Tonight had been harder on Padfoot and Moony than it was on James, who’d mostly just sat by quietly while his mates wrestled with very similar demons together. He was glad they had each other, glad they’d found a way to relate and seemingly put all that stuff from fifth year behind them. It made him feel hopeful; not only had they talked so openly with each other and resolved to try to change their more destructive habits, but they’d also made the choice to confide in James after the fact, to rehash that difficult conversation so James would be included in it. That meant more than James felt he could express, especially when he felt like he had so little to offer them. So he didn’t push when Sirius spoke as if to say something else and then trailed off. A lot of progress had been made; maybe whatever Padfoot wanted to say, he’d be able to say it to Moony. James gave his mate a small smile at Padfoot’s addition that they couldn’t have done it without him. He wasn’t so sure that was true, but he appreciated the sentiment. Maybe it was enough that he’d helped give Padfoot and Moony a space where they could be open with each other, even if he couldn’t fix everything for them. Maybe. James reached over and clasped a hand on Padfoot’s shoulder. “Well, I’m not going anywhere,” he said. He was surprised when Padfoot seemed to come back to what he’d started to say before. He squeezed his mate’s shoulder as Padfoot struggled with his words, understanding and concern working their way across his features as Padfoot spoke.
“You’re not gonna let us down, Padfoot,” James said first, because that felt the most important. “The only way you can do that is if you just stop trying,” he added, hopeful that the words wouldn’t make him worry about that but instead show him that all that mattered was he was trying, no matter how long it took him to get where he wanted to be, no matter how many setbacks there might be along the way. “Maybe it’s time to stop worrying whether or not you’re acting like a Black,” he added gently, going back to the fear Sirius had voiced. “You’ve already proven you’re not like them in all the important ways. That’s not a switch that’s just gonna flip if you stop trying to be different from your family in every way imaginable.” That seemed to be what Sirius was afraid of. “Your family….and all the people on the other side – they’re people. Like it or not, we’re all gonna have things in common with them. What sets us apart in the ways that matter is our choices. Whatever feeling it was that told you your family was wrong, that made you protect Regulus, that made you sit with me on the train the first day of Hogwarts instead of all your cousins – it doesn’t matter if that was rebellion or what. It was you. Your choices, your courage, your desire to think for yourself instead of doing what your parents said because even that young, you knew what they wanted was fucked up. That’s what separates you and Andie and Regulus from the Blacks who didn’t leave.” James chose his words carefully there. He still thought Sirius was way better than Regulus, but Andie wasn’t half bad and he didn’t think painting Regulus as worse was going to help Sirius with this family-related identity crisis. Maybe acknowledging there were two other people in his family who weren’t horrible would help him with that.
Sirius wanted to feel reassured by Prongs’ words. Except, as Moony had pointed out earlier, it wasn’t gonna be the same after the war. Both Moony and Prongs were gong to leave him. It was another fear of Sirius’s. All alone with only the worst parts of himself, because Prongs and Moony felt like the best parts. It was difficult not to let his mind go back to some of the awful things his family had snarled at him when he thought about being alone. Prongs’ hand on his shoulder helped him keep going instead of getting drowned in his own thoughts and memories. Maybe made it a little too easy since he found himself confessing his fears once again tonight. He loved James, not only for what he was saying, but because Sirius knew Prongs believed it. He’d spent the first half of his life with people who inventoried every mistake, big or small. All for the purpose of holding them against you at every opportunity. Not James Potter. Despite the mental gymnastics Sirius was capable of when it came to thinking people were going to abandon him, he knew that. James wasn’t the opposite either. As much as Sirius sometimes wanted to act like Prongs just held on to his broken things out of sentimentality he knew. James was perfectly able and willing to dismiss a person as being a lost cause, not worth his time. He’d known that before Peter. It was what had made Pete’s betrayal so shocking. Sirius could see betraying him, or Moony, but Peter had betrayed James Potter. Unthinkable. But somehow Prongs, despite Sirius giving him multiple opportunities to decide otherwise, still thought he was worth it. That he wouldn’t let them down. The only standard Sirius desperately wanted to live up too. He wanted to be the person Prongs thought he was. Sirius just didn’t know how, or if it was even possible. While Prongs telling him he wasn’t going anywhere hadn’t been the reassurance James likely thought it was, Prongs continued belief in him was. It still didn’t feel deserved but he didn’t want to lose it.
A lot of what he was saying about the fear Sirius had voiced felt a lot like the sort of stuff Andie said when she’d told him to forgive himself for being a Black. A phrase that still felt weird, impossible, and like some Hufflepuff nonsense she’d picked up from that husband of hers. Even Prongs sort of being on board didn’t stop it from feeling like any of it. As hard as it was he listened to Prongs. Even when his mind supplied counter arguments. Had he protected Regulus? The scar on his arm said otherwise. Truthfully Sirius wasn’t even sure that he’d known that his family was wrong. Just that he didn’t like them, was that the same? Not sitting with his cousins had been an easy choice. He hated Bella and Cissy. Hated the people they associated with, the Lestranges, Malfoy, all the other losers in green ties. He still wasn’t sure what had made him sit beside James Potter that day. He’d passed plenty of empty seats, even some whole compartments that hadn’t been taken yet. Just like he didn’t understand what made James take one look at a surly, unwanted kid and decide they should be mates. It was a surprise when James mentioned Regulus. That he managed to lump Regulus in with Sirius and Andie without any problem. Sirius had always wanted Reg and James to get along. But truthfully when things started going from bad to worse with him and Regulus, he didn’t mind James being anti-Regulus. Liked someone being that fiercely on his side just as much as it annoyed him that Regulus was anti-James. Sure it made him feel guilty whenever he tried with Regulus, worried he was betraying James. But James’s fierce loyalty helped ease the sting of Regulus’s continued rejection. He sighed, tugging roughly on his hair. It was all so complicated and confusing. “What if there is a switch,” he asked, not able to let that fear go. “What if my dad was right and I’m like Walburga? What if I’m not just anger but the rest of what I am is worse? Bella said all I was rebelling against was my nature.”It was like a constant battle in his head, Prongs voice verses all the Blacks. He looked at James in despair. Sirius didn’t like talking about the things his family had said that still haunted him. Hadn’t even told James everything that had gone down the night he’d showed up soaked and scared at the Potters’s door. Rationally he knew that it wouldn’t change Prongs’ opinion of him but he couldn’t help worrying it would. He still remembered the first howler he’d gotten the horrified expressions of his dormmates as his mother’s vile voice shouted terrible things at him. The shame of it. Sirius had been expecting it but it was clear that no one else in that room had a mother who would say such things. He’d tried his best after that to hide the worst of it, random things spilling out here or there in vulnerable times. The rest locked up in his head. This was where he’d usually run away, if not physically than mentally. Do something, anything, to try and distract from the garbage his family spewed at him. It seldom worked with Prongs but that didn’t stop him from trying. Despite it being hard not to do just that he didn’t. Seemed like tonight he was facing the truth, first with Moony in the backyard and now with Prongs in the kitchen. It sucked.