Okay that’s Inferno Wrapped up.
Here’s my review in brief.
Unlike the prior crossover arcs this felt like a complete story, which is a good. It also kept me engaged right up to the final issue.
Likewise I enjoyed it all with one exception.
In one issue it takes all the agency out of Scott and Maddie’s life and and a seems to just exist so Scott doesn’t have to hate himself for everything he’s done to Maddie and the people around him. It seems to exist just so they can say “oh Scott’s actually a good eveything morally grey and dubious he’s ever done is actually all down to Mister Sinister messing with his Brian as a kid.” And frankly I can’t imagine a more boring plot twist right at the end of an X-Men story that’s the first grip me to this extent since some of the classic New Mutant works, Dark Phoenix and the Crooked World Saga over in Captain Britain. Frankly if Inferno was one issue shorter if X-Factor #39 didn’t exist I could pass most of its flaws not to mention if it didn’t exist it would give more opportunity for everyone to angst a lot and damage everyone’s relationships with each other.
I am happy Beast is back being Blue and Furry again which happened right at the start. I feel like Warren is finally coming into his own for the first time since he was created. Iceman is still relatively nothing character who it’s clear the author is struggling to find a role for now he’s no longer the youngest member of the team. Jean’s I’m not sure what’s going on with Jean I feel they are setting something up with her but she had a nice reunion with Storm as well as a very… well intimate encounter with Psylock. Logan is still dull as always and they finally did something mildly interesting with Alex.
I’m a bit worried about Magik as she gone back to being a 9 year old when I read this I assumed it would be brief say 30 issues at most? But judging by what @daughterofheartshaven has said it’s going to hang around for a lot longer than that? Which seems a very strange decision as after Dani Magik was the most compelling of the New Mutants.
Speaking Dani I feel she’s been a bit to out of focus recently I feel the author has kind of lost track of what she wants to do with her which is really really disappointing and hope this gets resolved soon with Dani back in the limelight.
With the X-Men I have to say I really like Betsy new costume and I dislike that they are setting up conflict between Dazzler and Rogue over Longshot which feels forced as they had just made up about them trying to kill each other and where offering to dance with each other. I don’t have much more to say.
My thoughts of Maddie becoming the Goblyn Queen have already been described and can be best summed up as “poor Maddie” but Scott really did drive her to suicide didn’t he? Murder Suicide yes but suicide nonetheless. I will greatly miss her presence in these tales.
I do not like how Lorna has been treated at all. This is the second time she’s been possessed and she’s only been in two arcs significantly and in both of them she’s spent the majority of the possessed! I have ranted about this elsewhere however.
In enjoyed the X-Terminator’s mini but beyond that I have little to say. It seems they are setting them to join the New Mutants? Or at the least hang around with them for a while? I’m not sure?
Regrading the Excalibur crossover I would have liked Rachel to play a bigger role. I love her she’s amazing and I was hoping for her to reunite with her family properly. It was however nice seeing the Doctor Who references. And I want Meggan to have a full scale therapy session. I felt like in many ways it was a kind of synthesis of the whole Inferno Arc with Meggan as a Maddie stand in and Brian as a Scott. Except Brian doesn’t get to wash his hands of the guilt, as Nightcrawler reminds us, and Meggan is able to come back from being the being the Goblyn Princess. It felt like the got caught in some kind of mirror, meta tale it’s hard to describe. But it with the cinema motif and Meggan chameleoning Maddie due to her powers being beyond her control it felt like they were in a kind of story book version of Inferno. No not quite but… I don’t know. Well I do but I’m not good enough with words and writing to explain.
But overall I did enjoy it with the exception of X-Factor #39. Which I feel almost ruins the whole thing.