Season 4 Theory/Booth Buddies Thoughts
Hey guys,
So I am gonna be careful in my plot prediction here but I’m gonna give it ago.
So firstly here are my thoughts on “Booth Buddies”. Back in school I had quite a few crushes on girls but for the most part, these crushes were less true attraction and more “I wish I could be here.” When Marco and Star were in the booth together they were expressing there feelings very differently. Star’s gut impression struck me as loud and “Just do something with your feelings” where as Marco’s description of their gut feelings was more uncertain.
It got revealed at the end of the episode the booth wasn’t even magic and that dude was just tricking them. And maybe Starco ends up being end game. The blood moon was present in this episode and Star and Marco’s cheek marks lit up. Arguably there is something there I won’t deny. But Marco does seem uncertain about something.
I mean granted, Marco hasn’t had much of a window to get with Star. Star dumped her feelings on Marco when Marco was with Jackie and then when Marco became available, Star was with Tom. Still I get this impression that Star is way more certain of her feelings, meanwhile Marco doesn’t seem to be quite as certain. And back in school, I kinda remember asking myself a lot, “Do I truly like this girl or do I just want to be her?”
I’m not gonna lie, certainly Marco does seem to have some legitimate feelings for Star, but there definitely seems to be some uncertainty there on Marco’s part too.
Anyway, I hope you enjoy that little theory.
Now for Season 4. I maybe way off but something tells me this is gonna be the season Marco comes out as trans. Sabrina Cotugno is the director and they only recently finished Season 3 fully. Chances are that the latter episodes aren’t even being boarded yet and they have a chance to get round Disney’s censors. Interestingly enough though, I realised I misread something a few months back. At a panel at CalArts back in September, Daron said Disney rarely contribute to Star being a flawed female lead but tend to make a lot of suggestions regarding Marco’s feminine side. Whether these are positive or negative suggestions this isn’t stated. So who knows maybe Disney are pushing for Marco to be more feminine.
Also SVTFOE is being moved to Disney Channel and although there is a large overlap in the target demographic of Disney XD (9-14) and Disney Channel, Disney Channel (9-16) does target a slightly older side of the demographic and for reference Andi Mack that features Disney first canon LGBT character who is part of the main cast airs on Disney Channel. The change in channel strikes me that the show is going to begin to deal with more controversial themes and also give the show more freedom in terms of what can make it past the censors. Interestingly enough the change in channel also quite neatly matches up with Marco and Star turning 15, meaning many of the issues that will start to face will be above the target demographic of Disney XD.
Now the question I need to ask, why oh why is Marco still wearing the Princess Marco outfit?
Firstly, it isn’t even their colour. Marco makes this very clear in the book. Secondly, in “Princess Turdina” Marco says how they find that corset downright uncomfortable. So why Marco would you go into battle in this outfit. It doesn’t make sense, it really doesn’t.
BUT for nearly 2 season now we trans Marco theorists, especially @breastforceand @marcodiazisatransgirl have been collecting evidence backing up the theory that Marco Diaz is a closeted trans girl and somewhere between Season 2 and the first episode of Season 3 airing, the crew became aware of this theory. Meaning they now have all that evidence too, meaning if they wished to make Marco canonically trans they have a lot ammunition to back that up with.
Now early in Season 2 in “Mr Candle Cares”, Marco expresses how they’d love to be Queen. It comes off as a gag at first but then they go into some detail about what this would entail. They have given this a fair bit of thought. Odd.
In “Red Belt”, Marco has a stuck in life dream. They are horrified to find themself buried in a suit. Also odd.
“Heinous”, Marco wants to keep wearing the dress even after Heinous has left.
In the book “Star and Marco’s Guide To Mastering Every Dimension”, Marco expresses that the Princess Marco dress isn’t their colour yet they continue to wear this thing, a dress that isn’t even their style. Marco also says how they are jealous of the fact Pony Head has no legs as it means she doesn’t have to make a pants decision every morning like Marco does. Marco makes the agonising decision of wearing the same pair of pants every single morning except for on special occasions. Something doesn’t sit right there.
And in “Princess Turdina”, Marco finally reveals the corset is hell to breath in.
And I have largely focused on the dress and Marco’s clothing choices here for the point I wish to make. But Marco repeatedly shows discomfort in their body. Don’t get me started on “Running With Scissors”, it is my favourite episode for trans Marco theory evidence and I can write a bleeding essay on it. And as for liking feminine things not making you a girl, I agree and have you seen Nacho’s and some of Marco’s more masculine interests. Even if Marco is trans, they totally wouldn’t be all girly girl I don’t reckon. Also just a final clothing point, Marco has a super bland wardrobe. Star switches up her outfits a lot, Marco is just red hoody, brown converse and grey/black jeans day in day out.
It seems established though Marco doesn’t particularly like this outfit though. It isn’t them. However Marco must like it for some reason and two things we do know, Marco finds wearing it liberating and they feel beautiful in it. Marco looking at the statue in “Princess Turdina”.
And here is the interesting thing, the point that really gives me power in shooting down the cis Marco theory or feminine Marco theory. The argument, “Marco is just a guy comfortable in expressing his feminine side.” I’ve been able to shoot this down in many ways before such as Marco’s insecurities, etc. But here is one I have to say, one that I really thinks seals it. If Marco were so comfortable in expressing their feminine side, why not get a comfier outfit? One that is in their colour and one without the constricting corset. Marco could ask Star if they could borrow an outfit, Marco certainly has the cash to buy an outfit from the shop or online if need be. Yet Marco does none of this and I think the reason being is it would raise too many questions.
Marco has this convenient reason to keep the Princess Turdina dress. If Janna is going through Marco’s stuff, there if an explanation. Marco can always give a convenient excuse for having that one outfit around. Even now Marco can argue they were asked to pose for some more Princess Turdina merchandise.
And okay, I’m gonna correct myself a little, this doesn’t 100% shoot down Marco being cis. Maybe Marco is cis and does like expressing their feminine side but they are scared of how the world will judge them. They have a convenient excuse for the Princess Turdina outfit but not others. I’m a trans Marco theorist though and my plot prediction is gonna focus on that.
So in “Divide” and “Conquer” Marco resumes the Princess Turdina persona and this promo was also released on the Trans Day of Visibility which is beyond interesting. Their now ceases to be a clear reason as to why Marco would keep up this persona, my only explanation here is Marco feels more comfortable presenting as female.
I haven’t really enjoyed this Season. Marco has been immensely off character. I have had a theory for a while though and it related back to Angie saying that Marco needs their own “French Summer”. Marco needed a chance to find themselves and I think the reason Marco has been so off this Season is cos that is what Marco has been doing. Finding their true self and do you know something, Marco has been such a horrible character this season. A bad friend, a bad son, a bad boyfriend and just in general a bad character. And all these have lead to their own individual climaxes. Jackie and Marco breaking up and Marco not fighting for her, Marco ignoring their parents and neglecting to realise they had a baby brother on the way, Marco not being a great squire or friend to Star (”Night Life” and “Trial by Squire”), Marco not being a great friend to their friends on Earth (”Sophomore Slump”) and Marco being a bad boyfriend to Kelly and a bad friend to Tom, kissing Star in “Booth Buddies”.
And I believe Marco to be a good character, I believe all this to be building up inside of Marco and I like to think kissing Star was kinda the icing on a very bad cake, the icing that will make Marco question, “Why am I doing all this crap?” And look, I would love Marco to come out in the Season 3 finale, but I don’t this will happen but if on the off chance Disney has okayed a trans Marco storyline for Season 4, my theory is that Marco has finally put the pieces together. My theory is Marco has figured out they are trans and Marco dressing as Princess Turdina in “Divide” and “Conquer” is the first step out of the closet. I mean, even if Marco doesn’t say why they are dressing as Princess Turdina still, it is certainly going to invite some questions. And my theory is, that is the set up, Marco dressing as Princess Turdina as a means to push their friends to ask Marco the question, “Why? Why do you continue to dress like a princess Marco?” And that Season 4 picks up the trans Marco storyline from there.
I maybe way off, but I hope you enjoy my little theory/plot prediction. Let me know what you think.
EDIT: I got it wrong about Kelly and Marco being together. They’ve just seemed awfully close lately. The rest of my point still stands though and regardless Kelly was clearly Marco’s plus one at that wedding.