Coral Island Rafael x Farmer
A/N: My husband on every run through I play. Well, not anymore because I wanted to see everyones cutscenes but he is THE OG. I love him. He's a giant teddy bear and I love him. I want to do more coral island so if anyone has any fic ideas for these characters let. As long as its NOT Ben or Mark 🤢
༺。° .ᘛ𓆩♡𓆪ᘚ. °。༻༺。° .ᘛ𓆩♡𓆪ᘚ. °。༻
The day began like any other. The island, once peaceful and thriving, now felt stuffy and reeked of the oil spill that now loomed an impending sense of dread at the possibility of evacuation. If things didn't change and soon, everyone would have no choice but to leave. Pufferfish was basically waiting them out and what could anyone really do but try and keep their businesses and homes afloat. Rumors were the only thing that seemed to keep people chatting and in a somewhat upbeat mood as the people tried to avoid talking about anything Pufferfish was planning on doing.
Rafael was not fond of gossip. Especially after hearing about his own brother’s involvement in one of the town's biggest news stories. He could only try and hide his discomfort at what had happened. What he never imagined his brother capable of, and worse the more he thought about it the more he wasn’t actually surprised by what happened. His brother never faced consequences even with what happened with Charles, people had quickly brushed over it, as if it was okay simply because it was Pablo. The rumors mostly consisted about the timing of everything, which he did not want to find out about in case… well, it was bad enough as is. Needless to say, it's not like he could avoid the news whenever Pablo had his friends over. Now, the town was buzzing with the news of a new arrival. Surya had arrived a year prior with similar fanfare but Ling and his family kept him pretty busy.
The new arrival was supposedly taking over that unreasonably large plot of farmland. The old farmers had had to move years prior due to old age and sickness. Apparently, the new farmer had come into some money and was coming back to fix up her grandparent’s farm. A daunting task to be sure, Rafael only wondered if they would be able to handle the amount of work. It was easy to let his mind wonder while he cleaned the moss and dirt off of the gravestones. He had gotten used to getting up early to make sure every space was respectable. Plus, it was quiet and relaxing. It felt good to be doing something to give back. It didnt take too long either, you could just try and focus on your book. Unfortunately, the quiet made any visitors startle you.
“Hi! Nice to meet you. I’m Ren. Sorry to bother you, I’m just trying to get to know some of my new neighbors.”
Rafael feels his cheeks flush and his words, aside from his initial shock, could barely be described as audible. “Oh! Hi, there…My name is Rafael” His mind was blank, he tried to force himself to say something, anything else, “Uhmmm. I’m one of the blacksmiths here in Starlet Town.”
“Oh, that's nice! I guess we’ll be seeing a lot of each other then. I’m going to need some help with all of these tools. They’ll do their job but…well let’s say they’ve seen better days.” She smiled brightly at him. Her eyes resembled a pride he only saw when his parents would talk to Pablo.
Rafael could only nod at this girl who seemed to lack any of the shyness that plagued every fiber of his being, “Uh my brother and I can help. We would just need some supplies. Oh! Well– we also sell some but it can be easier to mine them.”
“That makes sense. I may just buy some to at least get a head start. If I’m going to clear out that mess of a farm I’ll need to have better tools, I don’t want to waste too much time.”
“I can show you where the shop is…if you like that is. Uhm, I usually work more in the afternoon.”
“I don’t want to disturb you. You seemed to be taking a well deserved break. I’ve been walking around and I saw you cleaning some of the headstones. Do you do that often?”
Rafael was surprised she didn’t seem weirded out by that, even his own brother would tease him about it. Too spooky to be so consistently hanging around the dead. He wasn’t sure how to respond, “Yeah, I know it may seem weird but I find it relaxing.”
Rafael found that he was cursing at himself. He was probably going to scare her off too, “It’s not weird. It probably needs to be done anyway. You’re just helping out. I like that.”
His words come out a jumbled mess, “Uhm. Well, I am finished…I don’t mind showing you the blacksmith shop. If…you want?”
Rafael can only nod and hope his cheeks don’t feel as red as they feel to him. They walk in a comfortable silence until they arrive at the shop. He’s about to offer to look at any tools she has in her bag. But Rafael is almost immediately interrupted by the person who seems to magnetize almost anyone he decides to befriend.
“Hey Raf! You’re back early!” He stops at the sight of their new guest. “You must be Ren. Damn I wasn’t expecting you to look like this. You’re surprisingly cute!”
Rafael can only look down, fully expecting to hear Ren begin to laugh or giggle at his obvious flirting. He wasn’t sure why it bothered him that Ren was about to start ignoring him. He should be used to this, everyone eventually ignored him when Pablo was around. How could they help it? He had always had an energy that drew people to him. Had he looked up he may have seen a grimace flashing across Ren’s face.
“How often does that line work out for you?”
Pablo could only laugh, “You’d be surprised. How can I help you today, beautiful?”
“Actually Rafael was showing me the shop. I was just trying to meet all of the people I’ll be working with.”
“That’s great! So I can expect to see you around more?”
“We’ll see.” Rafael could only look between the two. Internally shocked at the indifference Ren had with his brother. Not that it seemed to bother Pablo. Who only seemed to see it as a challenge. Someone new to befriend. She turned back to Rafael and smiled, “I should be heading out but thanks again for showing me around! I’ll see you later. See you, Pablo! Nice meeting you both.”
The door had barely closed before Pablo began talking about how she was going to change things up around here. Rafael could only pinch the bridge of his nose. “I can’t believe you said that.”
“Eh? What, you’re telling me you expected someone who looks like that to be the new farmer? And I was being honest. She is cute.”
“We should have her over for dinner sometime.”
“Maybe she’d have fun at the tavern!” Rafael could only sigh at his brother’s ramblings. There wasn’t anything else he could say anyway. He was probably right, it would only be a matter of time before Ren decided to give him a chance and decided he was the better of the two.
Ren had been making quick work at getting the supplies she needed to upgrade most of her tools. Rafael tried not to think too much about how he wished he would upgrade her tools. She was often busy most days, taking Ling's boat out further and further into the ocean, sometimes mining the entirety of the day. Some days Rafael would see her running around different parts of town trying to fish or catch some bugs to help Scott and MIllie with the museum. He was surprised no one had asked if she was doing okay, or if she had been resting enough. Then again, maybe someone else had, it's not like he talked to enough people to know. All he knew is what she told him whenever she dropped off or picked something new up.
It was a windy day when he saw Pablo and a group of people gathering around the mayor. He was worried Pufferfish announced something else so he rushed over and stood in the back. Ren came in right as Mayor Connor started speaking. She touched his arm as she came up next to him, a gesture she did to try and warn him she was not trying to sneak up on him like that first day in the cemetery. Rafael tried to stop the fluttering churning in his stomach every time she did that, he almost missed it whenever she didn't approach him that way. He never thought of himself as being a physical person until he started craving such a simple gesture.
“Is it okay if I stand next to you?”
Rafael could only nod. Ren smiled at him. It had become a habit to be on the lookout for her. At first it had become a habit to wait for her to come in for new materials or upgrades for her tools. When she didn’t come in or her tools were being worked on Rafael found himself lingering by the graveyard a little long or hanging out by the taco truck in hopes of seeing her. He never seemed to figure out that she could have made it to the beach much quicker through the southern part of her farm, or how she always seemed to walk by the taco truck to get some lunch whenever he was on breaks most days. Two people completely oblivious at their convenient “chance” encounters. The days he didn’t see her seemed to drag, and it subconsciously soured his mood, often not recognizing he was missing someone who seemed to be the only person who saw him at all.
Not to say that didn’t always come with drawbacks. The muscles in Ren's jaw ticked as Connor referred to Rafael as Pablo’s brother and then continued to praise Pablo for cleaning the cemetery so regularly. She seethed over the inability to actually give credit to the actual Sanchez brother early at work every morning, was it so hard to remember his name. The words 'Pablo's brother’ would ruminate in her head the rest of the day.
“Since when does Pablo ever get up early enough to do that?” She muttered under her breath.
Rafael could only shrug. It was probably an honest mistake but better than everyone staring at him. He could see her roll her eyes when Pablo started organizing a day for the community to do the cemetery as an event.
“It's fine, Ren.” Rafael whispered, but she could only offer a small smile before leaving halfway through Pablo’s speech.
“Sure, Rafael.” Her wistful expression made him want to yank her back and explain that he really was fine and that he was sorry for worrying about her. Instead, he could only stare at her figure retreating back up the stairs and into the woods. It was tempting to go after her and explain that it's always been like this. He didn’t care for attention, or recognition really. That’s not why he did any of the things he did. It was enough to know that at least one person could see his efforts, especially one he considered a good friend. But if he explained any of it, he knew deep down that she would tell him that he shouldn’t let people walk over him. Frankly, Rafael was not ready to hear that. Not quite ready to open old wounds that had long been ignored by everyone including himself.
Pablo shook Rafael out of his thoughts.
“Hey bro, where did Ren go? I’m kinda surprised she didn’t hang around the whole time.”
“Uhm, I think she was busy.”
“Makes sense, “ Pablo smiled brightly as if he saw nothing out of the ordinary, which if Rafael thought about, it really wasn’t. It’s always like this. His brother was like the sun people seemed to be drawn to. Being around him seemed to make everyone happier, more at ease. “Man, I can’t believe the mayor gave us a shout out.”
‘You’ a shout out, more like. Rafael thought to himself, “Yeah well about the cleani–”
“Oh yeah, good idea right?”
“Now you won’t have to worry about doing it so often!”
He enjoyed the routine of it, but how could he protest? His older brother seemed so eager to take on a new task for the island. “Sure…but Pablo I don't mind–”
“Don’t worry about it! Now you’ll have more time to relax.” Rafael gave up. The group cleaning wouldn’t last long. As soon as his brother found something else to do he would forget about this project and Rafael could continue doing whatever he liked. With a stiff smile he followed behind his brother as he greeted the other islanders that had questions about what the new project would entail.
A few days would pass before Rafael would get a letter from Millie apologizing for the mayor’s slip-up during the town meeting. Rafael could only stare at the letter. He knew that somehow Ren had something to do with this. He smiled down at the letter, and he found himself smiling the rest of the day. Someone had gone out of his way for him. Seen him…What was he supposed to do with that? It seemed like completely new territory. No. It was definitely new territory. Unfortunately, all he could manage the courage for was to ask her about how her day was when he saw her. She always lit up when she talked about the improvements she's been making to her farm and even more so when she discovered more things in the mines. He tried to not look too worried about that whenever she talked about it. Even he and Pablo didn't go too far down there to get supplies. If something happened to her… the only times Ren seemed to go quiet was when he asked about the times she went diving, she seemed to get a faraway look in her. Still that wasn’t too surprising. With the oil spill it must not be a pretty sight down there. Maybe he could go with her sometime.
Time kept going, Ren had only been there one half of the year and her efforts had already gotten their small island at Rank C. She was never around when they got those updates from the Mayor, but the only thing that had changed was her moving into the island. It was easy to see why the island seemed to be changing for the better. She didn’t seem to like talking about it. Just showed up to the many volunteer events. Rafael could understand why, he definitely avoided the attention himself when she had brought it up at the last town meeting she did attend. But she wasn’t like him. She was friendly with everyone on the island, he heard plenty from the twins and even Valentina whenever he saw her. She was always helping someone out. It was ironic he supposed how the two of them both seemed to be wanting the other out in the spotlight more than either of them wanted.
The beach cleanup was too crowded, Rafael barely got a word in with her. He could only stare as she partook in all of the competitions around the shore. Everyone cheered when she beat Sunny in the swimming contest, he's gone undefeated for years. He tried not to be too obvious at the fact that he kept searching for her. He tried to see her again when she was hanging out with Alice, but she seemed to disappear after talking to Ling about something. He could only hope she wasn’t going to keep working, those dives had to be exhausting her.
She hated how busy she was. Every week it seemed to be an endless repeat of diving, mining, diving, mining. Not to mention, fishing and catching whenever you could to help the museum. All she wanted was one day to sleep in. Well, Ren supposed technically she could, but after Karen started campaigning for Mayor all she could think about was proving that Coral Island didn’t need any more corporate involvement. She always gave an extra thanks to the Goddess of Flowers for helping run that ugly building with vines. While it didn’t make them leave yet, it was at least a bit comical to see them so frustrated with everything going on.
With the town at Rank B, there wasn’t much to do but wait for winter so you could grow the last of the goddess required for her altars. Ren tried to hide her disappointment with her only helping because of the offerings being made. But it was frustrating. Everything seemed to depend on her work. Whatever, she thought, she was going to finish the last few floors in the mine and then she would go to the blacksmiths to upgrade the last of her tools. It would give her a break for the next few days. And besides, it's been almost two months since she got to really talk to Rafael aside from a passing greeting in the mornings. Everyday had her wondering how his ironeye hammer was going. She even tried to see if she could find any of that Tevandium in the mines but she never saw anything out of the ordinary there. Ren can only hope he hadn’t been swindled by whatever explorer had come through. It sounded almost too good to be true, too convenient. But who was she to discourage him, he seemed to get enough of that from others.
She had found a crumpled letter just barely hidden in the rocks by the small waterfall near the caves. Ren couldn't help it. She opened it expecting to see more pufferfish trash, it could probably still be recycled she figured or maybe another shopping list that could help her get some surprise gifts for her neighbors… but Rafael's name froze her in her tracks. She should have crumpled it back up and thrown it away but hard as she tried she couldn’t peel her eyes away. It was from his parents, apologizing for sending him Pablo's favorite food for his birthday. Ren knew he had liked the onyx gemstones you dug up, he had made a comment on them when you had given him ores to break open from the mines. What she hadn’t known was that they were his favorites. But then again, his parents didn’t seem to be the most reliable source of information. When Ren finally did get home she burned the page, he didn’t need to know she knew about it. And Rafael must have been really upset if he threw it into the water instead of a trashcan. He was always picking up things he saw on the ground, silently keeping their little island clean the best he could.
Of course, this was after that town meeting. And it just made Ren go out of her way just a little more. He should know at least one person likes him. Enjoys his company. And remembers what he likes. At least, she thought so, He had been kind enough to share an easy recipe on the island before you had even really become friends, it was something you kept in mind whenever you would bring him some of the extra food you happened to not so accidentally make. His reaction was always priceless, like he couldn’t believe you still thought of him.
As with most things that led to her showing up, Ren had been lucky. On one of the rare occasions she’d gone to the blacksmith and he wasn’t there, Pablo had helped her break some ores that had luckily turned up one of the deepest and more beautiful looking onyx gemstones she had ever seen. The color...it was a deep black but looked as if purple was trying to break through. Like a beautiful root of an old tree. Whenever she figured out how to dress it up she would give it to him.
Unfortunately the caves took longer than expected. Ren had ran out of dynamite one the last three floors. Their shop would be closed soon. But first, and foremost, Ren felt grimy. One quick glance at the clock in her home and sigh of relief followed. She had an hour and a half before they closed for the day. Always the more thankful for the goddess blessing to somehow be able to teleport home by only needing to touch the stone pillars. Ren always made sure no one was around, it was not something she had really wanted to explain. There had already been one or two people asking why she was covered in pink petals. It had been a quick trip from the mines back home and she was ready for as long of a shower as time allowed.
She decides to quickly change into one of her lighter ripped jeans and throw on a light sweatshirt before throwing your hair up and rushing to the blacksmiths. Eight minutes to spare. Most days Ren would hate nothing more than to come somewhere right as they were closing up shop, she hopes dropping off some tools wouldn't be too big of an issue. You try not to look too excited when you see Rafael and Pablo head in your direction.
Rafael wonders if he will ever be able to figure out why Ren seemed so excited just saying hello to him. It was as if sunshine followed her wherever she went. It immediately helps ease the churning in his stomach at the thought of having to go out tonight.
“Hey Ren! We were just about to head to Fishensips. Come, join us!”
The confusion on her face is evident as she fishes out a phone to check something, “Oh my god! I totally misread the time before coming here, didn't I? I don’t want to interrupt, I thought I still had another eight minutes before closing. How did I misread the time that badly?? I'm so sorry, I didn’t want to interrupt. You guys have fun!”
“If you need to drop off tools you can just leave them by the front, I’ll remember they’re yours. Promise.” Pablo smiles at her and she looks away as she smiles. Rafael hates it. He absolutely hates it. Rafael hates how he isn't even sure if Pablo is just flirting like he always does or if he could possibly be serious about her. And worse? Rafael isn't if he hates it because he himself has some conflicted feelings about her or if he hates it on her behalf. What if she ends up hurt?
“Are you both sure?” And there it is again. The way she makes sure both brothers have a say. Makes sure one isn’t overlooked. Like his opinions might actually matter.
“It’s fine.” You hate how it sounds. Like he wouldn’t love her company to help fill the inevitable awkwardness when people come and say hello to Pablo, “if you want, of course. You’re probably tired too.”
“Awe come on, Ren. Please.” Pablo asks and Rafael has to try to not feel too bothered by him already getting out of hanging out with just him. Unfortunately, or fortunately he is more glad when Ren nods and follows you out. He couldn't help it, she was always welcome company.
The walk to the tavern is mostly Pablo answering Ren's questions, regardless of how much she asks the both of the brothers different kinds of questions about work or life Pablo is the one answering. Pablo talks, he’s always been the social one. So Rafael lets him, only nodding along. Ren smiles politely at the conversation and answers back if she can get a word in.
The tavern is painfully and unsurprisingly full. Pablo is instantly brought into a group of people playing pool. He suddenly feels sick. There's too many people here. Ren waves at everyone but hangs back with the younger of the two brothers. Pablo starts talking to Yuri and Rafael feels only a slight sense of relief that Pablo isn’t saying anything like that to Ren. There's a joke about Pablo not wanting him to know something but any mumbling about how it doesn’t even matter is also cut off from his lips. Pablo is already immersed in a new game.
“I know this place is busy, but man it's busy.” Ren nudges him. Deep down Rafael knows she probably feels bad for him and usually he would want to appreciate it. But right now…Rafael only feels like a joke. He knew his brother was popular, he knew hoping to have some one on one time with his only real family was a stretch. But why even ask to come out if he was only planning on ignoring him? Even if no one noticed, to be publicly ignored by your brother didn’t feel good. And there was just so. many. people…
He couldnt help it. The pity from Ren. He never wanted her to ignore him more, and Rafael has to cut her off before she can say anything else, “I think the pool game between me and Pablo is off. I think I’ll go home… I hope the tv show is still on.”
“Oh Rafael…” He hears her say sadly but for now, he couldn’t be in there any longer. He didn’t look back as he walked out, desperate for some fresh air. Hopefully the night air would help him be able to breathe again. It doesn’t. He had only barely made it out of the door before doubling over, he placed his hands on your knees to try and take some slower, deeper breaths. After four deep inhales he can feel the breathing settle enough to force himself to keep walking. He just needed some rest...probably. His brain only registers the hurried footsteps when the touch on his arm startles him out of the fog he seemed perpetually stuck in. Its a reflex that his hand arm yanks free immediately, followed by an even more immediate regret.
“Sorry…Didn’t–mean to– scare you….”
“Ren?? What– what are you doing here?” He could hear her try to catch her breath, very clearly having run from the tavern. When Rafael looks around he notices how he was about to pass the lab. Even if it's only a ten minute or so slow walk, she had to have raced here.
“Sorry it took so long, Noah asked if everything was okay when you left. He mentioned you, him and Alice like to keep to yourselves when you were younger. I just told him you wanted to catch a show.” Ah yes, their little band of misfits. Rafael eyes are glued to the floor, he can’t think of anything to say, anything to do. He was still embarrassed that he had just left her there alone. What if something happened to her. He would never forgive himself. He opens his mouth to mumble some kind of apology but she beats him to it.
“So… what show are we watching?”
Immediately his head snaps to face her, a grin growing on her face. “Wh-what?”
“I mean, only if you want company. So, maybe…you can show me an earlier episode. Just so I can catch up?”
“You would do that?” For me? He doesnt say the second part. It was too good to be true. It won’t compute in his brain. She left all those people who had seemed eager she had shown up to hang out…with him?
“Uh yeah? How many episodes am I behind, am I going to have to binge it? Is there more than one season? Ooh! Should I tell you a review per episode or do you want to binge some of the episodes with me. Sometimes I don’t get back until late. Or you can catch me up on a few episodes and then I can watch the rest on my own…”
“NO!” His voice comes out louder than you had ever heard, faster. Immediately he needs to explain himself as a flash of hurt passes her face. He wouldn’t be able to handle her backing out now, “I mean no, I would like to watch them with you…if that's okay. If you even want to watch. Its kind of a series of documentaries about weird or creepy things that have happened in history.”
“Oh yeah! You mentioned you like to read horror stories, so that makes sense.” Rafael tries to find a way to stop his heart from swelling to no avail, it feels like it could burst at any moment. To have someone remember such a small detail, a throwaway comment. “Does it have anything about witches and that kind of historical stuff? I love watching that.”
“Actually, yes. Its one of the first few episodes. I’m sure I can find where to stream it–”
“Don’t worry about that. I had Luke make it so I could watch anything I want. It’s pretty great. Would you be okay doing that at my house? I know its out of the way but I’ll get the snacks and–”
“No, that actually sounds great, I won’t feel bad about saying no to Pablo’s social events that way.” He tries to ignore the scratching comment about Luke in his brain.
“Great! Come on, we'll watch one or two tonight. I dropped off my tools today so I'm free for a little while anyway. You can borrow my horse for the ride back, I can get her in the morning.”
They had already started the small trek to her farm when she suggests this. Rafael following behind her and he allows himself to wonder for a split second if she thinks she’s actually inconveniencing him. “I’ll be fine. I like walking at night, you don’t have to worry about me.”
“Someone has to, Rafael.”