as his face moves ever closer towards yours, the rich, spicy scent of his cologne invading your senses. Blinking, you realize the peril youâre in, the pair of you alone in a semi-dark hallway, where anyone could walk by. You step back from him, and the spell heâs cast on you is broken.
You turn to leave, but then his words replay in your mind, and you spin around, indignant, unable to stop yourself. âMy Lord, pray tell me, what business is it of yours if Mr. Harley and I were to form an attachment?â
His eyes go wide. âSurely not, Miss Addison. You can do far better.â He crosses his arms, glaring at you, all the petulance of an angry kitten. You canât help the wry smile that plays on your lips as that old desire to needle him comes to the fore.
âNeed I remind you, Sir, that my affairs are my own and no one has any say in what I choose to do or whom I choose to be acquainted with, not the least of all a puffed-up, so-called gentleman whose neck cloth has come undone.â
He glares at you, even as he reaches down to his cravat, which has indeed come askew in the scuffle of him taking your arm and you retaliating. He turns to a mirror on the wall and attempts to fix it with fumbling fingers. You watch him for a few moments and then take pity on him, walking over and reaching up to redo the ivory silk around his neck.
His throat bobs as you fix the elegant knotwork started by his valet, and soon enough, youâre tucking it back in. Stepping back, you wait until his eyes meet yours before you say, âMy Lord, you are courting Miss Hunter. Unless that is to change, kindly keep your opinions on my choices to yourself.â
He swallows thickly but says nothing. There is a creaking sound on the floorboards behind you, and you turn to see Lady Bridgerton. She doesnât seem shocked or angry, only assessing.
The Viscount clears his throat and, after nodding at you, strides away, posture stiff, seemingly ignoring his mother as he brushes past her.
She still says nothing as you cautiously approach her. âMy Lady,â you begin, âI was overcome by all the dancing and your son, he,â you pause as she holds up a hand.
Her tone is gentle as she says, âYou need not offer up any explanation, I understand perfectly what has occurred. You ought to return to the ballroom, my dear.â
You curtsey to her and begin to head in that direction.
Behind you, she adds, âI heard what you just said to him.â
You pause in your walking, a lump forming in your throat. Surely you have ruined things between you and Lady Bridgerton, and certainly the family, by extension.
Which is why you are astonished when two days later you receive a personal invitation from her to join the Bridgerton family at Aubrey Hall, a few days ahead of her famous Hearts and Flowers Ball.
Next Part
taglist: @queen-of-the-misfit-toys @faye-tale @cosmiclove330 @abridgerton @fiction-is-life @kmc1989 @alexandrainlove @ietss @multi-fandom-lover7667 @turtle-cant-communicate @liliac-dreamer @hottytoddyhistory @laniec03 @sky0401 @kwbaby24 @spideymanluver @queenofmean14 @jtheteenagewitch @winterassassin1804 @austenesque222 @huening-web @imafangirlofeverything @jackierose902109 @pernandofalonso
Go Benedict! I know a catty bitch like him could clock a fraud from a mile off. And go Violet too! Even if she doesn't know Miss Hunter, she absolutely knows her son.















