Celestial Spirits Eclipse Arc Rant Part 1/?
Let me preface this by saying, I tried so hard to like this arc on my rewatch.
Filler arcs and I have always had a strained relationship, but I was surprisingly optimistic about this one.
When I first saw Fairy Tail, I absolutely DESPISED the Key of the Starry Skies, so much so that I was scared to rewatch it.
From...this whole blog, you can probably tell that I had a change of heart. In fact, I ended up adoring a character that used to be my all time least favorite.
So, I went into this filler arc with a new perspective.
However, unlike the Key of the Starry Heavens, I think revisiting this arc has only made it worse for me.
Now of course, we can't really judge a filler arc up to the standards of a well planned canon arc. Not that it's a bad thing to do so, but I feel it automatically puts said filler arc at a disadvantage.
What we can do however, is compare it to another filler arc.
So, in this multi-part rant, I'll talk about why Key of the Starry Skies worked for me, and why the Celestial Spirit Eclipse Arc failed.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
First, I've been really negative in the introduction. So, why not go over the positives of this arc! No matter how bad I do think it is, there are always some things that I think should be given credit.
The concept itself is very interesting!! There is so much potential to be had with Celestial Spirits, who from this point have been shown to serve Lucy(and Yukino), wanting a rebellion for their own individual freedom.
I like some of the Eclipse! designs a lot! I particularly like Eclipse! Taurus and Eclipse! Virgo's designs!(but I suppose that is down to personal preference)
The variety of fights was nice to see, and some of them are iconic.
Gray's dance battle with Eclipse! Cancer has to be one of the most memorable parts of the arc for me!!
..............................................................................................................................
Unfortunately, that's about where my praise for it ends.
Before I get into specifics, I just wanted to say that it's totally cool to like this arc! I'm glad you're able to enjoy it!! (つ≧▽≦)つ
To stop this section from being too long for now, I'll focus on just one character that bothers me. Truth be told, it's the character from this arc I have the most to say about(surprisingly).
Eclipse! Virgo was really uncomfortable to watch. Her awful, sadistic personality and love of seeing others suffer was just...not for me.
Normal Virgo is actually one of my favorite spirits, so seeing her become all mean and ruthless wasn't too fun.
Now, that sounds a bit familiar...maybe even a bit hypocritical of me.
A filler woman who doesn't mind hurting others, specifically Lucy, and gets a thrill from doing it. A filler character who believes that they are righteous in punishing people who oppose them in a militaristic fashion, having little care for the consequences…a filler character that the guild at first considers absolutely rude and obnoxious...
I might be absolutely crazy, but Eclipse! Virgo is just if Mary Hughes sucked and lacked any depth
Now, I'm incredibly biased, and I know that. But look at these two side by side and TELL me they aren't thinking the exact same thing.
It's not even the fact that most of her character traits feel recycled from Mary, but that they based a filler character...off of another filler character.
Mary Hughes is a character I love because she is flawed. She does horrible things, and expects to get away with them. The difference between her and Eclipse! Virgo is development.
Mary gets to go through a bit of a mini-arc in the latter half of season five. Eclipse! Virgo, of course, does not.
A major problem I have with having a filler arc like this is that it does feel very rushed. We have to go through each Zodiac in a span of a 22 episode arc. The Key of the Starry Skies did have 26, but also a more linear plot.
There are only 6 members of the Legion Platoon, compared to 12(13 if we count Ophiuchus) Celestial Spirits. It leaves for these Eclipse! variants to only leave their first impressions.
For Virgo, it left a bad taste in my mouth.
Even if we disregard that factor, Virgo is almost a flanderized version of Mary Hughes, taking all her more evil, grating traits and putting it into one character.
Of course, it's all very likely a coincidence.
However, Mary Hughes as a character displays that the show writers were able to create a character with those traits that works.
..............................................................................................................................
Okay I'm so sorry if you read this much thank you for listening to me yap
If I said anything wrong, please feel free to correct me!! I know some of the things I said might be a bit out there, but I wanted to say them.