WHY IS GEN ALPHA NOT SCHOOL?!?!?!
Youtube has shown me a couple of videos of someone reposting a Tiktok where a Teacher goes "Guys.... gen alpha CAN NOT (read/understand media/comprehend things) and I'm worried" and it makes me want to fucking scream. I say the following with full understanding that "generations" don't exist, that trying to place older and younger people in opposition is bullshit, and that trying to attribute behaviors to large groups of people is always a losing game, but more people will understand how I feel with these words so I don't care:
It feels spiritually millennial. Like we already had this conversation a long time ago but we have to re-hash it because I personally have now experienced it (or far more likely, because I personally have seen a Tiktok about it.) It feels like nobody's learning anything, they just want to talk about it until they feel like they have, and that all thought about this topic will be put down the moment we don't have to look at it anymore, until the next time it becomes a problem by looking at it.
I do not doubt for a single second that there is truth in what the teachers are describing. I'm not going to deny their reality. Speaking as somebody born in '96, who got to watch as the last sniffs of "The Good Times" closed every door in my face, who went along the same path of "gifted kid > burnout > unemployed internet freak," the anti-intellectualism these teachers are describing is not new, it is not specific to Gen Alpha, and if you retain one thing from this post let it be this:
Gen Alpha is "like that" because the internet has given the game away, and they are reacting rationally.
I do not say this as some kind of "SCHOOL SHOULD TEACH YOU SHIT THAT REALLY MATTERS" screed, fuck that whole argument. The idea of school isn't just that it teaches you stuff, it teaches you how to learn, and inspires in you a want to learn more. That hasn't been reality for at least 60-70 years, from what I know, and as someone who grew up watching Hank Green, PBS Kids, Bill Nye, all the shit that is incredibly worthwhile, that has never been my reality either. None of that actually prepares you for living in the US. If you think it does, I genuinely think that will be a big hurdle for you to clear before you ever understand the state of the US as much as you most likely want to.
FD Signifier, in a video discussing the asinine "why are black men not going to college??" discourse (watch his video, don't take my stupid ass's words as gospel, especially on topics of race) put it this way:
"[Black men who forego college] are simply just looking at college, at student loan debt, at wage slavery, and at a hostile work and educational environment, as a bad decision. They'd rather take the long shot at alternative venues of success (which, by the way, are highly marketed to them in our media) and saying hey, if I don't make it as a rapper, if I don't make it as a trapper, if I don't make it as a basketball player, then, y'know - maybe I'll make it at AutoZone."
I am not going to simply say, "This is a universal experience actually!" without acknowledging that FD is correct in his analysis and that his takes on black men and masculinity are always insightful, and that's why I want you to watch his video, with his words. The conjecture I would add is that this is a thought pattern which I believe is also increasingly prevalent the younger you are, the longer that we have lived in the post-modern capitalist shithole that is the current state of the world, and that young folks I have met tend to have a higher chance of having this mindset because the internet simply displays a hundred thousand things to you at once and doesn't tell you how to form an opinion on it or look up the things that led to it.
In my experience, as someone who's been both lucky enough to engage with real progressives and unlucky enough to engage with people who certainly think themselves progressives, when somebody is worrying about how The Kids Aren't Learning Anything, they are placing a value on learning that it does not functionally have. That is not a moral judgement. That is not a statement that learning isn't worthwhile. I wish above everything that learning and discovering science and culture and history and and nature and language and everything on this beautiful planet of ours was a worthwhile endeavor, but the reality is that my degree hasn't mattered since I was out of college for two years, and ever since then the only thing that's mattered is "can you lift a 50 pound box above your head and/or stand on your feet for 8 hours."
I can't, so I'm "useless." It doesn't matter if that's not actually true, if that's how I am constantly treated and made to feel by many of those around me, and it doesn't bring me any comfort knowing that people have it significantly worse than me for shit outside their control, nor does it bring me comfort to know that there are so many people who had things more in their control and "failed" anyway.
My office jobs were filled with primarily black women doing the actual work, and a gradient of mostly women filling in the in-between steps, becoming more and more oversaturated with white men and white women the further up the chain you went. My service and physical jobs were ones where primarily black men would do the difficult labor at the lowest levels, with a similar gradient the further up the chain you went - more and more white women and men in the positions with less and less physical responsibilities. This isn't even counting the undocumented migrants who are made to toil for pennies, or the literal slave labor we have in our prison system, and it certainly isn't counting the interconnected web of supply chains of suffering which keep the Imperial Core secure and well-fed. This is all written under the incorrect assumption that the bar for unjust suffering begins at "being poor or working class in the US," which it does not, but it is one of the only lenses I can actually argue from with some authority.
Gen Alpha does not need to learn how to retain information; if you're not going to a particularly "nice" college, you barely need to learn how to retain information to get by, at which point you can bleed out everything that isn't related to the specific place and specific tasks that your individual job requires of you. Gen Alpha has had the internet for their entire lives, so unless they live in a stable and positive environment (which, I don't think most adults do, let alone most young people and children) they can just see the reality that we live in, see the harsh edges which are going to or have already hurt them, and shrug and continue to scroll their phones because, fuck it, nothing matters anyway. Every single ad I get the few times I go on Twitch is a fucking gambling ad. More and more AI-generated art is being shown on billboards. Your labor was already worth a miniscule amount, and as long as I've been watching daytime TV and seeing News exposés on how random people IN YOUR CITY are struggling, I understood that it wasn't even worth that much because you need to have people dying alone with no security in order to have people desperate enough to do the shit jobs.
I live in a Midwestern city and I do not believe for a second that there will be real solidarity from the coasts when we inevitably require help in whatever hypothetical post-"socialist" utopia that people online want to believe in, because most of my life Red States were a punching bag by snot-nosed adult brats in fancy clothes. I understood how alone we were more than any of the people who could name more literature than me. That literature may have given me more, better words to describe it, but none of it would have given me enough words to convince people of reality, because I also learned a long time ago that learning and doing are two separate things, and learning only really matters so much as it can inspire you to do, and a lot of you don't want to do anything. If I, today, went back in time 10 years, I would not be able to stop us from getting to today, because I know none of you would have listened.
I have nothing but empathy for teachers, the US's schooling system is a fucking hellscape, but I also lived next to a now-retired teacher who never had anything good to say about her (mostly underprivileged) class, who could not conceive of children as anything other than a massive nuisance who can't just act right for some gosh darn reason. That is all I think of when I see a video talking about "kids these days aren't learning" -- somebody who, far sooner than they would like to believe, is going to have given up on the kids, given up on their job, and thrown up their hands. And hell, some of the time, I can't really blame them, but what chafes my ass is that it never seems to come from a place of concern for the children, just bewilderment at "why" and "how."
You should already know "why" by now. I saw all of this happening as a child. You should be able to recognize it as an adult.