@imwatchingyoumarlene - Tumblr Blog

Posts

tremolux

Got a feeling Ava’s blogging isn’t profitable, and she’s just been living on the stolen funds her dad left her.

That’s a secret that can be exploited.

a-hound-of-tindalos

If you remember

I will personally hand a you a certificate of good childhood taste.

thebestplltheories

Well that was fun! Thank you so much Caitlin, this was an honour and you tied a pretty little bow on this experience. 💙

http://www.wetpaint.com/spencer-twin-theory-thebestplltheories-tumblr-interview-1601255/

keeganallennews

needleinapileofneedles-deactiva

Yes

mayasdeluca

#you tell her mary

endiness

“So you— you broke up with him?” “No. No, I could never do that. But he is always close by.”

mxnrique

me: i hate country music

shania twain: let’s go girls!

me:

littleturtleduck

me: i hate country music

carrie underwood: right now, he’s probably-

me:

madsrocketship

Me: I hate country music

Beyoncé: daddy’s little girl

Me:

mxnrique

me: i hate country music

dolly parton: jolene jolene jolene jooooleeeeeeeeene

me:

black-sadness

me: i hate country music

Lady Antebellum: It’s a quarter after one!

me:

tryforce-deactivated20211211

me: i hate country music

Rascal Flats: Life is a highway!

me:

fuckyeahprettylittleliar

Me @ Marlene in previous interviews though…

peter-sluttin-it-up-hasting-blo

😂

imwatchingyoumarlene

YASSSS 😂🤣😂🤣

fosteringcallie-deactivated2019

Reblog if you're going to remain in the fandom after PLL ends

I want to see how many of you are doing this with me

prettylittlesmartass

So, we were led to believe for *years* that the girls were being punished for something that happened that night. YEARS.

thebestplltheories

No, we were never “lead” to believe this. It was just a theory. A really popular theory, which never ended up coming true.

prettylittlesmartass

Yes, we were.

“You know me, Spencer. You killed me.” For the A message with the dirt in Spencer’s bed.

The blood on Spencer’s clothing in the Dollhouse.

Flashbacks of both Emily and Spencer hitting “Ali”.

Melissa’s confession to burying who she thought was Ali because she was trying to protect Spencer.

Bethany being dressed as Ali that night, including a bracelet. The letters between Ali and Bethany. We know who hit Ali though how did Bethany end up in the ground? Was that all Mona?

Why have Sara Harvey dressed in the “That Night” get up in the Dollhouse? Why have Mona dressed up that way in the Dollhouse?

Flashbacks of that night- why put so much emphasis on the Liars being drugged?

Dream and hallucination Ali telling different girls that they all know more about that night than the realize?

I would have to go back over the A messages, though am pretty sure there were more alluding to them doing something wrong that night.

I get that AD is different than A, and that this was supposed to be a totally separate storyline. I am just not happy with it at all, because they could have woven together a flowing story from start to finish. Those Patsy Cline songs were supposed to be so important and such a huge clue, and she addressed them by Charlotte giving an album to Alex saying they were important to her?

It is what it is. In my opinion, it could have been so much stronger. At the very least, I think the fans would have enjoyed this much more if Marlene hadn’t over promised, over shared, over anagramed, etc.

lying-little-legend-blog

This ^^ is something I wish the writers gave better closure on. There were so many opportunities to make sense of these threats through the final reveal. For example, the vial of blood that wound up in Spencer’s bag when she was in London during an episode of 5B could have also been linked back to Alex, had the writers only spent a little time trying to make this reveal a little more impactful.

peter-sluttin-it-up-hasting-blo

The liars are irrelevant characters in a show that is actually supposed to be about them. They don’t tie into the plot or the mystery. The show became CeCe’s. She stole the game and the story, just like she said to Mona. The entire mystery is about a character that’s been in 11 or 12 episodes and that the majority of the fandom did not care about. The girl in the grave is meaningless. That night is meaningless as the main characters are detached from this entire plot–the entire mystery. They were reduced to secondary characters whose main existence was reduced to their love lives. In the end they were not even allowed to solve the mystery. This is awful storytelling.

The show used to be all about the girl in the grave and the liars involvement in the events of this night. And this was taken away from them and us.

“The four of you combined, you remember more about that night than you think you do.” They literally knew nothing because they were asleep.

All this could have been fixed if CeCe had lied and Alex had been woven into the story from the start. We were promised an Uber A. Uber means above all… above all the other A’s. AD, Alex, should have been the one who has always been there… but her character, just like the liars, was overshadowed by CeCe. Alex only exists because of CeCe.

The CeCe reveal destroyed this entire show and it never recovered from it. Marlene loved her CeCe reveal and she didn’t want to “undo” it.

AD doesn’t deserve the title of “Uber A.” There is no Uber A. That was Marlene’s biggest lie.

We were lied to. We were dragged along. We were promised that the lady in black and Uber A are pll endgame. The lady in black was Sara Harvey–who used to be a stock photo. And we still don’t even know 80% of her story and we never will. And they told us that Uber A and AD are the same person. Well, Uber A didn’t arrive until 10 episodes ago… just like with Sara, we will never really get to know Alex. None of these reveals made sense, nor do they explain why these girls needed to be tortured.

We were dragged along for nothing just like the liars were tortured for nothing.

We were lied to.

prettylittlesmartass

“The CeCe reveal destroyed this entire show and it never recovered from it.  Marlene loved her CeCe reveal and she didn’t want to “undo” it.”

Yes, thank you!! That right there is what it really is.

One of the things that got me thinking someone had a twin (and that someone was Spencer) was the episode with a Wilden’s funeral, where we see Black a Widow. If memory serves, as we see her, the Digital Daggers song, “The Devil Within”, starts to play, and would have been perfect to play again as Alex explained how she was there for years:

I will keep quiet You won’t even know I’m here You won’t suspect a thing You won’t see me in the mirror But I crept into your heart You can’t make me disappear Til I make you

I made myself at home In the cobwebs and the lies I’m learning all your tricks I can hurt you from inside I made myself a promise You would never see me cry Til I make you

You’ll never know what hit you Won’t see me closing in I’m gonna make you suffer This hell you put me in I’m underneath your skin The devil within You’ll never know what hit you

I will be here When you think you’re all alone Seeping through the cracks I’m the poison in your bones My love is your disease I won’t let it set you free Til I break you

You’ll never know what hit you Won’t see me closing in I’m gonna make you suffer This hell you put me in I’m underneath your skin The devil within You’ll never know what hit you

I tried to be the lover to your nightmare Look what you made of me Now I’m a heavy burden that you can’t bear Look what you made of me Look what you made of me I’ll make you see

You’ll never know what hit you Won’t see me closing in I’m gonna make you suffer This hell you put me in I’m underneath your skin The devil within You’ll never know what hit you

The devil within You’ll never know what hit you

peter-sluttin-it-up-hasting-blo

Yes. Agree about the song. Black widow should have been a twin because it makes no sense for Sara Harvey to cover her face like that. No one knew who she was, she could have walked in there without a veil and no one would have recognized her. Same with the Ali wig. Red coat should have been a brunette. Why else would she need the Ali wig? Sara and CeCe had hair like Ali, there was no reason for them to wear a wig. It would have made sense for Alex to get both these roles. Black Widow’s figure resembled Troian’s. Marlene could have fixed this so easily in the last 10 eps, but instead she forced all those love triangles down our throats. Alex would have easily fit into past seasons. Such a wasted opportunity.

takeanempanada

Can you imagine what this show might have been if there was someone different than Marlene pulling the strings? I mean welcome to the dollhouse was legitimately scary. And then they got out and it barely got mentioned again. Why was there a man in the dollhouse if Charlotte already transitioned? I mean the list of inconsisties can literally go on forever. The Cece reveal was the worst. It ruined the show and the finale didn’t save it.

plltheorygang

not to be dramatic but everyday for the rest of my life I'll think about how I wasted 7 years for this show only for nothing to make sense and unanswered plot holes

yawnjockey

The problem with the finale

Lest anyone think I’m just bitching for fun… or because of some vanity over my theories not being correct.

1. The twin storyline is already weak and overdone. BUT it could have been ok if it was better executed.

2. Toby is a victim of rape! Again! Twice by Alex and a few times by Jenna!

3. Nothing tied back to previous seasons.

4. There are still SOOOO many unanswered questions!!! What the fuck?!!

5. They didn’t close up ANY plot holes at alllll

6. Are we to just assume that Alex kidnapped Hanna?

7. If Mona killed Charlotte why is Mona still alive???

8. Ezra Fitz is one of the worst humans on television and he got a happy ending.

9. Byron actually blessed his daughters marriage to her abuser!!! I threw up in my mouth.

10. Lol so Sara Harvey is just red coat/black veil.

11. No one died and I crave not just death but violence to soothe my years long suffering.

12. I can no longer pretend that the Charlotte reveal isn’t canon and a part of me died with that hope.

13. Motive was bullshit times a thousand. Children could write better.

14. I actually hurt from my wasted energy. I literally feel like a part of me has died, and that’s the part that will ever invest in something I can’t control again.