To survive as a Big 2 comics reader, one of the things you have to get used to is authors who you normally cannot stand to read sometimes coming up with work that you genuinely can't help but love.
I think Tom Taylor and Joshua Williamson are both examples of mediocre writers with mostly undeserved plaudits - but by God if they didn't both make me cry this week with their respective books. (Detective Comics Annual '26 and Action Comics Annual - Year One Thousand)
In 'Tec you have Lobo, Batman, a murder accusation from a distant planet, an alliance under threat of ingested mini-suns, an off-world bar, a frame-up - and a Black Mercy. You know, the alien plant which when it attaches to you, paralyzes your nervous system, and sends you into a customized utopia which you cannot distinguish from reality. And from which you cannot escape unless you die, or are able to break away from the world of your dreams where everything you desire from the bottom of your heart is true.
So of course Batman and Lobo are attacked with the Black Mercy.
Bruce experiences a world where Selina is his wife. Helena exists, with a teasing yet doting older brother Damian, who in turn has Talia as a semi-involved mother. Bruce's parents and Alfred are alive, his mother is Mayor, and his parents regularly take Damian and Helena out to the movies so that Bruce and Selina can have a night off. However he is still Batman and she is still Catwoman, but now they get to enjoy the fruits of their labours as finally, Gotham is safe. (Yes - Dick, Barbara, Tim, Steph, Cass are shown to exist and be around.)
As far as dreams go this is a popular take (though I personally don't agree with all of it), and while I love it - these are not the panels which made me cry. However idyllic this dream world is, there is no fooling Batman. While having tea with Alfred on the terrace the next morning Batman turns up and confirms what Bruce has always known - that the world he is in is not real.
Then this panel happens, and cue the tears.
Then we have Williamson, and the long awaited news of what happened to Clark after the climactic KO battle where Superman proved WHY he's the greatest superhero of all time. He won, put everything Darkseid ruined on Earth to rights, and was crowned King Omega. Then he disappeared and we didn't know where he was till now.
Answer - time stream shenanigans. I won't get into the comic book sci-fi plot points; but suffice to say that time has been a fundamental building block of Superman stories. Clark struggling with the concept of being essentially immortal and having to watch as everything and everyone he loves wither away and vanish while he remains unchanged was a recurring motif in Pre-Crisis, and in the first post-Crisis decade.
We see it again in this issue.
This is juxtaposed with Clark losing all sense of time and place and reality while in the time stream, only anchored by his promise to return home to Lois - and the fear that he will miss whatever little time he can have with her. Leading to these poignant and bittersweet panels.
And finally - how it all comes full circle. How Superman comes home from the end of known time. How he reconciles his fear of the future with his joy of the past and the present.
Well done, Taylor and Williamson. I doubt you will ever be in my Top 30 Favourite Comics Authors, but credit where credit is due - these two issues were excellent.
@vintagerobin Re: Your tags
I will take your word for it about Williamson's work on Flash - I have not touched any of either Barry or Wally comics post Flashpoint. His work on Superman hasn't given me much cause for complaint, but then again it is also not a run I feel the slightest need to my collection. I have found his work mostly banal and surface level, though he is much more respectful of other characters orbiting around his titular character than Taylor is. He is better than Bendis, but then again that is no benchmark - not when Rebirth has had Tomasi, Jurgens and PKJ.
However I have been pleasantly surprised by his handling of KO, and after. Scott Snyder and Joshua Williamson together on a cosmic event had every chance of it being an incomprehensible headache, but it was quite decent, even if not extraordinary. The All-In Special was also very well done. So I agree that his strength probably does lie in the more cosmic stories, and I do think he will do LoSH justice.
I'm less inclined to give him a pass on being truthful to legacy - every time I remember his Mother Soul storyline I fly into a rage.










