When I was younger, I couldn’t have explained why I didn’t like the Simpsons. I just didn’t. It had funny jokes sometimes, which was easy to acknowledge if you showed me scenes from it out of context, but whenever I just sat and watched the show, I actively disliked it and after some point started avoiding it.
Revisiting some of it as an adult, it’s much easier to articulate. The Simpsons is horrible and depressing. It’s a mirror world, a parody of ours, where everything and everybody sucks. It’s one of the most misanthropic articles of American culture.
It’s about Homer, who’s just some random idiot, who in the beginning is at least sort of a well-meaning person, but as the show goes on even that becomes questionable. His family is stupid and dysfunctional, which is probably largely his fault considering he’s a physically abusive alcoholic father. Despite their house being weirdly large, it’s intended to be low quality and the family constantly on the brink financially, despite Homer giving up on all his dreams to work a job he hates trying to maintain stability.
Speaking of which, his job sucks. He doesn’t like it, he’s not remotely competent at it. His boss mistreats everybody and is a criminal if not downright evil. The police are all stupid incompetents, the town is run by a horribly corrupt and cynical mayor who gets reëlected anyway because everyone in the town is stupid.
There’s a priest character who’s dry, petty, and burned out, basically just showing up and doing his job as a 9 to 5 without caring. The only person in the show with a positive disposition at all is their neighbour, Ned, whom Homer despises and whose positivity is just something to make fun of. as the writers destroy his life and take everything from him for laughs.
Homer spends his free time at a bar run by a depressed, suicidal incel who’s jealous of his wife, alongside his stupid alcoholic friends, one of whom has completely destroyed his life drinking and whom the show gives no relief or redemption (the punchline is “haha, this guy used to be happy and functional, but now he’s a miserable fat alcoholic!” and that’s it).
The children’s television is all mindless crap, orchestrated by Krusty, who’s a cynical, drug-addicted criminal who shamelessly does whatever gets him paid.
I also really dislike their portrayal of the elderly. Every older person in the show is portrayed horribly. It’s like they’re all dementia patients who sit around doing nothing and having no value to society whatsoever. It feels downright hateful, like everybody in the writing room had a bad relationship with their grandparents.
Maybe if you have nostalgia-goggles because you saw this show on TV when you were a kid like I did, you got so used to how horrible its world was that after some point you don’t even feel it anymore. Stop me before I start thinking about how much the Simpsons alone may have contributed to a generation of 30-to-50 year-olds growing up to be jaded, cynical, ungrateful, pessimistic burn-outs.