I like what Joel said here, about sexism. Like. What’s wrong with being liked by teenage girls?
Okay, I have something of a theory about why a lot of rock bands now have large female fanbases. It's a little rough, but here goes nothing-
So, a lot of older rock fans will tell female rock fans that they only like these bands because they think the members are hot. I call bullshit for two reasons:
1. Oh yes, THAT's why fans listen to their music. To listen to the singer's eyebrows.
2. If that was the case, then why didn't the hair metal bands of the 80's have large female fanbases (I know that rock didn't start in the 80's, but that's when the rockstar archetype was brought into public perception, so I'm going with it)? They also had male artists in them, that many people found attractive.
Rock has been a male dominated genre basically since its inception, but the fandom demographics have changed in the last 25ish years to having large female fandoms. Because of that, I think it's major BS to say that female fans only like certain bands because they think the members are attractive. If that was the case, then rock bands having female fans wouldn't be a new development.
What HAS changed, though, is the material that these bands write about.
Compare Motley Crue's Girls, Girls, Girls to Blind Channel's Die Another Day:
"Girls, girls, girls Long legs and burgundy lips Girls, girls, girls Dancin' down on Sunset Strip Girls, girls, girls Red lips, fingertips"
vs.
"This world is gonna fuck you up It's gonna get dark and it seems too tough You don't wanna carry on I know all about giving up 'Cause lately I've been looking hard Where is my love? Where is my luck? Where is my faith? My reason to die another day"
Or let's look at Pour Some Sugar on Me by Def Leppard and Savior 2 by Black Veil Brides:
"Pour some sugar on me Ooh, in the name of love Pour some sugar on me C'mon, fire me up Pour your sugar on me I can't get enough"
and
"So I'm trying my hardest to be what you made Like a court jester, my smile won't fade Giving it all, rising to fall to my grave Answer the call, living in thrall, you're the one born to save"
Finally, examine the lyrics between Nothin' but A Good Time by Poison and The Light Behind Your Eyes by My Chemical Romance:
"Don't need nothin' but a good time How can I resist? Ain't lookin' for nothin' but a good time And it don't get better than this"
vs.
"If I could be with you tonight I would sing you to sleep Never let them take the light behind your eyes One day I’ll lose this fight As we fade in the dark Just remember you will always burn as bright"
I think you can get the picture. While a lot of older bands were singing about things that guys could relate to more easily, a LOT of modern rock artists are using the medium to work through their own mental health issues, fears, insecurities, and more "emotional" subjects that women and girls can relate to more easily. PLEASE NOTE that not for a second am I trying to say that men and boys don't also struggle with these emotional issues. The fact that the modern songs I'm pointing to are all sung by AMAB artists should prove otherwise. But in a world where toxic masculinity prevents men and boys from working through or even acknowledging their own mental health and emotional struggles, it's women and girls that are going to try and work through their mental health and relate to material that discusses these things.
Female fans aren't getting more into rock music because they think the artists are hot. What they are responding to is the material in the songs. Since therapy is expensive but Spotify is free, listening to music is a common way to try and work through their emotional turmoil. And rock bands just happen to be, more and more, writing about these themes of insecurity, fear, and mental illness.















