I’m probably going to lose some Caps mutuals for this, but.
I think this kind of post is important to pass around for new-ish (and definitely new to the Caps) fans like me who may not have, upon entry into fandom, fully understood the entire context of Wilson’s history right away. I started to gain more of an understanding of it in recent weeks and have scaled back my posting about him as a consequence, but the last day of events has been especially eye-opening as all this history comes back up. Thank you for posting this.
For the people who were already fully aware and/or feel defensive about this because he’s Your Guy, I feel like you need to start asking yourselves which scenario is more likely:
a) that the refs, the league, and the DoPS, and also somehow all the players with broken faces and head injuries, have all spent the better part of a decade being like “you know what, fuck this one dude in particular, let’s ruin his reputation”; OR,
b) that this guy continually plays the game in a way that is not safe, and has apparently decided he cannot or does not want to absorb the message of previous sanctions and truly learn to play differently, but you have decided you’re okay with it because he is on your team instead of doing it TO your team.
Obviously the league bears so much responsibility for letting so many incidents occur again and again and again. But I think as fans we have to ask ourselves what we’re encouraging when we defend this pattern or try to pass it off as simply “league bias”. At a certain point you cannot keep ignoring the pattern. You cannot keep trying to separate what you imagine his intent might have been from the clear, repeated results of his actions. You have to ask what is being enabled by offering yet another second chance.
If a player was repeatedly taking actions that ended up with people in the hospital OFF ice, we’d be talking about “change hockey culture” and accountability. I know that many Caps fans on here are caring people who would want to have that difficult conversation if a player was committing serious off-ice harms and continued to be employed through it.
So, if you’re suddenly okay with that pattern of actions and results just because it takes place on the job instead of in his personal life, I really think you should re-examine that. You need to take a good hard look at it.
(By the way, as an update to the above for those worried, Carlo has now been released from hospital and is resting at home, according to Bruins PR this afternoon (March 6).)