Ash and Shorter in Angel Eyes
So, I just finished my read through of Banana Fish. Yes, I cried my eyes out. I then finally got around to reading Angel Eyes all the way through for the first time, and man, what an awesome side story. There’s so much to talk about from it, and so much to explore, but there’s something really specific I noticed, which I think ties into my other post about other people’s perceptions of Ash, and which also relates to the last conversation we see between Ash and Blanca.
In the first three quarters of Angel Eyes, Ash comes across as very cold, as very unfeeling, and even frightening. Even Shorter at one point is so scared of Ash that he doesn’t want anything to do with him. Of course, by the end of the story, we realize his cold demeanor was, again, a total front. A wall put up to keep people away from him, including Shorter, because he seriously doesn’t know who he can trust. He’s wary of Shorter precisely because Shorter’s being nice to him, and nobody’s ever been nice to Ash for no reason. Ash is only going by his experiences in life to inform his decisions. His experiences tell him that anybody being nice to him is doing it because they want something from him. This, coupled with Frankie essentially submitting to Shorter’s demand that he stop harassing Ash at the beginning, and Ash’s having already pegged Frankie as an assassin, naturally makes Ash even more suspicious of Shorter. Eventually of course he realizes, after talking to Shorter and asking him if Frankie is part of his crew, that that’s not the case. But he still doesn’t trust Shorter. He still keeps him at a long distance and doesn’t tell him anything about himself. Well, why would he? He’s just met him a week ago and Ash’s life experiences tell him he can’t trust anybody.
Well, the thing I wanted to really talk about here, and I think this is a prime example of how it is that Ash was never this ruthless, cold-hearted killer, is the moment directly following the fight between Ash and Frankie, where Ash very nearly kills him. He only doesn’t because Shorter shouts at him as he’s charging Frankie with the pool cue and distracts him enough with that that Ash messes up his aim. Shorter runs after Ash afterward to thank him for “going easy” on Frankie, and we see Ash start to laugh, seeming almost demonic in his reaction as he explains to Shorter that he didn’t “go easy” on Frankie. He meant to kill him. Of course, when we later realize that Ash knew Frankie meant to kill him, his own intent to kill makes more sense. But there’s a very important bit of dialog between Ash and Shorter afterward, which speaks volumes about who Ash really is inside.
He thanks Shorter, and then starts saying “So that’s it. Deflect it slightly at the last second. I didn’t DECIDE to go easy on him. But now I finally know how.” He says I “finally” know how.
Now lets take this back for a moment to Ash’s last conversation with Blanca in the park, when they start talking about how Blanca never taught Ash how to go easy on an enemy. He says to Blanca “”Never let your enemy escape alive.” You’re the one who taught me that. I never learned how to go easy on someone I’m fighting.” And then Blanca replies, while smiling fondly, “That’s because I was told there was no need to teach you that.”.
These two pieces of conversation taken together tell us everything about Ash, and his attitude towards the idea of having to kill, even for reasons as justifiable as self-defense.
Blanca taught Ash how to kill with the efficiency of a professional hit man. He taught him how to react and kill in the quickest, easiest and most efficient way possible. He never taught him how to hold back once he was in the midst of a fight. Once he got going, he would become a killing machine, so to speak. And we see this from Ash throughout the series. Once he starts fighting someone with the intention to kill them, he goes through with it with frightening precision and effectiveness. Blanca never taught Ash how to simply incapacitate an opponent using a deadly weapon, he never taught Ash how to only maim, instead of kill. All of his lessons were geared towards showing Ash how to take the life of an enemy, nothing more, nothing less. Dino didn’t want Ash to carry out threats or warnings. He wanted him as a hit man. But Blanca’s words to Ash, that he was told he never needed to teach Ash how to go easy on an enemy, tells us that someone, Dino most likely, told Blanca that Ash was already too soft-hearted and too merciful, and that he shouldn’t bother with teaching Ash anything but how to kill. Dino wanted to use Ash as a weapon, to carry out hits for him. He didn’t have any use for Ash’s own ambivalent feelings about killing. He didn’t care how Ash felt. He needed to mold him into the most effective weapon he could. We see Dino remind Ash, early on in the series, and in a mocking way, about how Ash always used to cry over every job Dino made him do. Ash never wanted to kill anyone, and it was an upsetting enough experience for him that it used to reduce him to tears. He didn’t want to do it, but Dino forced him into it, like he forced him into prostitution.
But let’s go back to what Ash says to Shorter. He says “But now I FINALLY know how.” What this tells us about Ash is that he WANTED to know how to pull back while fighting someone so that he didn’t kill them. He wanted to know how he could stop himself from always taking someone’s life if he happened to get into a physical altercation with them. He’s happy that he’s learned how to pull back in just this one way. He’s been trained only to know how to kill, but Ash hates killing. He only does it because he has to. And we know Ash never would have even tried to kill Frankie if Frankie hadn’t first tried to kill him. Even later on, Ash let’s Frankie go, when he could have killed him. Even here, we see Ash show mercy, despite this asshole and his crew just trying to murder him. It’s the same as Ash only seducing Ricardo as a means of getting Frankie to make a move and show his hand. Because Ricardo made clear his own intention to try and rape Ash. So Ash uses Ricardo’s intention to his own benefit in forcing Frankie’s hand and to find out who sent him to kill him. I don’t think Ash ever intended to “set Ricardo on Frankie and let him do his dirty work for him”, like Shorter accuses Ash of. Ash saw Frankie beat Ricardo’s ass earlier, when they got into a fight over him, so he knows Ricardo can’t take out Frankie. Ash wouldn’t ever send someone to do a job for him like that anyway, as we see in the main story line of Banana Fish. He takes care of his own business when someone’s after him specifically. He never sends his own boys to do it for him. He acts dismissive of Shorter’s accusation because, again, he’s putting up a front of cold-hearted detachment because that’s the only way he knows how to protect himself. By showing no emotion. Even Shorter basically tells him to utilize a form of this earlier in the story, when he advises Ash to let himself be raped if he gets caught, and to be as quiet and passive as possible. Ash already knows those sorts of tactics, obviously. By this point in his life though, he’s been raped so many times, he’s got more sophisticated means of getting through it. So he uses Ricardo as a mean of sussing out who it is that’s gunning for him on the outside. He’s using sex as a weapon, because it’s one of the few ways he has of defending himself. I think Ash starts crying and is so upset when Shorter says if he keeps manipulating people like that, he’ll be just like the assholes who try to hurt him, because that was never Ash’s intention. He was just trying to protect himself. He never wanted to control anybody, or hurt them, or dominate them. He only uses tactics like manipulation to try and keep himself from getting more hurt. He starts shaking and crying and gets so upset, because the last thing he wants is to be like the people who hurt him, and because he never did the things he did for the same reasons. It hurts him badly that Shorter thinks he could be like them at all. That he could be like that, or have that kind of twisted mindset. He doesn’t, and he never did. It’s just he was brought up in such an unforgiving and cruel world, that those sorts of things were the only means available to him of staying alive. Like Ash later explains to Shorter, because he’s so good looking, guys are always trying to force him to have sex with them, and he only figured that it would make it easier on him, if he took the lead when guys made passes at him like that. If he takes the lead and makes these bastards happy, he can control what’s happening to him, at least to some extent. Shorter wonders then where Ash learned to do that. Well, the answer is obviously Club Cod. Ash HAD to learn to do that to keep himself from getting killed eventually. To keep himself from getting hooked on drugs and used up and destroyed, like most of the kids that ended up in that club. You can easily imagine that many of the “patrons” of that place were violent on top of their twisted sexual perversion, because those two things often go hand in hand. A lot of them probably physically hurt the kids there, were probably extremely violent with them. And we even see that happen to Ash in Private Opinion, when Blanca finds Ash in that motel room after he’s been raped by Marvin. His hands had been tied to the bed frame, and he had bruises all over him. He’s been beaten up on top of being raped. Ash obviously had to learn to “play nice” and be seductive just to keep the physical harm he suffered to a minimum. If he could make the men molesting and raping him think he was liking it, they were probably less likely to hurt him. Like Ash even says to Shorter, the guys who rape you aren’t doing it because they want to get laid. They’re doing it because they want to hurt you and dominate you and control you. The more you struggle, the angrier they get that you aren’t submitting to their will, the more violent they then become. It’s truly horrific.
But anyway, back to the scene between Shorter and Ash after the fight with Frankie. Shorter takes Ash’s laughing and words as a sign that the kid is crazy and dangerous. He thinks Ash is laughing because Ash is a lunatic who gets his kicks killing people. It’s a misinterpretation from Shorter. It’s after this interaction with Ash that he starts worrying that Ash is Arthur’s assassin, come to kill him. Ash is confused by Shorter’s sudden anxiety around him, as we see in the scene of them at night in their cell, when Ash gets up in the middle of the night to get a drink of water. Shorter tenses up in fear, thinking Ash is going to kill him. Ash smiles at Shorter and asks why he’s so tensed up, and then jokes, asking “You think I’m gonna rape you or something?” Ash then smiles at him again and says, in the friendliest tone we’ve seen Ash use on Shorter so far “G’night Shorter.”
Shorter looks completely confused, because it just doesn’t jibe with this picture he’s formed of Ash as this cold hearted killer that’s just waiting to pounce.
We see Shorter again later in the library, still worried that Ash might be the assassin, but then he realizes that he just doesn’t get that vibe off of Ash, and doesn’t sense that he’s got anything to do with Arthur. Which of course is true, and Shorter gets his first real glimpse of who Ash actually is, when he finds him in the stacks, sitting up on a ladder and just reading. It’s the first moment Shorter realizes that Ash looks just like the angel on his Christmas card, and we start to see Shorter’s fear of Ash dissipate in that moment.
The thing is, Shorter’s perception of Ash gets skewed for a while by the fear mongering of the other inmates. Nico, who we eventually realize is working with Frankie, is the first to stir it up, to start disseminating the idea that Ash is some kind of devil or demon, and that people should be wary of him. He spreads this ridiculous story that he claims his grandmother told him about this evil woman who came to her village and drove all the men insane and eventually drove them all to kill each other. Everyone laughs at first, because it’s an absurd story and Ash is just a kid. But after what happens with Frankie the first time, Nico doubles down on his fear mongering and won’t shut up about how Ash is the devil, and how he’s evil. He’s trying to turn the other inmates against Ash, because he’s with Frankie, and Frankie is working for Arthur. And eventually, even Shorter starts to get effected by all this talk, and starts to be afraid of Ash to a paranoid degree. Eventually Shorter realizes it’s just bullshit, and Ash really IS just a kid who’s just struggling to survive, and they become friends after that, and Ash no longer seems like this cold, emotionless and frightening devil, but just a cool kid he can shoot the breeze with and really talk to. By the end, they’re real friends, sharing jokes and laughing together. It’s only at the end of Angel Eyes that both we the reader and Shorter himself finally see the real Ash. Again, just this sweet kid who’s surviving in an uncaring and brutal world.
It also tells us everything about how it is Ash became the boss of his gang on the outside. Shorter remarks how, after the fight between Ash and Frankie’s crew in the library, everyone in the prison started treating him like a “Capo”, and that it made Ash really uncomfortable. We see again here how Ash never had any desire to become a boss, or to have any power over other people. Je never had any designs to that effect. Never any schemes to take over any gangs or territory on the outside. He’s even confused when Shorter starts talking about how clever Arthur was, in trying to nip the threat of Ash in the bud, because Arthur could see that Ash was the kind of kid that would naturally draw others to him and gain followers just by being there. So he gets Ash sent to reform school and then tries to have him killed there. Ash doesn’t even know what Shorter is talking about because he never had any intention himself of becoming a gang boss. He fell into it because of his natural abilities, and when he got out of reform school, he obviously had a whole group of street kids who saw him as their leader and wanted to follow him, and it obviously just snowballed from there, with Ash taking over Arthur’s territory, etc… But again, it stands as testament to how Ash never wanted this life at all. He never cared about money, or power, or control over the street gangs. Like he eventually tells Eiji, him being exceptional wasn’t something he ever wanted, because his gifts are what led him to eventually being thrust into a life of violence and crime which he detested and never wanted.