John knew that he was absolutely deserving of every word Ellen would throw his way, that every punch that landed would never be enough to make up for all of his mistakes, and yet⌠As Ellen marched towards him, there was still a moment where he couldnât help but think to himself, âThis is how I die.â The last thing he had expected was for Ellenâs arms to wrap around him, tight, like she was almost afraid to let go. On impulse he returned the hug, blatantly ignoring the ache in his chest, because⌠This was his fault. Bill had died on his watch and then he disappeared off the face of the earth, not even a single sorry sent in Ellenâs direction. And god, he missed her.
The moment seemed to last for too long and yet⌠not long enough, before she was pulling away and staring him down. He couldnât help but let out an amused huff of laughter at that look, the one he had been on the end of more times than he could count. And just like that, it felt like John was fifteen years younger, making stupid ass mistakes on a hunt. âIâm sorry, El,â he said, completely genuine. He deserved this lecture- mostly because he knew just how much he deserved it. He remembered every time he declined a call, knowing all too well that it was Ellen searching for answers. Every single time he saw her calling and just let it go to voicemail. Which he would delete without even listening to. âIâm sorry,â he said again, for something different altogether. And he hoped sheâd know what it was for, just by the guilt ringing in his tone. He wasnât sure if he could say it out loud, even now. He couldnât admit that Billâs death was his fault. So instead he looked at Ellen like he had destroyed her world (and hadnât he?) and he could only hope that he could make atonement.
"I know you are. I know, John." In the end, that was the simple truth of it. Ellen was entitled to feel whatever the hell she wanted about her husband's- about the love of her life's- death. She could hate whoever she wanted, blame whoever and she had. She did. But underneath all that rational irrationality, was the truth. Truth: John Winchester had loved Bill Harvelle. Truth: John Winchester would have done anything to take back that day. Truth: John Winchester was sorry, so sorry for her loss. For everything. She knew all of that, she'd made her peace with it a long time ago but that didn't make any of her feelings less valid. Right now, none of that really mattered. Right now she just wanted to be. Even if he was looking at her like that (and god, she could hardly stand it), she just wanted to be. Bill's loss was with her everyday but it was with him too, she could see that clear as day. He was so stupid. He shouldn't have pushed her away. Ellen closed her eyes for just a second, taking in a breath and absolutely refused to cry.
He was lucky she didn't smack him over the head again. There was so much more she wanted to say but she was tired, exhausted by the thought of it. How many times had she already yelled and cried and argued with an answering machine or just in her own head? No more, not today. So she tried for a smile and her head shook ever so slightly. "You know those boys of yours are still causin' all kinds of trouble here. I think someone wanted to get their attention real bad, locked us up in a bubble for it. They never can leave well enough alone," she was smiling properly now, "Remind you of anyone?" She took a small step back then, her hand briefly rested on his shoulder before she let go. "You seen them yet?"