I'm rereading Midnight Sun and I think what gets me the most is how much Meyer doubled down on how not like other girls Bella is.
It happens explicitly in Edward's point of view where he's always narrating that she's not like other humans and makes these choices that no other person would make, even though often they seem like choices that many other people would make and find relatable. He'll say something like "wow when Bella talks to her peers she acts like someone who's keeping up a human front like me and my family does" and I just feel like who doesn't feel that way as a teenager? Is that not the most like other girls thing out there?
And then he has these paragraphs about how she does these acts of kindness that we don't get to hear about in the original book and he's so floored by the idea that she might be a generally kind and good person as though that's so rare refined in the world. There's no way there aren't other affectionate, compassionate, thoughtful, supportive, sympathetic, warm, caring, understanding, generous, tender, tolerant people at Forks High School.
I think it's even kind of shady of Meyer to use her mind reading protagonist to double down on the idea that every other person at the school is shallow and self-involved. If a person truly believes that other people genuinely have nothing else going on outside of thinking about boys and gossip and school dances and they have no interest in the psychology of the cheerleader, then that person probably isn't as deep as they think they are. As it is, characters like Jessica or Lauren are really only there as foils to show us how much better Bella is than everybody which is kind of stupid.
I wish Bella could be an imperfect character and Edward could be interested in her just because she has a certain je ne sais quoi or because they have things in common, they're in alignment.