I'm half-way through watching the old anime movie A Wind Named Amnesia (eng dub) and have some thoughts.
I think the premise is great. All of humanity suddenly lost all their memories. It's intriguing and there's a lot you can do with that. Sadly it chooses to tell a (so far) rather lackluster story and hasn't thought through the setting as well as it probably should.
Before I go and rant about everything that bugs me about it I'll say some positives. The animation is good. I like when they showed the corpse in the police mech, that the robots and such weren't affected by the anti-memory wave and are still operating by their last commands. Though it felt a bit on the nose that they had to explain that the corpse in the mech had starved to death in it because he had forgotten how to get out. I don't know if that was just a dub thing or was in the original too. Anyway, I think it might have been better to just let the viewer come to that conclusion themselves.
I also like the implications behind the anti-memory wave (it's not called that in the movie but I like it and use it). So far it seems a powerful being got tired of humanity's many atrocities and decided to wipe the slate clean. However, said being was not all knowing and didn't foresee the chaos that would entail if everyone just lost their memories. It's nice to see them addressing how this being also was flawed.
Now, onto the rant.
First of all, what's happened in the movie so far.
A man named Wataru travels in the remains of US after everyone has lost their memories. There he meets a woman named Sofia who strangely seems to still have her memories (strong hints that she's the one who caused the amnesia in the first place). The two travel together, talk a bit about humanity and its nature. Then Wataru meets another woman/girl who is about to be sacrificed to a "god" (an excavator). He tries to save her but in the end he fails as she willingly goes to the machine thinking it's the only thing that can save everyone else.
What bothers me about Wataru is that he did lose his memories but met a young disabled boy, Johnny, who had access to a machine that literally put information in Wataru's brain so he can talk, knows what everything is, can drive a car, shoot a gun and such things without problems. It feels a bit convoluted, especially since it feels like the only reason he is made to be "aware" is so he can have these philosophical discussions with Sofia. Except Sofia can read people's minds (or something) by touching them (she does so with the "feral" people).
I feel like the discussions would be better if they were between Johnny and Sofia since both of them remember how it used to be, and (I assume) both had suffered at the hands of humans. Wataru should still be there as Johnny's friend and an example of the goodness in humanity.
But sadly Johnny had to die in Wataru's backstory because I guess having a teenager in a wheelchair would make it hard to move around? Even though they mostly travel by car.
Another thing that bothers me is why does every single person have clothes on? If every person was reduced to the mind of a baby only operating on getting food then why are they all still wearing clothes? (Most people have to learn to get used to wearing clothes as babies/children, it's not something we're born with.) The story takes place at least half a year after the anti-memory wave and some of the characters are as neatly dressed as they were before.
I would be able to excuse this entire clothes thing as a "they didn't want to animate everyone nude" IF they didn't have one particular scene.
Wataru and Sofia bring the sacrifice girl to the sea and the girl, seeing the sea for the first time, just drops all her clothes on the spot and starts running around in the water. I think the scene is there to show how innocent and pure she is, but it feels like it's there just to put some nudity in the movie. Like they showed it all, full body. She didn't even need to remove the clothes! She already wore a dress. She could've already run in the water without getting wet!
Then she dies because for some reason the excavator had guns on it (I guess they really wanted to show it takes place in the US) and randomly/accidentally shot her when everyone was in a panic.
When Wataru tried to save the girl, there was also a middle aged man trying to help her too. This man is, by photo, revealed to be her dad and a former sheriff. The indication being that despite him forgetting who she was he still felt a need to protect her which was sweet. However showing it together with his "sheriff star" feels like the movie is saying because he was a "man of the law" he was more virtuous than others which was why he protected his child when no other parent seemingly did.
To top it off, after they "kill" the excavator Wataru teaches the man how to use a rifle, put the star back on his chest, and returns him to the group of scared humans who just tried to sacrifice his daughter. The man holds up the rifle and all the people start to worship him as messiah on the spot. With the message being that now they'll follow a righteous person instead of a false god they're going to do well/be good. But it feels more like they're just following the person who is able to use a weapon.
Then there's the racism/anti-blackness. So far there's only been one Black character. An old guy who somehow figured out how to operate the excavator/false god. So he was an evil, scary Black man demanding a white, pure, innocent woman as a sacrifice and he caused her death. Then Wataru, the hero, shoots and kills the man. Also, for a movie about discussions of morality it's strange Wataru shows no remorse or anything about killing another human, even if it was self-defense.
Also when Wataru first met Johnny, the pale boy was attacked by a large, almost nude, man with dark skin. So I'm halfway through this movie and there's already been two scenes with a dark, "monstrous, man attacking a frail, innocent white person and in both scenes are resolved by the attacker being shot in the head. Then the attacker is not mentioned again. Twice is a bit much for a coincidence so I'll just say:
That's racist!
I guess I'll do an update when I finish the movie and see if there's anything that can be salvaged from it. But how it looks currently I doubt it.