The Best Seasons of HBO’s The Wire (Ranked)
What can I say about HBO’s The Wire that hasn’t already been said? Arguably one of the greatest TV shows ever made, The Wire provided audiences with an in-depth look into the city of Baltimore through its various institutions, establishments, and citizens. On the surface, The Wire is a simple story about police officers vs drug dealers but on another level, it’s an analysis of how people come together and interact when placed in a densely populated area.
The Wire could’ve easily taken place in New York, Philly, or Chicago but given how familiarized the creators David Simon and Ed Burns were with Baltimore – one being a Baltimore Sun journalist, the other being a homicide detective – there was no better backdrop. What separated The Wire from other police procedurals like NYPD Blue and Law & Order was its serialized nature. Each episode wasn’t its own case but rather a chapter in the overarching story that is the war on drugs.
Throughout the series, we examined the great American city through the eyes of cops, lawyers, politicians, drug dealers, and even the working class as each season introduced us to a new institution and how it either combats or perpetuates criminality. I could literally go on about The Wire forever (just ask my friends and family). However, I’m here to talk about its five seasons and which had the greatest impact on me as well storytelling and entertainment overall.
Check out where I ranked each season of HBO’s The Wire
Number 5: Season 2 (AKA The One That Left Everyone Confused)
On the first watch, I hated everything about season two of The Wire, mostly due to my lingering questions. Why were we focusing on a bunch of stevedores? What’s with this mysterious Greek character? Is McNulty going to be on marine patrol the entire time? What does any of this have to do with the Barksdale organization? By the time season two had ended, it had garnered my attention but I was still happy to be moving on.
Many distinguish the second season of The Wire as the weakest, mostly because of its 180° shift in terms of focus and narrative. The Major Crimes Unit has been disbanded, McNulty is riding the boat, Stringer Bell is in charge of the Barksdale organization while Avon and Deangelo are locked up, and something fishy is going on at the docks. As unnecessary as many people view season two, in retrospect, it might just be the most significant. While I feel we could’ve done without the mystery of the dead container girls, it was important to know just where the drugs were coming from.
Even though the Avon and Deangelo storyline got pushed back to the second tier, it did provide us with one of the show’s most heartbreaking deaths. Season two might’ve felt like a chore to slog through but on second and third watch, it proves that it belongs right next to the others in regards to character development and storytelling. Also, it gave us the Omar Little vs Lawyer courtroom scene, which is a must-see for anybody that questions how the legal system truly operates.
Number 4: Season 5 (AKA The One That Ended It All)
The series finale of The Wire is probably my all-time favorite next to Breaking Bad. It showed that even though the show was coming to an end, the so-called Game never stops. Drug lord Marlo Stanfield was forced into retirement, McNulty and Freamon were fired from the police force, and Michael and Dukie fit into their roles as the new Omar and Bubbles respectively.
However, season five wasn’t about giving its characters the send off they deserved but rather showing us how the cycle always finds a way to reset itself. The war on drugs could never be won because no one really understands how it operates or where it originated. There will always be another drug lord, cop, and politician to ensure that the drug trade has its highs and lows.
But, onto the season as a whole. The Wire has received critical acclaim for its immense level of realism. That being said, imagine my disappointment when I discovered the primary storyline for the final season. It would revolve around McNulty creating a fake serial killer so that the mayor would grant funds to the police department that McNulty would then funnel into a terminated drug case.
Now, don’t get me wrong. Season five was highly entertaining and superbly written but its premise was just too far-fetched for me to get behind. Also the most action-packed, season five gave us a Marlo vs Omar showdown, which seemed promising only to end rather anticlimactically. I love the final season for wrapping up the series in the most creative way possible but unfortunately, its semi-unbelievable concept forces me to place it at the number four spot.
Number 3: Season 1 (AKA The One That Started It All)
I still remember the first time watching The Wire. I had just finished binge watching Breaking Bad and was in need of something equally as captivating. Searching through my HBO Go, I came across The Wire and the rest was history. Despite initially finding it boring and convoluted, I quickly became invested in its characters and overall narrative.
Similar to Game of Thrones, I didn’t know what was going on but I was eager to discover what was going to happen next. What really captured my attention was the amount of time that the show dedicated to developing both sides of the conflict. This might sound crazy but season one showed us that there are such things as bad cops and good criminals because, at the end of the day, we’re all people.
The Wire’s freshman season also presented us with so many memorable moments like Kima getting shot, the death of Wallace, and Deangelo’s change of heart. Season one also did a wonderful job at telling a self-contained story so if they weren’t renewed, the audience would be given with an appropriate amount of closure. The Wire provided the perfect template for how a premiere season should be developed with many shows following the formula to this day.
Number 2: Season 3 (AKA The One That Shocked And Awed)
If season two took a detour through the docks and lives of the working class in Baltimore then season three was a delightful return to form. We found ourselves back on the Westside corners and wow was it mesmerizing. Avon, Stringer, and the Barksdale organization were back in business and this time they were going up against newcomer Marlo Stanfield.
Season three gave us a turf war that proved no matter who wins, the city always loses. In addition to this, police Major Bunny Colvin conducts an experiment that attempts to regulate the drug trade rather than fight it – something quite similar to the dispute regarding prohibition. The Major Crimes unit was up and running in full force and Stringer Bell was the true target again.
Season three is great because it continued to give us more of what we loved while introducing a new institution in the form of local government. It presented us with the grim reality of politics and that everything, including the war on drugs, is fought with the goal of further an agenda.
Arguably the most daring of the five, season three was not afraid to make some risky decisions, killing off fan favorites and leaving viewers with a “what now” attitude. It was in season three where The Wire really found its footing and established itself as a mainstay in pop culture. I couldn’t get enough.
Number 1: Season 4 (AKA The One That Changed Everything)
Wow. Just wow. That was my reaction when finishing the fourth season of The Wire. I am going to go ahead and say that season four is the greatest season of television…Ever. After the events of the previous season, I was left wondering where the writers could possibly take the story next. Stringer Bell was dead, Avon was back in prison, McNulty had quit the Major Crimes unit to become a beat cop, and Marlo had become the new king of the streets.
Well, The Wire decided to pull another 180 and this time it was executed to glorious effect. We were introduced to the corner boys and their equally diverse and magnetic personalities. Namond, Randy, Michael, and Dukie – Season four showed us the Baltimore drug trade through their eyes and how it trickles down into the school system and their ability to receive an education. If season two showed audiences where the drugs came from, then season four revealed how the modern drug dealer is created.
It’s here where we discover where the Stringer Bells and Avon Barksdales of the world are made. There’s honestly just too much to talk about when it comes to season four. It’s easily the most tragic, enthralling, and introspective season of the series. When we weren’t watching the four main kids combat the struggles of life on the Westside, we got a glimpse of a happy McNulty, a ruthless and murderous Marlo Stanfield (Chris & Snoop = scariest henchmen ever), and how politicians are just as much of a problem as they are a possible solution.
I once spoke with a teacher who said she couldn’t finish the season because of how real and heartbreaking its depiction of education in a lower-class neighborhood was – yeah, it’s that serious. If you never watch another season of TV, watch season four of The Wire aka the one that changed everything.
There’s just so much more to talk about but feel I like I’ve overstayed my welcome. The Wire is a seminal piece of television that is being taught and studied almost a decade after its initial run. The definition of re-watchable, each time you enter the world of The Wire, there will always be something new to pick apart and analyze. If you haven’t yet seen The Wire, sorry for the spoilers but go watch it immediately. For everyone else, let me know how you felt about the popular HBO series in the comments below.