Kate picked up her drink, swirling the contents around inside the glass as she held it up to the candlelight.
“Well?” an insistent voice asked her. “Aren’t you going to answer me?”
She dragged her eyes from the pink fizzing liquid to the man sitting across from her. His face danced in shadow and light as the candle flickered on the table between them. His eyes looked glassy and unreal to her, making her slightly uneasy as he stared.
“I don’t know, Alfred,” she shrugged, lifting the glass to her lips. She paused before drinking, sighed, and repeated, “I just don’t know.” Then she tilted her head back, downing the rest of her drink in one long swig.
Placing the glass back on the table, she looked up at him once more, then quickly away again. She immediately regretted the empty glass, wishing for some kind of distraction from his steady gaze. Scanning the restaurant, she searched for their waiter, but couldn’t seem to spot him through the dimly lit crowd of tables and patrons. She saw a busboy clearing a nearby table, and considered asking him to bring her another drink, but then thought better of it.
Alfred’s voice brought her attention back to their table. “I can’t believe that’s all you have to say to me.”
She shifted uncomfortably in her seat. Her stomach tightened, her mind skimming over thoughts ridden with guilt and shame, unwilling to settle on any of them. She sifted down through layers of self-loathing and caught on a spark of annoyance. Why couldn’t he just accept it? She immediately latched on to this feeling as her one saving grace, fanning the spark into a flame.
“What do you want me to say, Al?” she demanded through pursed lips. Crossing her arms, she sat up a little straighter, facing him head on this time as she met his gaze.
She watched a crease appear between his eyebrows, his jaw clench before he opened his mouth to snap at her, “I don’t know, Katie. How about the truth, for once?”
She knew she was in for a fight now, and that it was her own fault, but she didn’t even mind. This, she could handle. His anger she could deal with. She could return fire for fire. But that melancholy face he had worn all evening, his slow-soft voice edged with a hint of pleading, the hollow look in his eyes as he searched for an explanation that she couldn’t give him—this was what she couldn’t take. He was going to crush her under the weight of his own suffering. Suffering she knew she had inflicted.
Selfishly, she wished this conversation was over, wished she was back at her own apartment and that it was tomorrow already so she could put this all behind her. But she was still here, in this restaurant that she hadn’t even chosen, sitting across from the man that had also been chosen for her. The man she was now choosing to leave.
“Fine,” she said, placing her palms flat on the table in front of her and leaning in. “You want honesty? Fine. I’ll give you honesty.”
But something in his look made her pause. His face still wore a mask of anger, but somewhere behind his eyes, she saw a flicker of fear, there and then gone. She felt the guilt swell again, momentarily quelling the fire within her. She took a breath.
“Fine,” she repeated, but softly this time. “The truth is,” she began, her eyes locked on his now, unable to look away. “The truth is, we have been growing apart for some time now.” Here he opened his mouth, but she cut him off before he could argue. “You know it and I know it,” she said firmly.
His mouth closed, his jaw working as though he were chewing on something, but he said nothing.
She went on, “Maybe we were never…” her voice trailed as she saw something painful flare in his eyes. But she forced herself to finish her sentence. “Maybe we were never really in love at all,” she said in a small voice.
“I loved you!” he burst out, as though he were swearing at her. Then he snapped his mouth shut, turning his face away.
Kate felt her eyes fill with hot tears, but she rapidly blinked them away, wrapping her arms around her middle.
Alfred turned back to her. Kate felt her stomach drop like a stone into a pond, a cold feeling of dread reverberating through her at the look in his eye.
“Why don’t you just say what you really mean, Kate?” he asked after a moment’s pause. His voice was strangely quiet. If she wasn’t listening so hard, she might not be able to hear him over the murmur of conversation around them.
“What do you mean?” she tried to ask, but her throat felt suddenly dry and the words came out a whisper. She swallowed, wet her lips, and tried again. “What do you mean?”
He blinked slowly, his eyes closing for just a second too long.
“You never really loved me,” he said finally, his voice heavy.
She opened her mouth. She wanted to say, ‘That’s not true.’ She wanted to tell him she did love him, that she had always loved him, that things had just changed between them. But the words wouldn’t come out. Somehow, sitting across from him in the semi-darkness, his eyes watching her with a look both full and empty, she couldn’t bring herself to say those things to him. She couldn’t bring herself to lie.
It wasn’t until that moment that she realized it really was a lie. Maybe she had always known. Maybe it was just then that she finally let herself accept the truth.
She realized her mouth was still open. She closed it, looked away, then back at Alfred again. The silence stretched between them. Finally, she said the only thing she could think to say to him.
“I’m sorry,” she murmured, her eyes meeting his. She watched his expression as it shifted through emotions. On his face, she read anger, grief, pain—even a kind of acceptance, as though he had known all along.
Then his eyes hardened. Suddenly he was a stranger to her, seeming a million miles away although sitting so close she could reach out and touch him. But she didn’t touch him. Instead, she spoke. “I’m sorry,” she repeated, her voice a whisper now.
His eyes slid away from her. He reached into his back pocket, pulled out his wallet and began thumbing through it.
“What are you doing?” she asked, though she already knew.
He didn’t bother to answer, just laid a few bills on the table and stood up, his chair scraping against the floor.
“Wait,” she said, putting her hand out.
He paused and looked at her then. She didn’t know what to say. Didn’t know how to make things better, for him or herself. She just knew she didn’t want to leave things like this.
“Well?” he asked when she didn’t speak.
Kate opened her mouth, her palm held upwards, floating in the air between them as though disconnected from her own body. Still, she didn’t speak.
He shook his head, shrugging on his coat. “Goodbye, Kate.”
Kate stood up then, watching his back as he retreated. Watching him walk through the door. He didn’t look back.
Slowly, she sank back into her seat.
Kate watched the candle as it flickered in the small jar on the center of the table. She didn’t know how long she had been sitting there, staring at the dancing flame, when she heard a voice beside her. “Ma’am?”
She looked up. It was the waiter. “Can I bring you anything else, ma’am?” he asked politely, eyes flitting to the stack of bills laying on the tablecloth.
She sat up straight, hands swiping at her face as though wiping away invisible tears. “No,” she said, “thank you. We’re done here.” Then she stood, picked up her coat from the back of her chair and slid her arms into the sleeves.
“We’re done,” she repeated to the waiter, thanking him with a weak smile.
Then she walked to the door, pausing to look back at the table where the busboy was already busy clearing their dishes.
Kate took a deep breath, then turned away. Stepping out into the cold night air, she somehow felt as though she was crossing the threshold from her past into her future life. Whether good or bad, she thought, at least now it was of her own choosing. And she turned her face to the sky and smiled.