The Ultimate Moffat Critique Masterpost
Okay, so…here it is. I said I wanted to do this and I did. This has taken me FOREVER to put together and this isn’t even everything out there.
First of all, this is not meant to hate on Steven Moffat. This is criticism. Don’t go saying that all this post does is degrade Moffat; this post is to bring to light all the shit he’s done.
If any of these links don’t work or lead to the wrong place, please let me know. Additionally, if there is something you have that you want to see on here, just send me the link. I’ll be updating regularly with other stuff that I find, but I’m sure there’s other posts and articles that belong here. Right now I just really want to get this out there. Also, if there is something on here that you wrote and you don’t want it here, let me know. I’ll happily take it off.
8 examples of why Steven Moffat is NOT a feminist
(A wee bit late) The Girl in the Fireplace and why I dislike it…
About Amy’s and Rory’s families
About companions throughout the show
All That We’re Left With Is ‘The How’
Breaking Up With Doctor Who
Deconstructing Moffat Fanboys (and why they will always choose to believe ten was in love with and shagged reinette)
Doctor Who fans and thinking critically (not necessarily moffat crit but it discusses why we need to think critically about the show)
Doctor Who: On Respecting the Audience
Doctor Who Ramblings (thoughts on Hide, JTTCOTT, and TCH)
Doctor Who, Timelines, and that Odious Episode Known as Girl in the Fireplace
Doctor/Rose vs. Doctor/River
Eleven Sexually Assaults and Sexualises Jenny in The Crimson Horror by Mark Gatiss (Series 7 Episode 11)
Eleven/River’s abusive relationship (compared to Bella/Edward)
Emotionally Manipulating the Audience: The Silence vs Gallifrey
Families in Doctor Who (video)
Fast Forwarding through Character Development
Feminism, Steven Moffat, and why you should care (includes long analysis in comments)
Feminists working with Moffat
Go home, Digital Spy, you’re drunk (GitF meta)
How Clara Saved the Universe
*How Let’s Kill Hitler was offensive
How Steven Moffat Ruined Doctor Who
How Moffat mistreated Rose, Martha, and Donna
“I’m annoyed by any form of criticism"
Inconsistent characterization
Irene Adler: how to butcher a brilliant woman character
Karen Gillan, Amy Pond, Sexism and Steven Moffat
Let’s Talk About Elizabeth
Let’s Talk About Sally Donovan
Mary reveal vs Elementary!Moriarty reveal
Mental Illness in the Moffat Era
Moffat calling Nancy from TEC/TDD a slut
Moffat and Doctor Who’s popularity
Moffat’s assumption that we don’t care about companions
Moffat’s Female Characters
Moffat’s Magnificent Mystical Pregnancy
More rebuttals to an article
More thoughts on the Time of the Doctor
More on female characters
More rebuttals to a pro-Moffat post
On Amy’s mystical pregnancy
On sexual assault and rape
One off characters: RTD vs Moffat
Open Letters to Moffat Masterpost
Personal thoughts on Amy’s pregnancy/River’s birth
Plot revolving around the Doctor
POC with dialogue per episode RTD vs Moffat
Problem with Gallifrey falls no more plotline
Problems with Vastra and Jenny
Queer Representation and Visibility in Doctor Who - Canton Everett Delaware III
Queer Representation and Visibility in Doctor Who - River Song
Queer Representation and Visibility in Doctor Who - The Fat One and The Thin One
Questions Of A Confused Doctor Who Fan
Questions to do with the genocide of the Silence
Racism: Elementary vs Sherlock
Rebuttals to a Moffat stan post
Repeating female characters
River Song and Her Relationship with The Doctor
River and the Doctor’s abusive relationship
Rose leaving vs Amy leaving
Rose vs. River and the next installment
Rose vs River: The Doctor’s love for them
RTD’s era and Classic Era
Sacrifice in The Rings of Akhaten
Searching for a Dramatic Moment
Sherlock is Not a Sociopath
Statistical and Visual Representation of POC characters in New Who
Steven Moffat and Sexually Harassment/Assault
Steven Moffat and the Suspension of Disbelief
Steven Moffat is a Douchebag - The Masterlist
Steven Moffat, Sex And Me
Stop Excusing Eleven Sexually Assaulting Jenny Flint!
Support for the line “Don’t you think he looks tired?”
Taking away female characters’ agency
Ten Kisses Martha Jones vs Eleven Kisses Jenny Flint
Ten out of character during The Day of the Doctor and a similar post
The Bechdel Test and Doctor Who: So What’s the Big Deal?
*The Case of River Song and Her Insta-Love
The Casting of Martha Jones and Amy Pond. RTD vs Moffat.
The Day of the Doctor: a Case of Canon vs. Canon
The Doctor waiting outside Clara’s home
The Doctor’s death and inviting his friends
The Double-Edged Doctor Who Sword that is Steven Moffat’s Rose
The Eleventh Doctor Is Not My Hero (video)
The Girl in the Fireplace Criticism
The Girl in the Fireplace: Problematic Themes
The Girl Who Waited: Why I Hate Amy Pond
The male gaze in Moffat’s Era
The Problem With Moffat Era Doctor Who (By Claudia Boleyn)
The Problem With Moffat’s Reset Button
The Problem With River Song
The role of the companion
The Woman Who Waited…But Was Apparently Forgotten By The Narrative
Thoughts on The Girl in the Fireplace
Thoughts on The Name of the Doctor
We Need To Talk About Clara Oswald by Claudia Boleyn (video)
What is wrong with Doctor Who?
What Steven Moffat Doesn’t Understand About Grief, And Why It’s Killing Doctor Who
Ways to fix the plot holes
Why does everyone hate GitF
Why I Don’t Like Steven Moffat’s Doctor Who
*Why I’m Nine’s Woman, Through and Through
*Why Moffat is ruining Doctor Who
Why Moffat shouldn’t write a female doctor
Why Resetting Time Is Annoying And Bad Writing
Why You Should Love Sally Donovan (video)
Women in the 50th Anniversary Special
Doctor Who’s Girl-Women Weirdness
‘Doctor Who’ Christmas special was everything fans dislike about the Moffat Era
Fixing Doctor Who - Season Five Edition
For Whom the (Cloister) Bell Tolls, or Why We Hope Steven Moffat’s DOCTOR WHO Is an Island
Is Sherlock sexist? Steven Moffat’s wanton women
"Moffservations”, or We Should Have Seen This Coming
Press Tour: Benedict Cumberbatch talks fans, ‘Sherlock’, kissing Moriarty (includes Moffat’s and Gatiss’s “no homo” attitude, describing Sherlock and Moriarty kissing as “wrong”)
'Sherlock’ Boss on 'Moving’ Holmes/Watson Reunion and 'Funnier’ Season 3 (Q&A) (insults female fanbase)
'Sherlock’ wrote a female character out of a classic story, and fans aren’t happy
Steven Moffat Defends Plot Hole Criticism
Steven Moffat, I’m Over Your Lady Issues
Steven Moffat - A Case For The Prosecution
Stop Calling Sherlock a Sociopath! Thanks, a Psychologist.
The Captain Kirk Problem: How Doctor Who Betrayed Matt Smith
The Central Problem With Steven Moffat’s Doctor Who
The Dangers of Mystical Pregnancy as Entertainment
'There is a clue everybody’s missed’: Sherlock writer Steven Moffat interviewed (asexuality is no fun quote)
Time War No More: The Degeneration of the Doctor
Why does the man behind ‘Doctor Who’ and ‘Sherlock’ still have a job?
The Doctor, The Widow, and the Wardrobe by feministwhoniverse
Asylum of the Daleks by feministwhoniverse
Asylum of the Daleks by holycheeseandcrackers
Aslyum of the Daleks by liz011
Dinosaurs on a Spaceship by feministwhoniverse
A Town Called Mercy by liz011
The Snowmen by lileclaire
The Snowmen by robotaverage
The Snowmen by dwfeministwatch
The Bells of St. John by lileclaire
The Bells of St. John by liz011
The Rings of Akhaten by lileclaire
Cold War and Hide by whovianfeminism
Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS by fandomsandfeminism
Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS by whovianfeminism
The Crimson Horror by The Mary Sue
The Name of the Doctor by lileclaire
The Name of the Doctor by whovianfeminism
The Day of the Doctor by claudiaboleyn
The Day of the Doctor by whovianfeminism
The Day of the Doctor by stfu-moffat
The Day of the Doctor by fandomsandfeminism
The Day of the Doctor by loremipsumfandom
The Time of the Doctor by patches365
The Time of the Doctor by claudiaboleyn
The Time of the Doctor (article)
The Time of the Doctor by liz011
The Time of the Doctor by ritchandspace
The Empty Hearse by claudiaboleyn
His Last Vow by claudiaboleyn
His Last Vow by latevictorian
His Last Vow: Part 1 Part 2