http://headspacepress.com/right-thing-admit-banning-alex-jones-kinda-wrong/
Do the Right Thing, Admit Banning Alex Jones is Kinda Wrong
Let’s get the obligatory out of the way: Alex Jones is the worst. He’s a malicious blowhard the likes of which we’ve perhaps never seen. The perfectly horrible lovechild of late-stage capitalism and an American identity crisis. A living lab experiment babbling to its inevitable conclusion. Alex Jones has made millions off the fear and weaponized hyper-partisanship that beleaguers our culture, adding nothing to the world but more ugliness.
Yet I’m still not sure that banning him is the right thing to do. And it’s this doubt, this hesitance, that feels crucial.
Last week a group of major media companies (Facebook, YouTube, Spotify, and Apple podcasts) all nearly simultaneously removed Alex Jones and his content from their platforms. Jones’ and his InfoWars rantings have millions of loyal followers, including President Trump, so this kind of industry-wide ban was big news.
The reactions have so far been familiar: mild outrage from the right; wide approval from the left. But reading through the subsequent commentary, there seems to be something different in this latest skirmish of the free speech wars.
An assumed consensus.
As of today, the only major platform not to ban Jones is Twitter. And we are not pleased.
“Twitter’s stance on Infowars’ Alex Jones should be a moment of reckoning for users. The site has arrived at a moral crossroads — and it’s choosing the wrong path — VOX
“Twitter is the last major host for Alex Jones’s rants. Why does he get to break their rules?” — The Guardian
“Twitter Finally Admits Alex Jones Violated Their Rules and Still Won’t Do Anything About It” — GQ
Almost every major media platform has banned Jones (Vimeo just bounced him after he sought refuge there), but this near-complete exile is apparently not enough. Despite some decent moral reasoning and promises to address the evolving problem of online abuse, the outcry against Twitter for delaying their part in Jones’ total execution has been swift and relentless and, most troubling, seemingly unanimous.
Even with my progressive leanings, I was personally heartened to hear that a major gatekeeper had taken a moment to consider their position as arbiter of truth. To resist the pressure of the majority. To acknowledge that in the world of free speech, restricting anyone, no matter how unpopular, is a precedent we should be very wary of setting.
Now it could be because I’m currently binging The Handmaid’s Tale, but the whole thing feels kind of, well, totalitarian.
Expected compliance. Intolerance for dissent. An assumption that you must do this thing because it’s the right thing to do and that’s all there is to say about it.
Photo: Hulu
Forget all that free speech stuff. That at the core of any doubt is a devotion to the potentially oppressed. That access to speech being controlled by a private corporation, beholden to nothing but arbitrary considerations, should be a very worrisome prospect for those concerned with minority rights and unequal access to power.
Forget even that we might simply take a moment. An opportunity to stop, reevaluate our positions, consider this new world we are navigating.
No. First you do it and do it now. Then we’ll talk. The cleansing must be complete. For we are building a better world. (Just ignore the dead bodies hanging from the wall)
Oh you crazy lefties, you make it so easy. But then I look at the White House. The country. The contrast between what is and what should be. And I get it.
Today the President of the United States tweeted that a black woman who used to work for him was a lowlife dog.
I understand the urgency. The impatience. It’s time for something new and we’re no longer gonna wait.
Like we did with #MeToo and gay rights and Black Lives Matter — this is just the way it’s going to be. Yes, we are making the decisions for you now. So here are female Ghostbusters and a black President and a gay neighbor and an immigrant schoolmate and we’re gonna keep putting this shit in your face until you get used to it and shun away anyone who doesn’t.
Because it’s the right thing to do and we’re tired of waiting for you to grow up.
No more kids gloves. Maybe in the end this is the way it has to be. The way change is catalyzed, cauterized.
Maybe.
The problem with the faithful in The Handmaid’s Tale’s newly built utopia isn’t that they justify any means for their undeniably worthy ends — it’s that they actively don’t let themselves see their own sins. Despite daily doses of hanging nooses and restricted rights, all they permit themselves to see is the cause. And so with every cognizant self-betrayal they become more lost.
So please dispense with the “I’m a staunch supporter of free speech, but…” Just admit what you’re doing. A grown up finally dragging their asshole kid by the wrist, spanking them for everyone’s good even though you really really don’t normally condone violence.
As in the fictional Gilead, it may be sometimes necessary to get one’s hands dirty for the greater good — but know that you are. Consistently let yourself see the moral bends along the way, like breadcrumbs to find your way back.
***














